On a country property a man named Holland lives with his daughter Ellen. Over the years, as she grows into a beautiful young woman, he plants hundreds of different gum trees on his land. When Ellen is nineteen her father announces his decision: she will marry the man who can name all the species of eucalypt, down to the last tree. Suitors emerge from all corners, including the formidable, straight-backed Mr Cave, world expert on the varieties of eucalypt. And then, walking among her father’s trees, Ellen chances on a strange young man who in the days that follow tells her dozens of stories set in cities, deserts, faraway countries....
Haunting and mesmerising, Eucalyptus illuminates the nature of storytelling itself.
Any additional comments?
After ploughing through the first 4 Chapters, I realised that the even the best Voiceover Actor in the business (Humphrey Bower) couldn't save this book.
It was slow moving and boring in the extreme. Indeed, it felt like attending a schoolboy lecture in botany.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Very unusual story. There was not a huge plot ... Just beautiful writing that meanders till the end. I will be looking for more from this author... And the narrator was perfect.
One is discombobulated until the very end, when palpably relieved by the revelation of some prior prestidigitation.
What made the experience of listening to Eucalyptus the most enjoyable?
The lyrical, poetic and very Australian story has a magic to it. It is layered with stories that gently unfold and tell about the history of people and eucalypts.
There is a reverence for beauty and no nonsense truth.
What would have made Eucalyptus better?
A less dispassionate narrator; one who puts more expression and feeling into the work.
How did the narrator detract from the book?
He read too slowly, and there was very little expression in his voice. It was delivered in a flat, unemotional style. This was not engaging and I quickly lost interest in the story.
You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?
Eucalyptus has an intriguing plot and I liked learning about all the different types of gum trees. I didn't like the way the female character seemed to be helplessly under the spell of the male character, and the endless stories he told seemed to have little to do with each other or anything in the novel. It was a bit like watching one unrelated youtube clip after another, and having your brain fill up with meaningless images. Perhaps this was partly because of the way it was narrated.
Any additional comments?
The narrator is also a respected theatre actor and director, and perhaps in this context he is very good at what he does. In this audiobook, however, and in others that I've listened to samples of, he does not have a captivating voice, nor does he give life to the stories he tells. A very disappointing experience.
0 of 2 people found this review helpful
Would you try another book written by Murray Bail or narrated by Humphrey Bower?
A disappointing buy on my behalf. Just couldn't get into it.
If you’ve listened to books by Murray Bail before, how does this one compare?
First time I have listened
Would you listen to another book narrated by Humphrey Bower?
What character would you cut from Eucalyptus?
None, just not my style