Bad Science

Quacks, Hacks, and Big Pharma Flacks

De: Ben Goldacre

Narrado por: Jonathan Cowley

Author Ben Goldacre exposes the epidemic of pseudoscience and gives listeners the tools they need to distinguish good science from nonsense.

©2010 Ben Goldacre (P)2012 Tantor

Reseñas de la Crítica

"Great fun for science and statistics geeks, this is challenging in the best sense of the word." ( Library Journal)

Knowledge is Power

Goldacre really gives you pause for thought in regards to medicine and nutrition. He has no qualms about calling a quack a quack, and really makes you wonder about all the studies that have been done concerning supplements, diets, and general medical information.

Informative and well written

The book delivers on its promise of making a reader think more critically about scientifically sounding claims made by mass media or by companies that try to sell things. There are multiple examples of baseless claims that are wide spread and accepted like detox or homeopathy. The book enumerates quite a few of them and explains where the claims came from and why they are wrong.
Perhaps the most interesting part of the book is about how questionable conclusions can be substantiated by research/studies that on a surface seem credible. How, if you are not careful and don't know what to look for, you can easily be mislead by unethical studies. For example small details in selecting trial groups, deciding cohorts or assuming wrong control groups can completely change results of an experiment. Unfortunately some corrupt companies try to cheat using such methods.

Important Book In This Scientifically Trying Time

I'm a fan of Ben Goldacre. I've heard him interviewed on a number of podcasts and he's always interesting and makes great points. I did not fully connect with this audiobook, however. I was very familiar with most of the subject matter, as much of the material has been covered in depth on the podcast The Skeptic's Guide to the Universe. The book felt like a review and a lot of rehash.

The book attacks medical quackery, homeopathy, nutritionists, anti-vaxxers, and several other health-related, and anti-science topics. A couple chapters I found interesting were about Brain Gym and statistics manipulation. Brain Gym is a brain training company which is apparently a bigger deal in the UK (I've never even heard of it) which Goldacre claims is bad science and he takes it down in a big way. The Andrew Wakefield / MMR vaccine scare is covered in depth in this book. The author does a great job presenting his case against lousy science in a concise and sometimes funny way.

Despite my rating, I would recommend this book for anyone looking to become more proficient in seeing through anti-science claims and recognizing scams and pseudoscience. If this subject matter is new to you, you will probably find this book enlightening. It was written in 2012 and the message is as important now as it was then. Maybe more so, actually.

Life changing

The book is excellent. So good that I changed my career to pursue clinical trial work! Thank you so much!

If you like this topic you'll enjoy this book

Very well researched. The information is clearly presented and easy to understand. A good introduction to the topic

Worthwhile

audiobook, crooks, education, greed, medical, nonfiction, reference, science, social-issues, whispersync, fraud

A detailed reminder to verify claims and rationality of products that are aimed at desperate people reaching for an answer and finding snake oil instead. Very well worthwhile read.
Jonathan Cowley does come off rather pedantic, but that does not diminish the value of the material.

Worth a rethink

I don't always agree with his viewpoint but I do respect it. So I will give his ideas a second and third consideration.

Charity Case

I think it's nice that they've let somebody read this who has themselves only just learnt how to read. Dreadful.

So much

Overall there was just so much in it. Was hard to grasp everything in one go.

Brilliant book

It is a wonderful a passionate book. Well written . Not only for people with a science background. It is for anyone who want to understand critical thinking and how we fool ourselves