I couldn't possibly disagree the previous reviewer more. I think that the narration was outstanding and that this was a great buy. More than just a telling of the story of the burning of Atlanta, it is much more comprehensive, relating the history of Atlanta and the background of the main characters. I enjoyed this very much and would highly recommend it.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
I wish he would narrate more Civil War books. His feel for the regional accents, cadences, and attitudes is clearly well-defined and also relished.
Wortman tells the story behind the story of Sherman's battle for the heart of the Confederacy—Atlanta. Personal experiences characterize the telling so the reader has intimate relations with Yankees, Rebs, shop keepers, slaves, news media, government officials, generals and artillery captains. The scenes are vivid and the drama tense. Wortman is a master.
I was disappointed in the narrator who attempted to depict the southerners' accent and sense of anger or outrage. Not helpful.
As an avid reader and listener of many books covering the War Between the States, I looked forward to a long highway drive from Boston to Atlanta as a chance to listen to this book. The reader, unfortunately, was so distracting and irritating in his presentation and over dramatization of the book that I finally gave up half way through and switched to another selection. I am a long time customer and have never had this happen before. This reader is flat out annoying. A waste of money to me as I will have to buy the book to read after having spent money to listen to it.
2 of 4 people found this review helpful