The Feats of Sherlock Holmes

De: Nick Cardillo

Narrado por: Rob Sogomonian

Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson return in six further adventures which display the great detective's brilliance once more.

In these adventures set across the span of the duo's lives at 221b Baker Street, Holmes and Watson travel from the highest realms of society to the lowest dens of criminality across London in pursuit of the solution to a host of baffling mysteries. What secret does a simple wedding ring hold? What has become of a young woman fleeing the country? Can Holmes uncover the truth of a haunted house which has baffled all of London?

These are but a few of the questions which shall be answered in The Feats of Sherlock Holmes.

©2018 Nick Cardillo (P)2024 MX Publishing

Excellent Narration

I’m very particular when it comes to audiobooks. Even if the story is great, the performance has to draw me in or I lose interest. The narration on this one is really well done! I loved it!

A wonderful read!

The writing style and performance captured that slightly quirky nature of Sherlock. Told through the eyes of his assistant, Watson, we get to experience the funny and slightly outside view of the famous detective. The performance captures the essence of the well known characters perfectly and delivers excellent comedic timing.

Not bad, but…

This definitely felt like a new author's first works (which I believe it is). The writing wasn't bad, but there were little things that bothered the grammarian in me. But we'll put that aside, as very few folks were taught hardcore grammar like I was.

So let's talk about the tales themselves. I just don't see most of them as something that Watson would decide couldn't be published for at least a century and a year. It felt like a simple conceit to account for the books not appearing until now, and I just didn't buy it. The stories were okay, but definitely not up to the level of some of the top pastiches I've read or listened to.

In fact, some of them were just dreadful. Holmes solved too many of them without giving us even a fighting chance of seeing the solution for ourselves. While I don't enjoy mysteries where I have the solution as soon as the problem is stated, I also don't care for stories where the solution is suddenly presented out of the blue, where I had no realistic chance of solving it for myself.

In addition, the author tried to use "smart words" to make his writing more erudite. But he didn't really know the correct meanings, so it just doesn't work for me. Please, dear author, look up words you have not used on a very frequent basis for years.

And then we come to the narrator. He was okay. I guess. He didn't have a strong British accent, unlike most narrators of Holmes pastiches. But I don't hold that against him. But I do criticize him for his many misreadings and mispronounciations. Again, if you don't know the vocabulary, LOOK THE WORDS UP! And be careful as you read. Listen to what you are saying, to see if it makes sense. If not, you might have misread it.

I wish I could give this a better review, but I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review, and honestly, this was only a so-so book. Listen, or don't, as you choose.

Young author, poor narrator

While the author is obviously enthusiastic, it's also obvious that he is young. He has talent and imagination and will grow, I'm sure, but there is room for some polishing.

The narrator, however, was a disservice to this writer. Obviously not British, there were times he totally dropped the accent. Then there were the numerous words that he massacred, more than once. These distractions took me completely out of the story.

I dont' like writing negative reviews, but I hope that this will give both parties impetus to improve. I wish well for both in the future, but hope the author finds someone else for his narrator.