All three books have the same Narrator, who has a fine voice. However, his interpretation of some of the characters is not very good. And the repeats..Show More » of lines is horrible! All it would have taken is some editing to fix these and I would have given him a 3. But, since so many lines or parts of lines were repeated, several instances come up where he cleared his voice. I finally had to revert to reading a large portion of it. I plan to get my money back on these because its not worth keeping these in my library!