"[Hornby] has an uncanny ability for honing in on wholly contemporary, often serious topics and serving them up in truly hilarious fashion." (Booklist) "Far more than just boys will be boys, this has the right mix of hilarity and irrepressible characters to attract a wide audience: an upbeat, unqualified success." (Kirkus Reviews)
I listened to this book, but was confused when it abruptly ended. There is a spoiler ahead, so only read if you know the basic plot...
So Will meets Rachel, and lies by saying that Marcus is his son. I was waiting for the eventual confrontation when the truth came out, but somehow it never caught up with him, never came to light despite the fact that their "sons" become best friends, as do Rachel and Marcus' real mother Fiona. huh?!? I really don't think I missed anything; I listened to it straight through. I even went back through it.
Can someone explain, I know this is abridged, but could they really have cut out such a huge part of the story? Or is it really possible that it's not addressed in the book? Marcus even mentions about his real father to Rachel's son and in front of Will, and there is no astonishment or recognition from Rachel's son nor embarrassment on Will's part.
Otherwise "About a Boy" has a good reader, interesting and witty story, but like I said -- confusing, unresolved and abrupt ending, like they slapped on a "The End" three quarters through.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful
I love Nick Hornby. He's got a magical, masterful way of bringing characters to life, of making it impossible to stop reading because you are dying to find out what happens to them. In this book there are strong chords of story that make you think about the meaning of life, what love is, and other ponderables, but the writing is so fluid, the characters so vivid, and so much humor sparkles that it's not overwhelming. It's a lot of fun. Yet... quite a few times I found myself thinking that I must have accidentally clicked the jump forward button on my ipod, because there seemed to be big bites of plot missing. My suspicions were verified: this book is abridged and I didn't notice when I downloadeded it. I hate abridgements. If the author wanted the book to be shorter, he would have written less! This book has been hacked roughly with a machete-shaped editing pen. I recommend this book because Nick Hornby is really great, and the narrator does a good job too. But if you're like me you will be compelled to immediately go out and get an unabridged copy to see what's missing, so caveat emptor.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
The audio book skipped a lot of paragraphs in the actual book so if you want to read along, it's very difficult