In this brilliant portrait of the oceans' unlikely hero, H. Bruce Franklin shows how menhaden have shaped America's national-and natural-history, and why reckless overfishing now threatens their place in both. Since Native Americans began using menhaden as fertilizer, this amazing fish has greased the wheels of U.S. agriculture and industry. By the mid-1870s, menhaden had replaced whales as a principal source of industrial lubricant, with hundreds of ships and dozens of factories along the eastern seaboard working feverishly to produce fish oil. Since the Civil War, menhaden have provided the largest catch of any American fishery.
This is a superb book and the author, H Bruce Franklin, reads it wonderfully. The Menhaden is not just a parable for our abuse of the sea it is also a very real and pressing issue. One monopoly company is currently overfishing the Menhaden to make fishmeal and in the process destabilizing all the predators that eat it. A key fact in this is that Menhaden eat algae -- they clean the sea. Striped Bass and all the other great game fish eat Menhaden. Thus thee whole food chain of the sea and we on land need this previously unloved fish. I predict you will listen to this compulsively once you begin.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
What made the experience of listening to Most Important Fish in the Sea the most enjoyable?
great information about how overfishing one species could so greatly affect a local ecosystem which, in turn, affects the world
It took a bit of time to get used to the slow, scratchy voiced, and sometimes muffled narration, but the author is passionate and very well informed and I ended up really enjoying this book and narration.There is alot of great history presented on this little known(at least on the West Coast) fish and the tales of its abundance in earlier years is jaw dropping. Fascinating information about how long it has taken before man realized and was willing to do something to reverse the effects of overfishing. If fishing a species is going to destroy the ecosystem and deplete things to the point where we are endangering ourselves, then we can no longer "self regulate" fish catches and government(or an international fish conservancy commission) intervention is necessary.
You cannot leave it up to a corporation because their interests are short term and based on profits. It is amazing and disheartening to know that for this one species it comes down to ONE corporation! I hope the menhaden do not go the way of the passenger pigeon.
What other book might you compare Most Important Fish in the Sea to and why?
Four Fish by Paul Greenberg. Both are great books. Cod by Mike Kurlasky as well.
Which character – as performed by Bruce H. Franklin – was your favorite?
Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
I was appalled at how human thoughtlessness can devastate the balance of nature so easily. We're killing ourselves through our own selfishness. That must be Mother Nature's failsafe to keep us from irrevocably destroying the natural world. We will destroy ourselves first.
Any additional comments?
thank you Mr Franklin for writing this book.
I'm going to read this book in paperback. I couldn't get past the flipping of pages, inhale noises and other slurps of the narrator while he was reading the book. This audiobook could be done much better. Do yourself a favor and just read the book.
0 of 2 people found this review helpful
Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?
Yes. The information in this book is important for anyone who wants a better understanding of the impact humans are having on the sea. I learned a lot about how fisheries management strategies don't consider the ecosystem as a whole and the interdependence of species. The book is well set out and logically flows. There are lots of real life examples that are used to back up the research, which keeps the book interesting to listen to.
How could the performance have been better?
Unfortunately the narrator is incredibly frustrating to listen to. He tends to run words in together, to mispronounce things, and to rush quotes. The pace is unpredictable with him reading quickly at times and slowly at others. He loudly sighs and swallows throughout the book. Occasionally he puts on silly voices when quoting someone he disagrees with. It's a shame that his performance of this book got so distracting at times because the content was very interesting.