From the author of the critically acclaimed What Alice Forgot comes a wonderfully fun, insightful novel about the crazy things we do for love.
Ellen O’Farrell is a bit unusual. She’s a hypnotherapist. She’s never met her father. And she can’t seem to keep a relationship going. (Okay, that’s more normal that we want to admit.) When Ellen meets Patrick, she’s hopeful nevertheless. But when he says he needs to tell her something, she fears the worst.
When Patrick reveals that his ex-girlfriend is stalking him, Ellen thinks, "Is that all? Actually, that’s kind of neat." She’s more intrigued than frightened. What makes a supposedly smart, professional woman behave this way? She’d love to meet her. What she doesn’t know is that she already has.
©2012 Liane Moriarty (P)2012 Penguin
If you are someone who enjoys books about relationships & character studies, then this is the book for you. It's about what happens when a relationship ends, one party refuses to accept it, and how this affects the other persons new relationship.
Saskia and Patrick dated for 3 years. When he broke up with her, she simply refused be left and begins stalking him and his son. It's not with any violence--she just refuses to let him forget her, them, what they were. When Patrick falls in love with Ellen, she wants to get to know Ellen, as well and proceeds to, under the guise of a new client at Ellen's hypnotherapy practice. It's a story with lots of layers--Saskia and Patrick, Ellen's burgeoning interest in Saskia, Patrick and his family, Saski and Patrick's son, Ellen and her family, Saskia and her mother, Saskia and her lack of friends......they all play into the why's of how this 3 year stalking begins and ultimately what ends it.
It was funny, sad, interesting and insightful. Liane Moriarty really let's you get into the heads of Saskia and Ellen and what drives them and how they view their relationship with Patrick. She somehow made Saskia's stalking seem innocent and funny and a mind-game all at the same time. I felt for her and was appalled by her behavior at the same time.
Tamara Lovatt Smith's narration was excellent! She somehow walked the fine line between making Saskia likable and just short of manic. She really captured all of the characters well--so hard to do, especially in a book with many characters of different ages.
Addicted to Audible!
I love Liane Moriarty and I loved the narration by Tamara Lovatt Smith, I also loved, The Husband's Secret and What Alice Forgot. This book was not as good as the other two but not without some entertainment value. The plot was predictable, not all the characters likeable and we had to hear endless psychoanalysis of each character. However, the narration made it all easy to listen to and it wasn't a total waste of my time. I am sure I would NOT have enjoyed reading this book, but to listen on the treadmill, it was fine. I wouldn't rush out and get this one but if you need to use a credit, its not a total waste.
Loved this book. it is quite the suspenseful love story with the perfect amount of fun woven in! Just as good as What Alice Forgot!
The plot and characters are unusual (including a female stalker) that somehow all show varying levels of humanity, always with humor. The story is extremely well crafted, and the Australian accent of the narrator (and setting of the novel) adds to the charm.
The protagonist - the author does a great job of layering her emotional portrait.
I didn't laugh or cry, but I cared about the characters.
I've already recommended this book to several friends as a fun, captivating read.
A creative and fascinating plot, read expertly by Tamara Lovatt Smith. Liane Moriarty has a gift for getting dialogue (and inner monologue) exactly right. I highly recommend this book as well as her earlier book called "What Alice Forgot".
Never without an audible book on my phone!
I liked the underlying premise of the book - What happens when you love someone and you break up or that person dies? Do you ever stop loving them? Is the expectation that you should "get over it" realistic? The exploration of this question was quite good, but in other areas, the novel fell short. It was too long and rambling and the character development was not as deep as Moriarty's other books. The audio narration was excellent.
I listened to this book a couple of times, because it was so unusual and I thought I may have missed key parts. No...it's a straight forward story with a new storyline.
In the process of reading all the books by this author. Read "The Husband's Secret" first, then "What Alice Forgot" and then this one. Love the writer's style and humor in all her books. Enjoyed the hypnotist's career in the story, but I think I got a little frustrated waiting for things to get resolved; therefore, I am subtracting one star. It is worth the credit if you enjoy Liane Moriarty.
So well written that I was empathizing with Saskia and angry with Patrick. I really wanted Ellen and Saskia to be friends...but as the story progressed I knew that could not happen
How much the characters grew, how much they learned about themselves and others.
nope, great voice, easy to follow, easy to distinguish between different characters
hmmmm....Not What you Think
SPOILERS..Wow, at first I wanted to junk punch and kick Patrick for what he did to Saskia. Then as I understood him and the grief he was suffering I understood. If he had met Ellen first the same thing would have happened.Poor Saskia all that she went through, all that she lost, all the she'll never have... I think Patrick's mother really should have connected with her and kept her relationship with Jack strong. Jack suffered the most because of Patrick's decision. I'm glad she was able to find a life for herself. She spent too much time alone now she finally has support.Really likd Ellen's character, felt that she grew not only as a hypnotist but as a person.
had me fooled...
none in particular
pleasing but ...
no, it did hold my interest but.... (again)
yes! additional comments.... it WAS interesting all the way through, and here's my "BUT"... I was so sure there was a plot or going to be a surprising ending but it ended rather dull... kind of began to expect it when there was only 1 hour left and that disappointed me.
To the narrator's voice, pleasing as it was, I found it disappointing again in this area as when she changed from one of the 2 key players to the other, in the book, she didn't change her voice and because I was listening to it on and off (I can't sit and listen to a book in full, too busy) I wouldn't realize which character was talking until I listened for a minute. Therefore, I didn't know where I was or what was happening where I'd left off and especially when it changed characters, if I'd stopped it at the end of a chapter or in a place when it "seemed to end in a good place, where I could quit for now and pick back up later"... small complaints? Maybe so but I just found these things not to my liking. Maybe I'm too use to my "cozy mysteries".
All in all, it's worth reading, don't NOT read it because of my review, it did keep me reading but I suppose it's because I thought something BIG was right around the corner and it never was.
Thank you for reading my review and I hope it was helpful.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.