Speeches by Malcolm X - The Ultimate Collection

De: Malcolm X

Narrado por: Malcolm X

"Any kind of movement for freedom of Black people based solely within the confines of America is absolutely doomed to fail." Speeches and interviews of Malcolm X.

©2020 Black History (P)2020 Black History

a good book but

it was good but seem like I heard they same speeches more than once enjoyed it

The Ultimate Collection

Malcolm X was very intellectual in all ways. Like he said” When you travel, you broaden your scope”
“We have to have human rights before we can secure civil rights. We must be respected as humans before we can be recognized as citizens”
Mean while Democrats left the Borders open
Now I know they are here for wrong reasons.
Malcolm X the GOAT.

poor production quality

liked what I heard but the book is 18 hours with only 6 hours of content

Great Collection

I was discouraged by the first review that I read because the listener did not like the audio quality, the inclusion of audio that was not a speech from Malcolm X, and the repeated clips. I don’t disagree with those points.

I must add that the context of some speeches are lost. This is because the clips are not in chronological order.

That stated, this is an excellent collection to listen to AFTER the listener reads the Autobiography of Malcolm X (the Spike Lee movie Malcolm X is not an appropriate substitute). When listening to this collection as a supplement to knowing Malcolm X’s life story from his perspective, his words (and even some of the clips not from his speeches) have much more significance and educational value.

Could have gotten five stars

I love Malcolm X, however the chapter would end mid-sentence in some parts; most frustrating.

Speeches, yes; Organized or labeled? No

You will get to hear Malcolm X and that gives this collection value. However, there are no labels of date, location, interviewers. etc for speeches. As other reviewers pointed out clips from movie and other speakers are included. At the end of chapter 1 is some random few seconds of a clip. At minimum, the chapters could have been labeled with the speech date and location.

Awesome

These speeches could fit for today 2022 change some names and dates and it fits! Don't like the insertion of the movie clips,there not speeches!

Producers did Brother Malcolm a disservice

Some chapters do not include the Minister speaking but Minister Elijah Muhammad, Denzel Washington’s portrayal of the Minister in the film “X” and even a poorly edited clip of “Fight the Power” by Public Enemy.
Chapters should have titles of the speeches with notes of date, time, location, event, members of panel, etc. This production is intellectually lazy.

something is better than nothing

outline of chapters confusing
content repeats
audio sometimes distorts
His message is clear
as-salamu alaykum

Tricks

Yes you will hear MalcolmX however you will hear the same speeches over and over
And over and
Over and over