War Without Mercy

Race and Power in the Pacific War

De: John W. Dower

Narrado por: Tim Campbell

War Without Mercy has been hailed by the New York Times as "one of the most original and important books to be written about the war between Japan and the United States." In this monumental history, professor John Dower reveals a hidden, explosive dimension of the Pacific War - race - while writing what John Toland has called "a landmark book...a powerful, moving, and evenhanded history that is sorely needed in both America and Japan."

Drawing on American and Japanese songs, slogans, cartoons, propaganda films, secret reports, and a wealth of other documents of the time, Dower opens up a whole new way of looking at that bitter struggle of four and a half decades ago and its ramifications in our lives today. As Edwin O. Reischauer, former ambassador to Japan, has pointed out, this book offers "a lesson that the postwar generations need most...with eloquence, crushing detail, and power."

©1986 John W. Dower (P)2017 Tantor

Reseñas de la Crítica

"One of the most original and important books to be written about the war between Japan and the United States." ( New York Times)

Interesting Insights

I read many books on WW2, but this was one to expose the horrors on both sides of the battlefields in the Pacific. The brutality was not just the consequence of the Japanese refusing to surrender but the West being humiliated by people of Color. The Japanese evicted the Europeans (Dutch, English, and French in Indonesia, Singapore, and Vietnam, respectively) and the Americans (Philippines) from their colonies in the Pacific. Having suffered humiliation, the idea was to make an example of these people who would challenge the West's hegemony. This mindset subsequently led to the loss of human life in Korea and Vietnam and the destruction of the lands and inhabitants of both countries, although we like to hide behind the cliche of "containment of communism." We do not have clean hands, and now, we feel shocked to see Asians (especially the Chinese) do everything possible to defeat the West today on the commercial battlefield.

Classic Analysis

If it seems less revolutionary than when first published in 1986, this is largely because so many of Dower's basic conclusions have been widely accepted over the past 30 years. A classic study of how "race hates" and "war hates" effected the Pacific War (and by extension, many wars before and since). The Epilogue section about the economic tensions between Japan and the U.S. in the 1980s seems a piece of history now, when the emphasis on the "Yellow Peril" of China seems newly triumphant. Let's hope that turns out better between the Japanese and U.S. relationship up to and through WW2.

Mid

Mediocre revisionist history leaves out and attempts to re frame much of the activities of the Japanese army

War without Mercy

This book is historical revisionism without mercy. Main thesis is that the Japanese and Americans were at least equally racist, and often the US (simply because they were more powerful) was the most racist. Utter drivel blaming the US for everything and giving the Japanese a pass despite their overall aggression, the rape of Nanking and Pearl Harbor. I got my money back.

Revisionist history

Paints WWII America as racially motivated to go to war and kill Japanese. Revisionist history.

Framed by the Cold War

The first two chapters and the final chapter are the strong points of this book, everything else verging on old sociology class lectures one tends to put in the trash bin of the brain until confronted by that style of history thirty plus years later. There's plenty of gang related studies, studies of cartoons, newspaper treatment of the Japanese, folk tale renderings of the Americans in Japanese culture... but it doesn't add up to a compelling story. Being an us vs. them format, Dower doesn't delve into Japanese race relations with the Chinese to any significant degree, a major whoopsie, to me, considering the devastation the Japanese brought to China. He mentions the Australians in passing, the British rather more so and with the Brits he had a chance to really lay it on thick with their history of class snobbery and denigration of any culture not that of Albion. He chooses to skate on by that rich trove of racist history, however, which I feel would have elevated the material significantly. Finishing up with what amounts to an op ed column for an afterword, focused on then current race viewpoints of Americans toward the Japanese framed by WW2, it's definitely got a stale, cold coffee taste to it.

The narrator goes at it fast and furious, by the way. You may find yourself rewinding quite a bit.