©2005 Lynn Austin; (P)2006 Recorded Books, LLC
"[A] brilliant novel about love, forgiveness, suffering, and the importance of resisting the temptation to run away when things get tough." (Christian Book Previews.com)
Loved the complexity and the direction the author used to keep you wanting to know more of the sad story of Eleanor.
This was a good book, IMHO, though not great. The story was interesting the way all the characters' lives dovetailed into each other. It flowed along nicely, and was an interesting listen. Well written.
Absolutely! Austin's depictions of the roaring 20s, World War II, and the 1960s were stellar. The shutting off of emotions between mothers and daughters, their complex relationships, were well drawn.
I would have liked to have more male characters be strong and dependable, such as Kathleen's husband... I didn't get to know him, and how he put up with Kathleen's shutting off of herself, I don't know... but this is a minor quibble in an otherwise good book.
This book was well-done all in all. Linda Stevens' performance was good, but her penchant for pausing at the end of each chapter drove me a little batty, but her emotional inflections were very good.
No. It is aimed a a specific audience. Even though I am far from that particular demographic, I suppose this story has a place among its intended listeners. It's definitely not aimed at me, though.
The whole idea that one is only forgiven by grace is, in a word, selfish. If one really wanted to be forgiven for transgressions against others, shouldn't one really seek out the aggrieved party and ask for forgiveness from that person? Asking "forgiveness" from god doesn't repair anything with the person you have wronged. The characters could find strength in themselves and their own being--they don't need to "find god" to do this. Frankly, it made the entire story rather unbelievable. You don't become a better person by "finding god." You become a better person by acting better. That should have been the focus of this story.
I really wanted to like this book. It started out well and sounded like it was turning into a mystery novel, which would have been kind of cool. Every time, though that I heard mention of "forgiveness from Jesus," it cemented in my mind the possibility that it would turn into a proselytizing piece. Alas, that's exactly what it ended up being. I guess that's not necessarily a bad thing, but if so, why not express that in the description of the story? Honestly, I would not have purchased it if I had known this piece.
Suzanne, avid reader and listener who loves a broad range of genres but, ecpecially authors,T.C. Boyle, Jodi Picoult, Barbara Kingsolver, Lionel Shriver, Sue Miller, Larry McMurty, Bryce Courteran, Lisa Gardner, Brian Haig, Richard North Patterson, Nelson Demille, Robert Tannenbaum, Sara Gruen, Kate Norton, Steig Larsen, Tana French and Gillian Flynn!! Still many more and the number of authors I enjoy continues to grow.
I would have enjoyed this book much more if there were not the constant insertions about faith and Christianity. I think Austin is a competent and at times, compelling writer but, her religious beliefs were too distracting.
I can enjoy some inspirational themes but this was way too much and too born again for my liking.
Definitely one of the best!
When Kathleen realized how her memories of her family were so different from the way things were when they reconnected.
Lynn Austin is such an excellent writer and in this book she keeps you captivated on the characters life and growth. I love how she deals with some difficult issues in families and in spirituality and in love and forgiveness.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.