Forced by the Reverend tells about the erotic escapades of Reverend White and church members Lindsey and Millie. The reverend has always had a thing for these two 18-year-old beautiful women. Although he is a devout man of the community, he still has sexual urges and fantasies of his own. His thoughts have always bordered on the taboo side. The two women have always thought the reverend was cute and would often fantasize about being entered by him. After being dropped off by her mom, Lindsey walks in the church and is quickly taken a willing sex slave. Soon she finds that she is not alone, but also her best friend, Millie, is there. They soon discover who the mysterious handsome man is and are overcome with sexual passion and love.