The Janissary Tree

A Novel

De: Jason Goodwin

Narrado por: Stephen Hoye

The Janissary Tree, the first book in a new series, is set in a most extraordinary world and features a most extraordinary sleuth.

It is 1836. Europe is modernizing, and the Ottoman Empire must follow suit. But just before the sultan announces sweeping changes, a wave of murders threatens the fragile balance of power in his court. Who is behind them? Only one intelligence agent can be trusted to find out: Yashim Togalu, a man both brilliant and near-invisible in this world.

You see, Yashim is a eunuch.

He leads us into the palace's luxurious seraglios and Istanbul's teeming streets, and leans on the wisdom of a dyspeptic Polish ambassador, a transsexual dancer, and a Creole-born queen mother. He finds sweet salvation in the arms of another man's wife. (This is not your everyday eunuch.) And he introduces us to the Janissaries. For, 400 years earlier, the sultan had them crushed. Are the Janissaries staging a brutal comeback?

©2007 Jason Goodwin (P)2007 Tantor Media Inc.

Reseñas de la Crítica

• Edgar Award, Best Novel, 2007

"A work of dazzling beauty....The rare coming together of historical scholarship and curiosity about distant places with luminous writing." (The New York Times Book Review)

A Real Page Turner

This was one of the most riveting historical mysteries I have listened to in a long time. The wealth of detail about the Ottoman Empire and life in Istambul really makes this book come alive. I love historical mysteries that really make you live in the period and this is one of them. The detail is marvelous and adds to the depth of the book. While at first I didn't much care for the narrator, the more I listened the more I felt he was just right for the book and his ability to vocally differentiate the various characters in the book is really marvellous. Highly recommended.

Entertaining

A mix of intrigue, building plot and humility. Novel setting with unique characters does nor disappoint.

Narrator made a Russian of a Pole

My one quibble is that the narrator who briefly started out w a decent Polish accent for the Polish ambassador quickly went over to a Russian one. That left him w no good Russian accent for the Russian characters! If you don't notice accents, you won't find this an issue.

Wow, what an enthralling story.

Draws you in and tantalizes, with vivid descriptions and draping clues... Oh well. On to the next Yashim mystery.

Quite wonderful

Fascinating insight into another world, with a complex story and wonderful characters. I can’t wait to read the next book in the series.

A Good Read

If you could sum up The Janissary Tree in three words, what would they be?

Plot, characterization and setting expertly written. Solid historical fiction.

Did the plot keep you on the edge of your seat? How?

Plot line was compelling. I was bothered by the descriptions of the macabre homicides, which is why I give it a "4", not a "5".

What about Stephen Hoye???s performance did you like?

Easy to listen to.

Any additional comments?

Stephen Hoye's Polish accent sounded too much like a Yiddush accent!

Muddled But Engaging

First off, the 19th century setting of a detective mystery in the harem of the Sultan of the fading Ottoman Empire is wonderfully intriguing. Goodwin carries it off making this a memorable read. But… but… there's something about this whole thing that like hearing a symphony on a 78 RPM recording… It's Lo-Fi. Nope, don't mean the actual Audible recording, I mean the writing. It's as if you can get the melody, but hardly any of the nuance. Can't explain it exactly, and it's not the fault of Stephen Hoye who reads the thing OK. The characters are only interesting as oddities, not as people.

But while I'd recommend The Janisary Tree as a diversion, a trip to an exotic place (or maybe a carney freak show) and time seen through the eyes of a particularly exotic detective… Well its the setting of the story that make for the interest, not the mystery. It's muddled but well, engaging.

As they say, when the critics begin reviewing the set… the play's in trouble. Here it's the set that stars.

Exotic and Entertaining

In this historical novel set in 1836 Istanbul, a eunuch named Yashim is asked to investigate into several cases. There are four officers who have gone missing (one of which turns up dead in an oversized cauldron a short while later); the sultan's most recent concubine is murdered in her bed; and the sultan's mother's jewels have gone missing. In the case of the officers, Yashim finds clues that seem to point toward the Janissaries as being responsible for the abduction and it's aftermath. The Janissaries had had a powerful presence in Turkey until 1826, just a decade previous to the start of our story. An elite force created by Sultan Murad I in 1383, they formed the Ottoman Sultan's household troops and bodyguards, but Sultan Mahmud II found them to be an unruly and disruptive presence, and wanting to create a modern army to keep up with the Europeans, he disbanded and slaughtered the Janissaries. But it seems there were survivors after all, and Yashim needs to figure out what they are up to to stop more bodies from turning up dead. Aiding him in his search for clues are his colourful and somewhat eccentric friends, the Polish ambassador and a transsexual dancer. A complex plot and an entertaining mystery set in an exotic place which is undergoing a great transition from ancient traditional customs to European modernization. I would have liked to find out more about Yashim himself, but perhaps more is revealed about him in the following 3 novels.

Loved Stephen Hoye's narration.

Enjoyed reading more than listening

... fell in love with this series years ago. Reading allowed me to ‘hear’ each character as I imagined... while Stephen Hoye would have been wonderful for some sort of British type of novel - think Remains of the Day, Brideshead, or some such... I felt Hoye was miscast here. When I originally read the series I spent hours looking up places mentioned - Istanbul is one of the places I wish I could see in person. Since I never will be able to, this series allows me to go vicariously. I still love this series, I’ll just stick to reading it instead of listening.

Buyer beware: Decent novel. Irritating chapter markers.

If you’re accustomed to marking your progress by hitting the button in the lower right of your screen (at least at the beginning of each chapter…or when you pause reading in the middle of a chapter so that you can keep your place), be aware that Audible’s chapter numbers mean nothing in this rather interesting novel.

An Audible “chapter” may contain up to ten tiny chapters, each announced by the narrator, and each tiny chapter may mark a shift in location, a jump to the concurrent actions of another character, or sometimes, inexplicably, a continuation of the actions of the previous chapter. What won’t happen is a shift to a new chapter when the Audible screen tells you that you’ve just begun Chapter 4. You’re probably in the middle of chapter 37.

I’ll leave it to other reviewers to talk about a book that I think would be better read than listened to.