The Girl on the Train

By: Paula Hawkins

Narrated by: Clare Corbett, Louise Brealey, India Fisher

Length: 10 hrs and 58 mins

Publisher's Summary

Audie Award, Audiobook of the Year, 2016

Rachel takes the same commuter train every morning. Every day she rattles down the track, flashes past a stretch of cozy suburban homes, and stops at the signal that allows her to daily watch the same couple breakfasting on their deck. She’s even started to feel like she knows them. "Jess and Jason," she calls them. Their life—as she sees it—is perfect. Not unlike the life she recently lost.

And then she sees something shocking. It’s only a minute until the train moves on, but it’s enough. Now everything’s changed. Unable to keep it to herself, Rachel offers what she knows to the police, and becomes inextricably entwined in what happens next, as well as in the lives of everyone involved. Has she done more harm than good?

Compulsively readable, The Girl on the Train is an emotionally immersive, Hitchcockian thriller and an electrifying debut.

©2014 Paula Hawkins (P)2014 Penguin Audio

Critic Reviews

"Top-notch narration makes this perfect for audio." (AudioFile)

A festival of personality disorders

What would have made The Girl on the Train better?

The one standout criticism I have about this book is that I was not enticed by the author to care enough about the characters to be truly drawn in to the tale.

While I am not one to expect my protagonists to be perfect, nor every story to have a happy ending, none of the characters were genuinely likable at all. It was like a festival of personality disorders, self-centeredness and pathetic weaknesses.

You start out feeling for the main character, sympathetic to her plight and hoping for sobriety to take hold, but it all goes to hell in a hand basket when every single flawed character behaves badly and you, unfortunately, end up caring less and less about them as the book goes on. I finished it out of a sense of duty, not desire.

This is coming from a reader who LOVES Dexter Morgan -but why do I love a serial killer and loathe a struggling British divorcee with a drinking problem? Because, in Dexter's case, the author has seduced me with his back story, his vow to live by his "code", and then throws villains into the mix who are revealed as far worse monsters than Dexter who deserve whatever special treatment he has in store for them.

I make this comparison for the sake of stressing character development and trajectory. I just didn't really feel I was given enough reason to empathize with these people and their loathsome troubles.

218 of 254 people found this review helpful

The Girl on The Train

Any additional comments?

There are literally thousands of reviews of this book on Amazon and Goodreads. So … if you need synopsis of detail, you’ll have no trouble finding. Reviews are from 1 to 5 stars, opinions are varied.

With regard to the audiobook … The Girl on the Train is narrated by several female readers, which is fine … but, they basically sound alike … they all emote a lot. All are British (British author).

All of the characters are so into their own self analyzing angst, including the supposed victim of a crime … it’s maddening. The lead character, Rachael, is a ridiculously self absorbed alcoholic who has memory black-outs, witnesses what she believes is wrong do-ing, and is obsessed with her ex-husband. Convoluted, I know ... just like the story. But, that’s the basics. In my opinion, the story should have been several hours (pages) shorter.

Frankly, the fact that this story is a mega-hit and has hogged the best-seller list for months and months is beyond me, but it’s the reason I finally succumbed. Maybe it’s just clever marketing … but The Girl on the Train has created an amazing, albeit completely puzzling, buzz.

Guess I’m not into drunks. Or, adolescent angst from supposedly mature people. Maybe I’m old. Yeah, that’s it. Must be it. Anyway …. not my cup ‘o tea, ’t all. Not recommended.

621 of 728 people found this review helpful

I am the only person I know who hated this book…

So, you can take this review with a grain of salt. I don't know exactly why I hated it, but it seems like one of those "Girl" books that you are supposed to love. It's about people who should know better doing stupid things to other people or with other people, and bad things happening as a result. I finished it, but I honestly couldn't wait for to be done. So, I can say that much for it: I have stopped really bad books in the past, and this book was not that bad. In fact, I can see that it was actually very well written. It's just that the story and the characters were too awful to contemplate.

345 of 409 people found this review helpful

I Don't Like Any of These People

Relationships are, what I think this book is about.After listening to 26 of its 133 chapters, I couldn't tell you. What I am sure of is that the people in these relationships are reeeeeeely unlikable. Look, I try to give an author plenty of rope, even listening to stinko stories to their end in hopes of retrieving some value for time already invested. But not this one. A question though: why are there three readers? I can't tell them apart, so why three? Did each reader grow bored as me and need replacing from time to time? Which explains why they hired women with identical voices, huh?

Or maybe there was only one reader in the first 26 chapters and others will appear if I just stay on the train? Nope, the car's are too filled with the kind of drooling, mumbling, rumpled creatures with whom you damn well try NOT to make conscious contact.

Perhaps somewhere in chapter 27 or 30 or 60, Paula Hawkins reveals just where this train's going. It was sold as a mystery, maybe even a murder tale. Well, perhaps someone will write a long spoiler in the reviews so I'll know. It was also sold as "fast-paced!" Huh? Turtles pace quicker than Hawkins. Engine grease pours faster.

Okay, the problem's mine. The reviews and sales of "The Girl On the Train" are powerful. I wanted to like it. Didn't happen and shall return it. Yawn...

165 of 199 people found this review helpful

Could not wait to finish..

....And be done with this story
Very rarely does a hot popular book flop so unconditionally with me, but I literally found absolutely no redeeming value in this book. From sappy boring narration to a painfully cliche' and sophomoric dialogue, I don't even see how "young adults" could find this story interesting.
Don't waste your time or credit!! PASS!

217 of 263 people found this review helpful

I hated this book!

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

No, but that was not the fault of the narrator. I just really didn't feel this story was ground breaking. Also, I felt the main character was a waste - I felt no empathy for her. I felt no connection to her. I basically had no interest in her which made investing in the story a little difficult.

What was your reaction to the ending? (No spoilers please!)

I found it very predictable.

Which character – as performed by the narrators – was your favorite?

Dr. Kamal Abdic

Did The Girl on the Train inspire you to do anything?

Yes, it inspired me to tell others not to bother reading it.

12 of 14 people found this review helpful

Such a gratingly over-emoting narrator

Would you try another book from Paula Hawkins and/or the narrators?

Maybe another book by this author, but NEVER this narrator (the one voicing the main character Rachel).

What was the most interesting aspect of this story? The least interesting?

The most interesting was the depth (partly admirable, partly evil) of some of the lesser characters, primarily Tom and Anna.

Would you be willing to try another one of the narrators’s performances?

No

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

Yes. Without the consistently breathless, desperate-sounding narration, it was interesting enough to be quite intriguing.

Any additional comments?

I enjoyed having the murder be over and done with by the time we began hearing chapters told from the point of view of the victim; that was quite creative.

7 of 8 people found this review helpful

"Rear Window" Meets "Gone Girl"

This book was on my "must listen" list because I actually take the 8AM train into work each day. Like "Rear Window", I can easily imagine looking into the windows and backyards while imagining what kind of life the occupants lead.

Three characters tell this story from their viewpoint. I am so glad that Audible chose three different narrators for Rachel, Anne and Meghan. It made this story much easier to follow when each scene changed. Like "Good Girl" none of these characters are candidates for citizen of the year. In addition, can you rely on their viewpoint? Rachel's life is a drunken shambles, Anne is the "other woman" and Meghan goes missing and we are not sure why.

This is a twisty, well plotted mystery that will keep you riveted and guessing to the very end. Occasionally, I listened to a chapter again and continued to make links with other information I learned. Listen carefully and you will be rewarded. This book will be a huge success. Enjoy!

302 of 384 people found this review helpful

On Track

From the onslaught of pre-release reviews for this book I was very prepared for the *unreliable narrator,* that tricky little beastie that requires the reader to stay on their toes, but, when our girl Rachel settles onto the train and pops her canned gin and tonic for breakfast, I knew we were in for one helluva ride. In what has been called an *amnesia thriller,* been compared to Hitchcock's Rear Window, and tacked with the ubiquitous "the next Gone Girl" tagline (when will that stop?) author Hawkins gives us one of those always entertaining train-ride thrillers told from the pov of 3 female narrators -- one of whoms story is ala Mary Alice Young in Desperate Housewives, from the grave. Their connection...a man, a neighborhood, and a fateful event.

Not much should be said about the story because it relies heavily on slowly revealing a little more with each clickety-clak of the rails. I'd suggest just settling in and riding along as sad, overweight, unemployed, newly divorced, and barren Rachel rides the train and peers into a certain yard/window of a house that borders the tracks along her journey. Looking out the window of the train at that house, she projects everything she wished for onto a certain willowy blonde she names *Jess,* and her husband. Rachel used to live in the same neighborhood -- now her ex lives in the home with his new wife and baby girl.

Hawkins dishes out the information with a controlling hand, and might rely a little too much on this tactic to keep a sense of tension when more information, fleshing out the characters a little more, could have given the story more psychological depth -- she certainly has created characters with the underpinnings of a great psychological thriller and shows talent as a writer. Maybe I've seen too much Hitchcock, read too many Flynn novels; I didn't find the story really thrilling or mysterious, but that's OK -- it was fun and entertaining, and I flew through it enjoying every minute. I have to say it is a much lighter read than that GG novel (except for the issue of alcoholism, which is especially dark here).

The narrators did a good job keeping the novel moving and interpreting the characters and make this all the more enticing.

329 of 420 people found this review helpful

Don't Compare, Just Enjoy

Whenever I read, "this is the next best thing" I set the threshold for quality high. Whenever I see, "the next Gone Girl" I set my expectations even higher. This is not fair to us as readers nor both of the authors. If Paula Hawkins' book doesn't blow you away, then her reputation is sullied and if the next book by Gillian Flynn doesn't surpass "Gone Girl" then she's weak. Weighty expectations are unfair and produce resentment all around. Enough of my rant about marketing.

This book is good on it's own merit and the only parallel to "Gone Girl" is the missing girl scenario. What makes this tale different and fun is the unreliable narrator, Rachel; neither blonde, sleek, beautiful nor sophisticated. She's a hot mess, literally stumbling in a drunken stupor from one cringe-worthy situation to the next. The recently sacked redhead squeezes her pudgy bum into the train seat each day riding her old rail line to spy on her old home now shared by her ex and his new pretty wife & baby. Along the way she invents names and stories for different houses and people, crossing the line between make-believe and reality only to lead us on a haphazard goose chase to find out where in the world is Meghan.

Read this quirky, odd, humorous, sad, awkwardly embarrassing, and utterly redeemable new novel.

182 of 234 people found this review helpful