How Green Was My Valley is Richard Llewellyn’s best-selling - and timeless - classic, as well as the basis of a beloved film.
As Huw Morgan is about to leave home forever, he reminisces about the golden days of his youth when South Wales still prospered, when coal dust had not yet blackened the valley. Drawn simply and lovingly, with a crisp Welsh humor, Llewellyn’s characters fight, love, laugh, and cry, creating an indelible portrait of a people.
Richard Llewellyn (1906-1983), a Welsh novelist, was born in Hendon, England, in the county of Middlesex. Before World War II, he spent periods working in hotels, wrote a play, worked as a coal miner, and produced his best-known novel, How Green Was My Valley, as well as 19 other novels. After the war, he worked as a journalist, covering the Nuremberg Trials, and then as a screenwriter for MGM.
©1939 1940 by Richard Vivian Llewellyn Lloyd; renewed 1967 by Richard Llewellyn (P)2011 Blackstone Audio, Inc.
“A story of exquisite distinction and vibrant interest; clear and strong as the music under the sky.” (New York Times Book Review)
Tangential, eclectic, avid listener... favorite book is the one currently in ear.
I loved it! Written in 1939, it is a classic... I've read and listened to it both now. Coal mining family in South Wales seen though the eyes of the youngest son. I loved the speech patterns, the taste of the food, the honor of work, the cultural flavor and the love of a family. I loved the slowly evolving plots and complex characters. You have to be patient with this book, it is not a Dr. Pepper or bar of chocolate book. It is a rich stew, with hearty vegetables, herbs and tender chuncks of beef. There are strikes, mine collapses, young love trysts, long held grudges, fist fights, pride and sorrow... there is a family that grows, swells and forms a spider web from the valley across the world. I will listen again, if just to jot down some of the Welsh sayings I love the most... like the courting couple they called "Kiss and Scratch' for either they were overly affectionate or fighting. Go you then.
What a joy it was to read this classic book that was the basis for the 1941 Oscar Award movie by the same title. As with most books, it was ten times better than the movie, which I also very much enjoyed.
This first person narrative of a small Welsh coal mining town from decades ago, could very well be a story in present day America. This tale of the joys, trials, comradeship, faith, family, and community was underpinned with the disputes of workers seeking better salaries. But it was the faith of God and love of family that ran through all the emotions that make up a great story.
I highly recommend this classic to everyone who has yet to read the book. Superior writing also made this book a real treasure for all times!
There are certain books that I have read from this era that were so good I felt like I had the opportunity to live in that time for a while, this is one of those books. This is more than an author detailing the life of his family for posterity, it captures the culture, the personalities, and the very detail of everyday life of all the people who lived in that community. This book does more than tell a story, it brings you into the story, you are involved and invested in the many triumphs and struggles that befall the Morgan clan. The story is told in a wonderful fashion as well and is unique as a piece of literature, beautiful in what is told and what is not, the narration is also top tier as well.
This book gets a strong recommendation
This story of a Welsh coal mining family and the village they live in is lyrically written and beautifully narrated. It is not a fast book, it is a book you listen to carefully, for the sake of the language. It is an old-fashioned book, that allows you to listen to someone remembering a time long gone and a way of life that has disappeared. The Morgan family is loving and loyal and tries hard to stay true to themselves and the ideals they were raised with, even as the world is changing around them and their small village becomes a place that is filled with bitterness and poverty. But if you just listen to the melody of the language and let the story flow, I believe that this book will stay with you and move you more than you may realize at first. I loved reading it years ago and I loved listening to it as well. If you are looking for a slower-paced listen and want to savor the language and writing, give it a try!
I am a book reviewer for a Mystery Group. My favorite types are mysteries, thrillers and suspense!! Audible has been a blessing!
I have loved this book forever it seems, BUT I had never had the pleasure of having it read to me. I cannot brag enough on the quality and presentation of this Audible Book. There is nothing that compares to listening to this beloved classic with the accents and the story of a large Welsh family trying to make a living during the coal mining days that were coming to a close forcing the village to make changes that will separate their family in sad and tragic ways ... but this inspiring tale brings everything good about families and the love that makes them so strong and resilient!!
The strong message it has about dignity, strength and courage.
What a joy it was to listen to his voice and FINALLY know how to pronounce the names correctly! lol
No, this is one of those books that you want to listen to a few chapters at a time and the rest of the day you can ponder its messages.
This is one of those classics you will want to listen to over and over again ...
I felt like I was glimpsing a lost world, honestly and lovingly portrayed. I could feel the changes - the loss, over the lifetime of the narrator, of a way of life as the lovely green valley was transformed into a slag heap and the young people were forced to moved away to find work. I could see the mountains and streams. I could hear the voices sing. I grew to know and care about the community and individuals in the story.
The narrator portrayed his people in his family and others with loving stories so it is hard to pick, but perhaps it is the parents whom I appreciated the most. The father worked so hard so that his sons would have a better life. While some of his values were rigid, by today's standards, overall, he was ruled by reason and caring and retained his moral compass even when it wasn't convenient. The mother, though limited educationally, was very courageous and stood up for her husband and children at risk of her own life. I also really like the minister in town, who chose a life of helping people over material wealth.
So many great scenes it is hard to pick. One of the most vivid was the scene where the mother climbed the mountain at night to stand on a rock and admonished the mob about their evil tongues. Afterwards, on her way down, she takes a tumble and her young son saves her life, at great risk to himself - such courage!
The entire sweep of the story was moving.
While this story was written in 1939, it does not suffer from age. It is set at a period in time, but has something to teach us about our own time - universal themes.
By all accounts, the author did not, as one would assume, grow up in South Wales mining family. His portrait of that world is based largely on conversations with others. THe picture of late 19th century life in South Wales is very vivid, although obviously highly idealized in places. The language is beautiful and captures in a stylized way the idioms of the region. Sometimes, especially in the last third of the book, he gets a bit carried away trying to write something like prose poetry and it comes across as forced, or sentimental, or simply over the top. The narrator is OK, but it would be much better if he had a genuine Welsh accent. The prose would read better if read with more of a sweet lilt.
I read this book when I was much younger, maybe in my mid teens. I thought it was beautiful then and I've thought of it fondly over time. It was my turn to pick a book for my book group and I saw the opportunity to re-read it. I love it as much now as I did then and the reader did a very, very good job. I would recommend it to anybody.
This is a melancholy tale, and at the beginning, the narrator's voice had a flatness that made me fear for the rest of the book - but suddenly the animation was there, and my interest never flagged. This novel is so well written; it shows how extraordinary an ordinary life can be. The fate of the Welsh coal miners is so heartrending, yet the thread of hope is woven through; and, while the characters are their own worst enemies at times, one hopes right along with them even while knowing a sad ending is inevitable. Poignant human drama at its best.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.