The Weimar Years

Rise and Fall 1918–1933

De: Frank McDonough

Narrado por: Paul McGann

Bloomsbury presents The Weimar Years by Frank McDonough, read by Paul McGann.

A DAILY MAIL BOOK OF THE WEEK
A SPECTATOR BOOK OF THE YEAR
A DAILY TELEGRAPH BEST HISTORY BOOK OF 2023
ASPECTS OF HISTORY BOOKS OF THE YEAR
A GUARDIAN BOOK OF THE YEAR 2023
A DAILY MAIL BEST CHRISTMAS BOOK OF 2023

Established in 1918–19, in the wake of Germany’s catastrophic defeat in the First World War and the revolution that followed swiftly on its heels, the Weimar Republic ushered in widespread social reform, a radical cultural flowering and the most democratic conditions the German people had ever known.

At its beginning, Weimar held out the hope that democracy, stability and prosperity would take root in Germany, but it was beset by frequent changes of government, waves of economic upheaval and spasms of violence of increasing intensity between the forces of left and right. Agitation and assassination by rightwing nationalists – enraged by the severity of the Treaty of Versailles and the acceptance of its terms by liberal German politicians – formed a threatening descant to the conciliatory efforts of successive coalition governments. Ultimately, the instabilities of Weimar would lead to the appointment as German Chancellor of the Nazi Fu¨hrer Adolf Hitler, who created a one-party dictatorship that abandoned the rule of law, democracy and civil rights. In the words of Gustav Stresemann, Germany’s Nobel Peace Prize-winning Foreign Minister from 1923 to 1929, Weimar democracy was ‘dancing on a volcano’.

The Weimar Years is a vivid and compelling narrative of a dramatic period in German history. Year by year, from 1918 to 1933, Frank McDonough covers the major events in both domestic and foreign policy and the personalities who shaped them, together with developments in music, art, theatre and literature. McDonough places particular focus on the parliamentary history of Weimar, arguing that it was the failure of parliamentary democracy to bring stability that eroded public confidence and allowed the power of the elected Reichstag to gradually diminish, culminating in Hitler’s accession to power in January 1933.

The Weimar Years is the tragic story of a rise and fall, as well as a warning of how, under poor leadership, economic pressure and unrelenting political volatility, a democracy can drift towards a form of authoritarian rule that eventually destroys it.©2023 Frank McDonough (P)2023 Bloomsbury Publishing Plc.

A thorough explanation of the Weimar republic

My review truly has nothing to do with the book rather the audio. I must’ve hit rewind no less than 100 times because the voice of the narrator, trailed off to such a low volume at the end of so many sentences that it negatively impacted from the experience.

Brilliant dissection of the road to Hitler’s rise to power.

What an extraordinary listening experience ! What a cautionary tale! How little I knew about the Weimar years in Germany. Thanks to listening to this tour de force of historical analysis, I understand the past and the present a million times better - how mistakes made by so many leaders between 1917 and 1933 paved the path inexorably to A Second World War in which more than 40 million people died in the European theatre of war. Leaders matter! Hindenburg, according to the author, was the primary cause of the collapse of the democratic government of the Weimar Republic, and the ascension of Hitler as Chancellor on January 30, 1933. I had never understood how rational, good people voted for Hitler in democratic elections. After reading this book, I understand how this was possible, how the choices people make lead to their own tragic downfall, and to ruin and destruction for all.

Great subject, too many confusing political party names

Mostly about the many political parties with similar names, some about the culture and economics.

The details

Loved this book. Very detailed, but doesn’t get lost in the weeds. A very relevant book.

An excellent history of the time period

This is a very detailed, systematic study of the Weimar Era. I really enjoyed the fact that it was divided by years instead of themes.
I wish I could give it a sixth star for its analysis of my favorite movie (Metropolis).
As an added bonus, Paul McGann’s narration is superb. His pronunciation of the various German words and phrases is flawless and unfaltering. Often when narrators come to foreign text in a book, they pause briefly or seem to stumble; not so with Paul McGann.
I definitely recommend The Weimar Years to anyone interested in either the time period or history in general.

Wonderful narrative, underpinned by a good range of primary and secondary sources, as well as electoral data.

Well narrated, compelling thesis, definitely a great guide to the political history of the Weimar republic

Amazing listen

Author explains the Weimar republic very well, with detailed history of every year, significant personalities and elections. The author never gives too many names, like some history book authors do, to the point it being impossible to recall any, but gives just enough so that you know all important people and organizations by the time you finish the book. The narrator's voice is clear and pleasant to listen to. Overall, a very good account of this significant period of German history.

Excellent history with some audiobook issues

This is a difficult book for me to rate. On one hand there is more detail than seems needed in some parts of the book. For example the author gives us the names of all of the cabinet members in all of the multiple governments formed during the Weimar Republic when most of those people are relatively obscure now and there are no details of much of what they did wen they were in office. For another many of the political parties, mentioned by their initials, sound exactly the same in the audio book so it is very difficult to know whether the author is referring to the DDP or the DVP and with 10 or 12 or more political parties being discussed it is very hard to keep track of which party is left, right or center.. And as a third issue the narrator sometimes breathes into the microphone so loudly that it is difficult to concentrate of what he is saying.

On the other hand the information about is happening year to year is so well presented that it makes the reasons for the tragedy of the Weimar Republic's failure clear and understandable. In fact it clarified for me the reasons that the British and French stood by during the early Hitler years without taking actions that probably would have prevented World War II. While I was familiar with what happened during the period from 1933 to the start of World War II I was always puzzled by the lack of reaction from the British and French toward Germany during those years and this book make those years of inaction more understandable.

Given how much this book helped me understand the crisis years leading to World War II I can not help but give the book itself 5 stars in spite of the issues with this audiobook version. If you are interested in why and how the world stumbled into World War II when it could easily have been avoided by actions on the part of t he French this book will help you understand.

Many Questions Answered

Should be required reading today as our own democracy comes under threat. Exactly how a democratic experiment devolved into Adolf Hitler. Many differences from our situation today, but also many similarities and scary parallels. I highly recommend this book.

Excellent overview

Changed a lot of preconceptions I had about Weimar. A little light on cultural matters, but the detail and analysis of the constantly changing political environment well outweighs that minor quibble.