In this best-selling expose of national policy gone wrong, America's foremost historian of education, Diane Ravitch, renounces her support for reform policies implemented over the past decade that she says are wrecking America's cherished tradition of public education. Strategies like accountability schemes based on questionable standardized tests, merit pay for teachers based on gains on the same unreliable tests, vouchers, and charter schools have been oversold as solutions for our educational problems. Policymakers pushing a market model of reform and charter schools are on the wrong track, ignoring classroom realities. The more they push these policies, Ravitch says, the more they will harm our nation's school system and undermine the quality of education.
The bipartisan No Child Left Behind program ("NCLB") implemented with a heavy political hand nationwide, has failed to improve education. It has turned our schools into testing factories to train children how to take standardized tests instead of giving them the knowledge and skills that are necessary components of a good education. The federal "sanctions" and "remedies" now mandated nationwide have unfairly stigmatized thousands of schools, putting them at risk of being closed and privatized.
The "miracles" touted by districts under the new policies vanish on close examination. Test scores in many states and districts are inflated by statistical game-playing and lowered standards. The over-emphasis on testing has all but eliminated the essential elements of a solid education, including history, civics, science, the arts, geography, literature, physical education, health education, and foreign languages. Privatization and deregulation has led predictably to some good and some bad but, on average, charters do not get better results than regular public schools-just new federal subsidies. Teacher evaluation by student test scores is a deeply flawed approach to hiring and job tenure that is driving good teachers out of public education.
The future of public education is at stake. A democratic society needs a healthy, vibrant public education system with good public schools in every neighborhood. On our current course, the schools will be privatized, deregulated, and turned over to entrepreneurs. Based on a careful review of the evidence, Ravitch says that this course of action is unlikely to improve American education.
©2011 Diane Ravitch (P)2012 Diane Ravitch
I originally read this in hardcover and found Ravitch gives a detailed, well-thought-out and valuable critique of new "educational initiative." However, the highest credit goes to Eliza Foss who is superb at narrating a relatively dry text, filled with facts, statistics, etc. I am impressed at how well she aries her voice and holds the listeners interest in the fact based non-fiction work.
Realistic, Refreshing, Thought-provoking
Exposing the politics of education, sharing the important role that demographics play in learning, describing the real-life challenges that educators face, the sequence of the story.
The chapters on District 1 in NYC and the part about the failure of the San Diego public schools that recruited the business person to be their superintendent.
The author's admission that she was caught up in the accountability movement associated with NCLB and her revelation that the system is flawed and that it disadvantages low-wealth schools.
Great book for policy makers and educators!
thought-provoking, statistical, research-based
The description of a business model for education, as though learning were a market commodity, and the damage that model does to useful learning in our schools.
The description of the New York educational "reform", and the flawed statistics that supported the results as effective.
No! Way too dense. One disadvantage of audiobooks is that a report like this, with reference to many statistics in the narrative, is difficult to follow--hard to remember what numbers were cited a few paragraphs ago. In printed books, you can just flip back.
I appreciated the fact-based investigation and arguments Ravitch offered, and will be watching our own schools to see if they can move away from "teaching to the test", a move that both of my daughters, both schoolteachers, find is an impediment to their ability to educate their students, especially in critical thinking and problem-solving.
College professor, feminist, educational reformer, policy analyst,foodie, and artist.
Revealing, Provacative, Insightful
Understanding the corporate influence in policy making
The narrator needed to speak clearly, and louder, at times she drifted into a soft whisper, and talked too sensual for the topic.
An expose into the forces shaping educational policy.
You must read this book, if you are in anyway involved with education. If you are concerned about the state of students today, and want to understand why and how the problems of K-12 are now fully entrenched into Higher Education, you need to be aware of the history of decentralization of school. This book is brilliant and enlightening.
A short history of the American educational system, including an honest look at the causes and consequences of the current trends.
Ms. Ravitch eloquently explains the issues facing today's educators. She has a first-hand knowledge of the politics that drive public education. The only thing missing are the answers.
Content: As a student of Education, this is hands down one of my favorite books on education I've read during my PhD program.
Performance: adequate narration, a touch slow for my taste. I usually listened to it at 1.5 speed, sometimes 1.25.
Overall: Whether you are an educator, policy maker, parent, or a concerned citizen, this is a book that you should read. It's not only an important but a solid writer is at the helm. A welcome voice of both heart and reason.
As an educator this book has with out exaggeration changed my life. Everything this author writes has made my must read list. As I told my doctoral classmates this is a book you just can't put down like game of thrones.
There is a lot here. A lot seemed repetitive. I appreciated the additions in the Revised Edition. I've seen complaints elsewhere that we're talking to folks about "reforming" schools who are neither education professionals nor scholars in the field of Education. What special knowledge or experience does Bill Gates have that qualifies him to be treated as an expert. The old Ravitch still show through was some very traditional notions of what should be taught. I agree that her essential position hasn't changed. This book is an indictment about how we've gone about the very laudable goal of providing a good education to all Americans. Having worked in the system, I agree with most of what she presents. The system of high stakes testing isn't the right focus. We don't need kids good at taking fill in the bubble tests, we need kids who know how to learn, can write clearly, are mathematically literate, and have a desire for learning. It's a bit long, but worth reading.
The woman who read the book was irritating. I think it took twice as long than if I had read the text myself. Too many long pauses.
The fact that the author seemed genuinely less concerned about party politics and more concerned about the welfare of the American student.
Report Inappropriate Content