Rethinking Thin

The New Science of Weight Loss - And the Myths and Realities of Dieting

By: Gina Kolata

Narrated by: Ellen Archer

In this eye-opening audiobook, New York Times science writer Gina Kolata shows that our society's obsession with dieting and weight loss is less about keeping trim and staying healthy than about money, power, trends, and impossible ideals.

Rethinking Thin is at once an account of the place of diets in American society and a provocative critique of the weight-loss industry. Kolata's account of four determined dieters' progress through a study comparing the Atkins diet to a conventional low-calorie one becomes a broad tale of science and society, of social mores and social sanctions, and of politics and power.

Rethinking Thin asks whether words like willpower are really applicable when it comes to eating and body weight. It dramatizes what it feels like to spend a lifetime struggling with one's weight and fantasizing about finally getting thin. It tells the little-known story of the science of obesity and the history of diets and dieting: scientific and social phenomena that have made some people rich and thin and left others fat and miserable. And it offers commonsense answers to questions about weight, eating habits, and obesity, giving us a better understanding of the weight that is right for our bodies.

©2007 Gina Kolata (P)2007 Tantor Media Inc.

Critic reviews

"Kolata may be the best writer around covering the science of health...This book will change your thinking about weight, whether you struggle with it or not." ( Publishers Weekly)

very interesting

I feel i gained a new way to think about my weight. Well read and I might even listen to it again.

The Book You Want Others to Read

This is the book you wish others would read, but it may be bad for you to read it yourself. This is the definition of a dangerous meme. So, although I recommend this book, you’ve been warned; I gained 10 pounds because of reading it.

The book includes a lot of history on western thinking about how to lose weight. The separation caused by time makes the silliness these ideas rather apparent. The book also includes summaries of a lot of scientific evaluation of these ideas.

So the science is clear, all the common wisdom about weight loss is wrong. Usually extremely wrong! For example, changing how much you eat (within large limits) has a truly minuscule affect on your weight. The body regulates its energy usage based on how much food you find for it in order to satisfy its own idea about how much fat it needs. From an evolutionary perspective this is as it must be. But the implication is that if you eat 20% less everyday you don’t get 20% thinner, more likely you lose 0.2% of your body weight. And if you diet to lose weight, but don’t change the body’s idea of how much fat it needs, over time you’ll gain it all back. What the body thinks it needs, it eventually figures out how to get.

So can you change the body’s idea of how much fat it needs? Yes, because people do it; these are the only people who “keep the weight off”. But no one knows how it’s done. The science shows most things that people claim have this affect, don’t work for most people (but might work for the people making the claim).

The book stops here, and left me with an intense desire to give up.

My own theory is that the body’s internal fat goal has an epigenetic control. Things you do either deliberately or as a side effect of life change your epigenetics, resulting in semi-permanent changes to your body’s fat goals. It is believed that the kinds of things that cause epigenetic changes are mostly semi-traumatic. There are two problems: 1) the kind of intervention that results in such a change may be rather dependent on the environment and 2) the necessary changes for a desired outcome may depend rather strongly on your existing epigenetics; that is, they are highly individualistic.

So the intervention that works for you is unlikely to work for someone else and vice versa.

Not a diet book but a NON diet book

This book is the best book I have ever listened to about diets and science. The book goes into detail about the modern myths and how little science knows about trying to loose weight. How many of the popular diets came about is shocking and how little science has gone into them. It is a must read because you learn it is lifestyle not BMI that determines your quality of life. BRAVO!!

The truth on being fat in our society.<br />

Gina Kolata has done all the research necessary to answer the question do diets work? Reviewing study after study, and conclusion after conclusion she makes a very good case for why diets only work on a temporary basis. That it is false hope that keeps us trying in spite of the evidence of a lifetime of being heavy. That everyone has a set weight and it has more to do with the weight of your parents than how careful you are or how motivated you are to lose weight. For those of us who have struggled for years this book validates our reality. It also offers hope as Scientists continue to work on a biological solution to the brain's set point determined by genetics.
This is a book that is surprisingly easy to listen to because of the author's style and the narrator's gift and pleasant voice.

Life changing

The information in this book is absolutely essential to all humans suffering with weight problems. Ms Kolata's book explains the new findings in the scientific field, without ever being boring. In fact, the book can be listened to, almost as if it were a novel, as the listener follows the story of the people participating in a weight loss study and also when she masterfully narrates the countless attempts and experiences implemented over the centuries to fight this ILLNESS. All this with the pleasing colloquial tone of Ellen Archer.
This book has really changed the way I see my weight problem and how to fight it. In a nutshell, it gives you a real dimension of your ENEMY'S SIZE.