The Prettiest Star

De: Carter Sickels

Narrado por: Tiffany Morgan, Charlie Thurston

Small-town Appalachia doesn't have a lot going for it, but it's where Brian is from, where his family is, and where he's chosen to return to die.

At 18, Brian, like so many other promising young gay men, arrived in New York City without much more than a love for the freedom and release from his past that it promised. But within six short years, AIDS would claim his lover, his friends, and his future. With nothing left in New York but memories of death, Brian decides to write his mother a letter asking to come back to the place, and family, he was once so desperate to escape.

Set in 1986, a year after Rock Hudson's death shifted the public consciousness of the epidemic and brought the news of AIDS into living rooms and kitchens across America, The Prettiest Star is part Dog Years by Mark Doty and part Tell the Wolves I'm Home by Carol Rifka Brunt. But it is also an urgent story now: It a novel about the politics and fragility of the body; it is a novel about sex and shame. And it is a novel that speaks to the question of what home and family means when we try to forge a life for ourselves in a world that can be harsh and unpredictable.

Contains mature themes.

©2020 Carter Sickels (P)2020 Tantor

A moving read

I absolutely loved this book. I just wished it ended differently, maybe a bit more closure. You definitely get sucked up into the story and your heart strings are more yanked than pulled.

Beautiful and heartbreaking

This book is beautifully written. The characters are well developed. The narration is very well done. The story will break your heart.

I really liked it, but I wanted to love it.

The Prettiest Star is a compelling and thought-provoking read, though it didn’t quite reach the level of love for me, I did, however, appreciate it. The premise is strong, though not entirely unique, as similar themes have been explored in other works. The pacing was uneven; while the beginning felt slow, the middle drew me in, only to lose momentum again in the final last quarter of the book.

The characters were likable but lacked deeper development, which made it harder to feel fully invested in their journeys. The storyline itself tackles difficult, even controversial, subject matter, but it serves as an important reflection of reality during that era, and a sobering reminder of how little has changed in some ways as far as the way people are treated that do not fall into what some people believe to be the "norm".

My main critique lies in the handling of the main characters illness, it felt unnecessarily prolonged, and the eventual resolution (or lack thereof) left me wanting more closure. As for the audiobook performance, the narration took some getting used to, but by the end, I found the voice fitting and engaging.

Despite its flaws, The Prettiest Star is worth experiencing, if only for its unflinching portrayal of prejudice, suffering, and the enduring impact of history. It’s a story that stays with you, prompting reflection on how far we’ve come and how far we still have to go.

Beautiful and haunting

The book took me back to the ‘80’s; I lived in southern Ohio then, and the story and the characters rang true. I did not care for the narrators, especially the female narration. The accent went in and out, and was more “soft southern” than the Ohio twang. I would recommend people read rather than listen to this book.

Heart wrenching

A heart wrenching tale about a young gay man in the 80's told from 3 different perspectives. He leaves his small town home for New York so he can finally live his true life. While living his truth, he finds love, friendships, and death. He loses his soul mate to AIDS and is diagnosed with the disease himself. He decides to move back to his hometown to face the reality of what is ahead. You will hear the story of an unwelcoming small town and the struggles of this young gay man as he lives out his final days.

Four stars! Be prepared to be sad, angry, simply broken-hearted. A great book!

Heartbreaking and transformative!

This is a book that will open hearts and raise consciousness. A beautiful meditation on the meaning of home, the tension between sorrow and rage, and what it means to be queer at a time when having a virus made you less than human. This book asks us to "Don't forget. Say their names."

The narrators do justice to the story as well. Highly recommend!

Very Compelling Story

It's a great story. I personally could have done with a lot less use of the f word.

A Beautiful Story

Perhaps this story is not for everyone. But for those of us who experienced these events, and lost family, friends, and lovers to AIDS, it will move you deeply. The story is uniquely written, and performed with great talent and compassion. No matter who you are, or what you know, I recommend you listen.

important to remember

The performance has spots where the location or time or the story changes from one sentence to the next without pause or warning; not terrible, but it is distracting. The story itself is a hard one, so much bigotry and pain and ignorance during the AIDS crisis in the mid-80s and it's all here. There are few heroes in this book and lots of moments where hindsight grants the reader the opportunity to be judgmental. As the blurbs say, it's the story of one young man and his family and the small town he goes back to to die, but I think it's also important to remember the response of Ronald Reagan and his supporters: ignore the crisis, deny it's a crisis, blame the victims, invoke god's punishment, people die.

Just Amazing

I was completely absorbed and could not stop listening. I'm certain that this book is going to win prizes.