My Favorite Secret

Playing Favorites, Book 3

De: Skyla Summers

Narrado por: Lucy Rivers, Joe Arden, Lee Samuels

Felix and Tyler Blackwood are a sin I can’t stop craving. I have strict values about saving myself for marriage, but when I return from a vacation abroad, Felix and Tyler are no longer the innocent boys I grew up with and resisting them feels impossible. They’re now men, they’re gorgeous, and they’re tempting me to give in to forbidden desires.

I can hold out until we all start living together. They say I’ve always belonged to them and they’re more than willing to share me.

Before I know it, the three of us are entangled. What we’re doing is so wrong but feels too good to stop. We can keep it a secret. They’re mine and they promise me nothing will tear us apart. I want to believe them but I’m scared. Some secrets can kill. There’s one secret I know will be the death of us.

Written in multi POV, My Favorite Secret is the first book in Felix, Tyler, and Harper's duet. It is set before My Favorite Girl, contains an MFM relationship, and ends on a cliffhanger. The duet is a "second chance romance". The characters will find their happy ever after in the second book of the duet when they are in their late twenties.

For the best listening experience, it is recommended that you listen to My Favorite Girl and My Favorite Sin first to gain a deeper appreciation of the Blackwood family dynamics

©2025 Skyla Summers (P)2025 Blue Nose Publishing

ALC

🎧ALC REVIEW🎧

My Favorite Secret by : Skyla Summers

In multicast duet narration by: Lucy Rivers, Joe Arden and Lee Samuels.

5/⭐️s
5/🌶s
5/🎧


This audiobook was such a standout listen. The multicast duet narration of My Favorite Secret adds so much personality and emotional depth to every scene. Lucy Rivers, Joe Arden, and Lee Samuels each bring a distinct energy that makes the tension, humor, and romance feel incredibly real. The dialogue flows naturally, the chemistry is strong, and the dramatic moments land beautifully. If you love emotional romance with secrets, sparks, and top tier voice acting, this one is an easy recommendation.

Harper, Felisx and Tyler

Book 3 in The Playing Favorites Series

Multicast Duet Narration by Lucy Rivers, Joe Arden and Lee Samuels.

Felix and Tyler are brothers, and Harper is the daughter of their mother's best friend. Clara has taken the boys under her wing as their father throws himself in to work.
They have always had a close bond. As they grew older, its much more forbidden.

I like the way the triggers which were on and off the page were handled.

This is a MFM story, Check the Trigger

I enjoyed the narrator's performances with this book; I am waiting eagerly for the next installment.

Brothers!

Brothers....yes please. I love both of them. They each bring something special to the book. The FMC annoyed me in the beginning with her prudish ways but that eventually chamged. the story took a turn inwas expecting and now I can't wait to see how it ends. I hate cliffhangers but was expecting it ao it wasnt too bad. the narrators are perfect!

The Heartache 💔

Spice: 🌶🌶🌶🌶

🅃🅁🄾🄿🄴🅂
💋 why choose
💋 friends to lovers
💋 possessive/obsessive

🅃🄷🄾🅄🄶🄷🅃🅂
Skyla did it to me again. I am beyond ready for the next book. I knew how this book was going to end. If you read My Favorite Girl and My Favorite Sin, you have already been introduced to Felix, Tyler and Harper. The synopsis explains that they do not get their HEA in this book. So I knew… but I am still emotionally damaged. The heartache I feel for these characters and what they go through.

And of course we had amazing narrators who brought the story to life! The emotion I felt from their performances was top tier.

The spice. The connection. The chemistry. The emotional damage.

My Favorite Secret, Playing Favorites, Book 3
by Skyla Summers
Narrated by Lucy Rivers, Joe Arden, Lee Samuels


Just… wow. I was already fully addicted to this series after My Favorite Girl and My Favorite Sin, but somehow Skyla Summers turned everything all the way up with My Favorite Secret, and I was absolutely not ready.

The spice. The connection. The chemistry. The emotional damage. Skyla, respectfully, please stomp on my heart harder next time.

This book is intense in the best way. Every interaction feels loaded, every moment heavy with longing and tension. And yes, we need to talk about those scenes. The Jeep scene. The pool scene. The maze. Gosh, the maze. I don’t think I’ve ever highlighted this many lines in a book, truly unhinged behavior on my part, no regrets.
This story completely consumed me, and that cliffhanger? Cruel. I genuinely don’t know how I’m supposed to survive waiting until May for the next book.

The narration was an absolute masterpiece.
Lucy Rivers just continues to cement herself as one of my all-time favorite female narrators. She embodies Harper so beautifully, the emotion pouring out of every word, it was impossible not to feel everything right along with her. Joe Arden… I have no words. He shattered me. The letters alone left me emotionally wrecked, staring into the void. His performance was devastating. This was only my second audiobook narrated by Lee Samuels, but his Tyler was perfection. That quiet, kind but still dominant presence fit him like a glove and added so much depth to the character.

“I love you,” she speaks the words like they’re sacred. “You are my favorite secret, Felix Blackwood.”
“You are my entire world.”

This was immersive, emotional, spicy, and completely addictive. I need everyone to read it and listen to it. If you like Taboo, forbidden, spicy, angsty and emotional damage you must read this!

⭐️ Infinite stars
🌶️ 4.5 chili peppers

Thank you so much Blue Nose Audio and Skyla Summers for this review copy, all opinions are my own.