Elizabeth I and Her Circle

By: Susan Doran

Narrated by: Joanna Daniel

Length: 14 hrs and 33 mins

Publisher's summary

This is the story of Elizabeth I's inner circle and the crucial human relationships which lay at the heart of her personal and political life. Using a wide range of original sources - including private letters, portraits, verse, drama, and state papers - Susan Doran provides a vivid and often dramatic account of political life in Elizabethan England and the queen at its center. Doran offers a deeper insight into Elizabeth's emotional and political conduct, and challenges many of the popular myths that have grown up around her.

It is a story replete with fascinating questions. What was the true nature of Elizabeth's relationship with her father, Henry VIII - especially after his execution of her mother? How close was she to her half-brother Edward VI - and were relations with her half-sister Mary really as poisonous as is popularly assumed? And what of her relationship with her Stewart cousins, most famously with Mary Queen of Scots, executed on Elizabeth's orders in 1587, but also with Mary's son James VI of Scotland, later to succeed Elizabeth as her chosen successor?

Elizabeth's relations with her family were crucial, but just as crucial were her relations with her courtiers and her councilors. Here again, the story raises a host of fascinating questions. Was the queen really sexually jealous of her maids of honor? Did physically attractive male favorites dominate her court? What does her long and intimate relationship with the Earl of Leicester reveal about her character, personality, and attitude to marriage? What can the fall of Essex tell us about Elizabeth's political management in the final years of her reign? And what was the true nature of her personal and political relationship with influential and long-serving councilors such as the Cecils and Sir Francis Walsingham? And how did courtiers and councilors deal with their demanding royal mistress?

©2015 Susan Doran (P)2015 Audible, Inc.

Do a little studying before this book.

This book is fairly involved in the running of ER's administration and I found knowing all the players on the board brought a depth of understanding that helped me enjoy the book more.
The narrator did a good job and did not detract from the story. The author had a lot to convey to the reader and did this very well without being too wordy or overly florid.
The thing I liked the most about this book was that it humanized Elizabeth and made me ponder this central question. Was Elizabeth's greatness from her or from the incredibly talented men surrounding her.....or both?

Not Much new Here for Tudor Afficiandos

I didn't learn much new from this book, but it was a good review of who was who and what went on at court. I especially liked the structure of the book. It is divided into three parts: Kin, Courtiers, and Councillors, and each section is divided into chapters focused on small groups or specific persons. "Kin" has chapter on Parents & Siblings, The Suffolk Cousins, Mary Queen of Scots, and James VI of Scotland (her eventual heir to the English throne). Three favorites are the chapter subjects of "Courtiers": Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester; Sir Christopher Hatton; and Robert Devereux, Earl of Essex. The section has an additional chapter on the noblewomen who served as ladies in waiting to the queen. Part Three, "Councillors," includes chapters on William Cecil, Lord Burghley; Sir Francis Walsingham; and Burghley's son, Robert Cecil. In the course of the book, relationships between the various subjects and Elizabeth are analyzed and important events (the succession, Elizabeth's "marriage game," the Spanish Armada, the Dutch wars, religious dissent, etc.) are discussed in detail. In short, it's a nice primer or reference book on Elizabeth's reign.

Very detailed and enjoyable

The author takes a fresh look at this well studied chapter in English history. She focuses on the relationships of the various people within EI's sphere and tells each person's story through the prism of the relationship. It's a very interesting approach. She points out how a courtier had different boundaries than a Privy Councilman and argues that this forced them to use different tactics when trying to gain influence.

Unfortunately, organizing the book as sequential biographies leads to jumping around in time and main charachters from one chapter showing up as minor actors in another. This confusion is compounded by the English historical tendency for people to change names and titles several times during the course of their lives.

She jumps right into the people and events of the 16th century so you must have some familiarity with the Tudor period to avoid being overwhelmed by relations and namesakes.

I found it very enjoyable, if a little dry.

Note to editor

Any additional comments?

In an audible book, it is unnecessary - worse, it's a distraction - to have the reader recite "old English" phrases and then re-state the same word in modern English. This is fine for a printed book, where the difference in how the words are written may be of interest, but it doesn't work for an audible presentation and whomever produced this book should eliminate this type of thing in the future.

Advanced Elizabethan Writing

The cadences of Elizabethan writing are very much different from our writing today. The author includes many significant quotes from the sources upon which she bases her characterizations. The author included enough hints so we can understand the language of the times and the reader reads them well. It's a more sober assessment of Elizabeth's reign than the torrid love of the florid cougar, etc. Reality is always refreshing and I'm glad I was able to hear actual words from the time period.

Elizabeth I and Her Circle

The narration of this audio book absolutely ruined the listening experience. I can't imagine why the author or publisher would sign off on Joanna Daniel's narration - it is so sing-songy (for lack of a better
description) throughout the entire book that I'm unable to listen to it for more than a couple of minutes. I was looking forward to this book as Elizabeth is an ancestor of mine. Will purchase printed version as book actually full of interesting information and I respect what was most likely a massive amount of research that Ms Doran spent on this work. However, due to it's presentation, it was a total waste of Audible choice; I will avoid any Audible books narrated by Ms Daniel; really horrible!