It does not take long for the noted police investigator Porfiry Petrovich, still drained from his work on the case involving the deranged student Raskolnikov, to suspect that the truth of the matter is more complex than the crime scene might suggest. Why do so many roads lead to the same house of prostitution and the same ring or pornographers? Why do so many powerful interests seem intent on blocking his efforts? His investigation leads him from the squalid tenements, brothels, and drinking dens of the city's Haymarket district to an altogether more genteel stratum of society. As he gets deeper and deeper in, and the connections between the two spheres begin to multiply, both his anger and his terror mount.
Atmospheric and tense, from its dramatic opening to its shocking climax, The Gentle Axe is a spellbinding historical crime novel, a book that explores the darkest places of the human heart with tremendous energy, empathy, and wit. As lucky as St. Petersburg residents are to have Porfiry Petrovich in public service, listeners are equally fortunate to have R.N. Morris on hand to chronicle his most challenging case to date.
"British author Morris deserves credit for a clever premise - using the deceptively stolid Porfiry Petrovich, the detective in Dostoyevski's Crime and Punishment (who helped inspire TV's Lieutenant Columbo), as the central focus of a period whodunit." (Publishers Weekly)
"Morris' heavily atmospheric thriller treads much of the same literary ground Dostoevsky covered in his great novel. The wretched and squalid lives of the poor, the philosophy of Hegel, the growing rage of the lower classes, and the Russian national character - even the Russian soul - are all important elements of the world Morris re-creates." (Booklist)
As with any plot driven novel, something is needed to set it apart from the many others of its ilk. In this case, it is the "new" Czarist Russia, circa 1865 or so. However, I personally prefer character driven books (Harry Bosh comes to mind...) and so when reading a plot driven book I need a pretty good dose of its intended "uniqueness," which does not happen that well in this case.
Lots of loooonnnggg Russian names which were troublesome to keep organized and I found myself working hard ot maintain interest at the 8 hour mark, but pushed through.
Soid narration and good plot with just enough mid 19th century Russia kept me to the end of a book that I might have given up if it took place in 1980s New York....
5 of 6 people found this review helpful