The Penalty

New York Gods, Book 3

By: Andi Jaxon, J.R. Gray

Narrated by: Kirt Graves, Tim Paige

I've been kept away from my destiny as long as I've been alive.

I'm the bastard, banished from Manhattan, and forbidden from my dream of playing college hockey for the Gods because no one can find out about me.

But now Dad's dead, and guess who's in the will? So my dream of playing for the Gods can finally come true, but I have to find my place in my half-brother's shadow while dealing with my rival Teddy, who's been a thorn in my side since juniors.

He's cocky, infuriating, and the biggest himbo I've ever met.

Half the time, I think he hates me. But it all comes out after a drunken night, and now I can't get him out of my head.

Exile is over, and I'm here to make their lives a living hell.

©2025 Andi Jaxon (P)2025 Podium Audio

Hilarious..

This was so so funny and Teddy and Rhys are so cute.. love this book just as much as the other 2 books.
Totally recommend this book to lift your day up.

Favorite of the series

This was a really cute love story with excellent character development. Everyone should have a Teddy in their life.

Fav of the series so far!

I’ve enjoyed this entire series but this book… yea it’s the one. I laughed and I cried. The narration was also fantastic. Can’t wait for the next book to come to audio!

Soooo Sweet !! Updated From Couples

Chapter 12 The whole chapter so funny!!! Crying Funny Asf “Breedable” Rhys X Teddy . Really got to see more of the brothers & husbands engaging with each other, which just made the last book so much better.

Oh Teddy!!!! He’s precious!!

Well after Connor joining the Godfrey family I thought that he was gonna be the funny spouse/BF… then came backwards Teddy! He’s a Gem! Such a pure hearted loof!
This book was great! Rhys is the 1/2 brother of the Godfrey siblings on their dad’s side that none of them knew about. He grew up not wealthy even though his father is like a billionaire! Teddy is his best friend Toby’s older brother. Nothing bad or horrible happens in this book unlike Connor’s father in book 2. But there are some moments of surprise involving Toby. The thought process of Teddy is somewhat confusing at first but once you understand his way of thinking, (think of it as his sayings are backward) you will get it!
I must say that Oliver is slowly growing on me cause of this book!
5 stars!