Once Upon A Time, A True Story of Memory, Murder and the Law

De: Harry N. MacLean

Narrado por: Wendy Almeida

Duración: 24 h

Resumen del Editor

In 1989, Eileen Franklin, a young California housewife, claimed to recover a repressed memory of her father killing her playmate 20 years earlier. In a landmark trial, the father was charged and convicted of first-degree murder, based solely on his daughter's testimony. This book chronicles the trial, explores the remarkably dysfunctional Franklin family and delves into the credibility of repressed memories as evidence.

This version contains a 2011 Epilogue, which details the reasons for the reversal of George Franklin's murder conviction and the refusal of the district attorney to retry him for murder.

©1993 Harry N. MacLean (P)2015 Harry N. MacLean

Reseñas de la Crítica

"A tragic but gripping story, and expertly crafted. Mr. MacLean has a positive talent for detail, and an obvious knowledge of the law. I congratulate him on a masterfully told story" (Steve Martini, author of Compelling Evidence)

" Once Upon A Time is a well-written and meticulous account of a true human drama. The uncharted terrain of the human mind and its ability to repress as well as deceive are fascinating food for thought." (Nancy Taylor Rosenberg, author of Mitigating Circumstances)

"MacLean gives us a fascinating look at a fascinating crime." (Tony Hillerman, author of Talking God and Coyote Waits)

Author/ narrator dissonance

I had a hard time with this book. I was unsure of the authors intent at several points because of the narrators delivery. It occurred to me that it may have been vague for the narrator as well so she did the best she could in interpreting through inflection. Still, although I found the basic facts gripping, I was not a fan of how the author portrayed behaviors of the female victims and the way he described the appearance of the prosecuting attorney. False memory syndrome is fascinating and I'd like to find titles that focus on the emerging science of such. All in all I walked away wondering if the author has ever known anyone that was a victim of abuse or incest because he seemed like either a closet chauvinist or the bitter ex of a victim.

Our children. Our future.

The book leaves you with an aftertaste of avoiding contact with any appearance of molestation however innocent. I've often wanted to get involved with helping disadvantage youth but fear those who have suspicious minds. Innocent until proven guilty is a myth. It's a shame as our future is tied to our children.

Fascinating true story!!!

Where does Once Upon A Time, A True Story of Memory, Murder and the Law rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

This ranks among my favorite Audible books. I remember this story from the '90s and the facts are very different than what was reported at the time. This story details an abusive and extremely dysfunctional family and a father accused of murder by his daughter. The author presents a believable psychological explanation and a 2011 update.

Interesting and addictive story, bad narrator

Would you consider the audio edition of Once Upon A Time, A True Story of Memory, Murder and the Law to be better than the print version?

No, the narrator was annoying. I found myself getting irritated at her over and mis-pronunciations.

What was the most interesting aspect of this story? The least interesting?

Wondering if her story is true, or how much of it is true.

Would you be willing to try another one of Wendy Almeida’s performances?

NO

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

It kept me interested and wondering what was going to happen next. It made me research this case, look at pictures of the family and try to decide for myself.

Job well done.

This book had you on the edge of your seat. I was late for a lot of appointments because I didn't want to get out of the car. Ms. Wendy did an awesome job narrating the story.

exceptional...

i found this book to be exceptionally written and very well narrated...the story is unreal but is told in such a well written manner...

Slow

This story is way too slow and dragged out it was interesting however I don’t think it had to be so painfully slow

Superb!

As an avid true crime lover I especially enjoyed the detail in this book. The entire court case was told in such a way to make you feel as if you were there. Too many true crime stories assume guilt based on a conviction, in this tale the reader is allowed to make up their own mind. I found myself wondering what I would have done had I been on the jury, with the facts that the jury was given, and also trying to decide what I thought with all the facts. That was an interesting change for me, as usually my option of guilt is decided before the book even makes it to the courtroom.

The narrator did a pretty good job of portraying the different speakers, although there were moments that she annoyed me in her attempts to do this. Overall though, she added to the book and did not take away.

Highly recommend!

Interesting story but slow read

What about Wendy Almeida’s performance did you like?

Had to listen on faster speed. Narration is too slow and tedious.

Any additional comments?

Interesting subject matter. Be prepared for a slow narration.

Poor writing worse narration!

You could rip out every other page of this book and still probably not miss anything of substance. MacLean's writing style was dizzying and told the story as a watery soup more full of contradicting opinions than facts. It isn't the worst true crime novel but it's not good either. The narration was truly awful! What were they thinking?! Almeida sounds grandmotherly and every time she said something obscene (which is frequently) I truly cringed! I'm sure she could pull off many books very well as a narrator and she did do a fantastic southern drawl for the killers voice, but she was honestly a very very poor choice for this book! I cannot recommend, nor will I ever re-read.