Imagine watching your child walk to the store and never returning. This is the harrowing reality for Carrie Greenhill, whose six-year-old daughter, Sheree Beasley, vanished on a warm afternoon in Rosebud, Melbourne, in June 1991. We recount the frantic search efforts by police, volunteers, and the local community, all racing against time to find Sherry. As the town grappled with fear and uncertainty, a young boy's report of seeing Sherry being forced into a blue car became a critical lead, breathing new life into the investigation.

Join us as we examine the gripping trial of Robert Arthur Selby Lowe, a church elder charged with Sherry's murder, kidnapping, and false imprisonment. Hear the compelling courtroom testimonies, including those from a boy who witnessed Sherry's abduction and individuals who saw a distressed girl in a blue car. Lowe's estranged wife, Lorraine, offers a chilling glimpse into his dark obsessions, while damning evidence, such as a tape-recorded confession, exposes his shifting narratives. Listen in as we piece together this intricate puzzle of a community shattered by a tragic crime.

Support the Show.

Could the unraveling of a decades-old mystery lie within the faded paint of a red pickup truck? We're piecing together the chilling puzzle of Morgan Chontelnik's 1995 disappearance, an unsolved tragedy that still echoes through the streets of Alma, Arkansas. This haunting episode takes you back to a fateful Little League game where six-year-old Morgan was last seen alive, chasing lightning bugs before vanishing without a trace. Feel the palpable tension as we recount eyewitness accounts of an eerie stranger and explore the disturbing links to other local abduction attempts.

Join us as we examine the life of Billy Jack Lynx, a figure whose shadow looms large over this case. Our probing investigation reveals his sinister past and how his actions may be intertwined with Morgan's fate. We scrutinize the recent forensic findings from Lynx's own vehicle, where traces of blood, hair, and fibers offer silent testimony to the dark secrets it may hold. This episode is not just a recount of events; it's an urgent call to arms for anyone who might hold the key to finally bringing justice to Morgan and solace to a community that has long awaited answers.

Support the Show.

When family ties are shattered by a heinous act, we are left grappling with a mix of sorrow, disbelief, and a quest for understanding. Our journey through the harrowing case of Sonny Kim, a teenager who succumbed to his darkest impulses, murdering his sister Ashley, exposes a wound that lies at the intersection of mental health and criminal justice. With the measured guidance of forensic psychologist Dr. Ellison Paganelli, we delve into the psyche of a troubled youth battling Asperger's and schizotypal disorders, whose initial intent to annihilate his family and himself was abruptly halted by his own unraveling mind.

The sentence handed down to Sonny—a life behind bars with the prospect of parole in three decades, conditional on receiving consistent mental health treatment—forces us to consider the fabric of our societal responses to such tragedies. We navigate the complexities of a family torn apart by violence, as they contend with grief and the haunting questions that linger. Dr. Paganelli helps unravel the psychological threads that led to the fatal night, while we confront the broader implications of Sonny's actions and the influence of mental illness on individual behavior. This episode is a profound exploration of the human condition, the depths of familial love, and the painstaking road to accountability and possible redemption.

Support the Show.