My Favorite Secret

Playing Favorites, Book 3

By: Skyla Summers

Narrated by: Lucy Rivers, Joe Arden, Lee Samuels

Felix and Tyler Blackwood are a sin I can’t stop craving. I have strict values about saving myself for marriage, but when I return from a vacation abroad, Felix and Tyler are no longer the innocent boys I grew up with and resisting them feels impossible. They’re now men, they’re gorgeous, and they’re tempting me to give in to forbidden desires.

I can hold out until we all start living together. They say I’ve always belonged to them and they’re more than willing to share me.

Before I know it, the three of us are entangled. What we’re doing is so wrong but feels too good to stop. We can keep it a secret. They’re mine and they promise me nothing will tear us apart. I want to believe them but I’m scared. Some secrets can kill. There’s one secret I know will be the death of us.

Written in multi POV, My Favorite Secret is the first book in Felix, Tyler, and Harper's duet. It is set before My Favorite Girl, contains an MFM relationship, and ends on a cliffhanger. The duet is a "second chance romance". The characters will find their happy ever after in the second book of the duet when they are in their late twenties.

For the best listening experience, it is recommended that you listen to My Favorite Girl and My Favorite Sin first to gain a deeper appreciation of the Blackwood family dynamics

©2025 Skyla Summers (P)2025 Blue Nose Publishing

Everything was intense, the love, the spice, the emotions.

The story was captivating from the beginning. The narrators brought each character to life in such a way that I felt every emotion, so much so that when Joe Arden, Felix, said to run, I was ready to run. Joe Arden never disappoints. The entire cast performed well. There were a lot of unexpected twists that I never saw coming. The spice was hot! 🌶️🌶️🌶️ The emotions between the 3 was intense. I fell in love with them. I cheered them on till the end. I cried with them.
This story ends on a cliffhanger. At this time, the next book isn’t available. I need the next book. Till then I’m left to imagine that they will all be together, forever.
Kudos to the author. These books were brilliantly written.

NEED THE NEXT BOOK

SKYLA! HE ENDING?! I need book 2 audio asap! This book is the first in the Tyler, Felix and Harper duet in the series. It had me hooked from the start and I lovedddd it! The tension, the chemistry, the LONGING 😩 I ate it up. This is a taboo romance with two brothers and their childhood best friend. It’s a MFM, friends-to-lovers, enemies-to-lovers, secret relationship romance. It’s so gooood. I loved seeing the emotional connection build between the MCs. The absolute devotion that the brothers have for Harper is so admirable 🥺. Definitely some touch her and 💀 vibes. The spice was spicingggg. Lucy, Joe and Lee were amazing!

Taboo and Spicy!

Absolutely loved hearing Harper, Felix' and Tyler's origin story. This book in angsty, heart wrenching and super spicy. The push and pull between all three of them is super hot and even though I knew it would end on a cliffhanger, it wasn't what I was expecting. Skyla keeps the intrigue going through all 11 hours and 30 minutes of this audio. Lucy, Joe and Lee are incredible as always. The emotions come out so clearly and your heart breaks for all of them. I cannot wait to hear part two!

heartfelt, intense, and impossible to let go of

This audiobook was delicious and emotional in a why-do-I-do-this-to-myself kind of way.

At the center is Harper, a sheltered, rule-following ballerina who has spent her life being exactly what everyone expects her to be. She’s grown up alongside Tyler and Felix and as they grow older, the lines between safety, desire, and longing blur and the emotional fallout is intense.

Felix is pure chaos wrapped in obsession. Tyler is his opposite; more controlled, steady, and drowning in restraint he’s terrified to lose. Harper’s connection to each of them feels distinct and the push-and-pull between all three is electric. This story thrives on yearning and jealousy and I ate it up.

Now let’s talk about the audiobook, because wow.

Lucy Rivers did an amazing job voicing all the vulnerability that Harper has throughout this book. You can hear every crack in her composure, every moment she starts realizing she wants more than the life she’s been given. Joe Arden’s portrayal of Felix is downright dangerous in the best possible way. His voice carries obsession, pain, and edge in a way that makes every scene hit that much harder. Lee Samuels gives Tyler a grounded intensity that simmers beneath the surface, and when that control starts to slip? Chills.

The performances by these three amazing voice actors elevate everything: the emotional beats cut deeper, the tension stretches tighter, and yes...the spice hits on a whole different level.

The pacing is great, the emotional payoff is brutal, and the ending… devastating. The cliffhanger lands like a punch to the chest, and even knowing it was coming didn’t soften the blow. I need book 4 NOW. Wah!!!

If you love taboo romance that’s heartfelt, intense, and impossible to let go of...especially when brought to life by an incredible narration team then My Favorite Secret is an absolute must.

Everything about this book is perfection

-I haven’t finished yet I have a couple hrs left but the 9 hours I have listened to have been pure perfection. The narrator’s are sooo amazing. The story grabbed my attention right away and has kept me hooked the entire time. The spice is everything I needed 🥵 only complaint is now I have to wait for book 2 😫