The Cement Garden

De: Ian McEwan

Narrado por: Steven Crossley

One of the world's most acclaimed novelists, New York Times best-selling author Ian McEwan has earned the Booker Prize and the National Book Critics Circle Award. After their parents die, four children are left alone in the family house. They are free to live however they choose, but they must preserve their terrible secret.©1996 Ian McEwan (P)2003 Recorded Books, LLC

Reseñas de la Crítica

"A shocking book, morbid, full of repellant imagery, and irresistibly readable." (The New York Review of Books)
"Darkly impressive." (The Times)

an uncomfortable and painful story

I found this book uncomfortable, disquieting and painful -- and that is exactly how a reader of this book should feel. The topic of this one is agonizing. And it should be. I see that many reviewers didn't enjoy it, but I did. If a writer creates characters that inspire my empathy and compassion then I will always feel connected to the book.

This book is about four kids -- siblings who range in ages of 6 to 17. The problem is there relationships are marked by incest, which the reader encounters on page 2! They have faced the deaths of both their parents, and decided to bury her in the cellar so that they could stay together. They believed they could hide the fact that they were living together without any guardians.

The missing element here for me is backstory. I wanted to know more about the parents of these kids and how they were interacting with each other. I wanted to know why this family became what it did.

Oof

This book is disturbing as all hell. Great story. Great sense of disturbance.
The narrator was hard to get past at times. Every time he read dialogue it was quite over dramatic and silly, otherwise he did well.
Highly recommend but not for the faint of heart.

The concrete garden

The story is poor, the characters are flat and it’s predictable. It might the time the story was written.

Disappointing

Beware of Spoiler: Shocking ending. For me there was little redeeming value. The kids were really suffering, and the end result was incest? Shock value. It could have been ... well it’s his story to tell. But. Cheap ending I thought.

Really diabolical

This was pretty odd and uncomfortable and didn’t resolve anything other than make the reader feel dumb for investing 4 hours of their time into it.