It Seemed like a Good Idea

De: Lauren Blakely

Narrado por: Erin Mallon, J.F. Harding

Performed in duet by Erin Mallon and JF Harding! A spicy and hilarious forbidden small town rom com from #1 New York Times bestselling author Lauren Blakely!

He ghosted me once, now he’s supposed to protect me?

I don’t need a bodyguard—I run a small-town lavender farm, for bee’s sake. But when my identical twin sister lands the movie role of a lifetime that’s being shot in my hometown I get one anyway. And guess which broody, tattooed protector the studio sends to keep the paparazzi off my porch?

Last month’s almost one-night stand. The guy with the wicked mouth and heated eyes who slipped out before the fun even started. But turns out the sexy jerk is excellent at rescuing me from sneaky photographers at the market. Then the coffee shop. I’m trying hard to stay mad after the third time my new bodyguard saves me.

To top it all off, he’s staying in the cottage at my farm. With me. And there’s only one bed.

Maybe if we finally give in and finish what we started, it’ll relieve the tension? But one night quickly turns into another. Then into late-night secrets and soft confessions we shouldn’t say out loud. Especially since he’s leaving and I’m staying, and there’s no way we can be more than a summer romance that ends far too soon.

©2025 Lauren Blakely Books (P)2026 Lauren Blakely Books

The non one night stand

Some of Banks wording. The way he said sweetheart sounded a bit creepy. Some his other comments he makes were a bit cheesy

3.75 Stars ⭐️

I don’t think you can go wrong if you are looking for a quick, fun, and easy read/listen that does not require too much brain power and leaves you with a feeling of contentment. Ms. Blakely is definitely consistent.

We are taken back to the small town of Darling Springs in this romance between FMC Ripley - the owner of a Lavender Farm (yep, did not know that was a thing) and MMC Banks - the man who is assigned as her bodyguard.

See, Ripley is a twin and her twin sister Haven is an up and coming actress who is going to be filming her next movie in - you guessed it - Darling Springs. Since Ripley and Haven look exactly alike and the film is garnering quite a bit of attention, it is deemed important that Ripley have a close body protector too.

Unfortunately, the two MC’s met right before all of this was known and had an unfortunate encounter. That is the premise going forward as we watch Ripley and Banks navigate their circumstances.

As usual, I alternated between listening and reading and really enjoyed the audio version. It was narrated by Erin Mallon and J.F. Harding so I knew that they would do a wonderful job and I was not disappointed.

Good Voice Actors - Plot drags on

I'm 68% through this book and considering DNF'ing it. The plot is good, but it's dragging. I feel like the MCs are creating issues out of non-issues. The characters are nice. The writing is okay. I'm not sure where the author is trying to go for the ending.

Sweet and Swooney

It Seemed Like a Good Idea is definitely a good time.

With a wonderful pairing of small town charm with big screen shenanigans, swoon worthy action with frolicking in the lavender fields and palpable chemistry, Ripley and Banks just had it all. Full of humor, heat and heart, this is a feel good, fun and playful story with a side of spice and suspense.
Last but not least is the wonderful performance from narrators Erin Mallon and JF Harding - that managed to bring life into these characters, creating an all around wonderful experience. I can't wait for more from Darling Springs!

4 stars and an origami animal

Small Town Romance

I really do like a small town romance. It’s simple, sweet and plenty of loyalty. Banks might have lived in a major city, but he adapted well in Darling Springs on his work assignment. Being a close protection officer is his dream job but little did he know he’d find his dream girl as well. Ripley is the owner of a lavender farm which is about to host a movie crew for the shoots duration. Being the stars twin sister, the production company feels Ripley is going to need a CPO to protect her from the paparazzi and the like. Was she happy she had a shadow, no! Did she try and ditch him at every opportunity, yes! Did she succeed, again no but it was funny her trying.

Banks and Ripley made for a great couple, they attempted to stay away from each other but sharing a cabin with one bed will test the best of us. I liked when they let go and behind closed doors could just be themselves together. I adored how much Banks would do things for Ripley as she is always doing something for others and it was nice to see someone look after her too. Of course with any LB novel there’s always an adorable dog in the mix and Hudson was cute as.

I was happy with all the outcomes with the story. This might be a little tamer in spice for a LB novel but I was on board with it as less is more imo. There’s a bonus scene link at the end, don’t miss that as it’s very special indeed. And if you get the opportunity grab the audio book as these narrators did a fabulous job with these characters. I really loved listening as I read along and JF Harding is so easy to love. His voice is hypnotic and very swoony.