The Mets made a move — and Justin had to react.

In this solo episode of Meet the Mets Fans, Justin breaks down the Mets signing Jorge Polanco to a 2-year, $40 million contract and what it says about the direction of the team under David Stearns. Is this a smart bounce-back signing or another risky bet for a roster still finding its identity?

Justin dives into Polanco’s fit in the Mets’ infield, the financial commitment, and what this move could mean for the rest of the offseason as the Mets continue reshaping the roster.

From OMG to WTF… Mets fans are still trying to process what just happened.

In Episode 11 of Meet the Mets Fans, Sid, Justin, and Stefan react to the aftermath of the Winter Meetings and what now feels like a full-scale gutting of the Mets. This isn’t a simple roster shakeup — the core is gone, Pete Alonso is gone, and David Stearns officially has a blank slate.

We hear directly from Mets fans still reeling from the Alonso departure, reflect on how quickly optimism turned into disbelief, and break down what Stearns’ vision might look like now that the team has been torn down. Plus, we dive into the latest chaos in our Group Chat Headlines segment as fan emotions continue to boil over.

If you’re a Mets fan feeling confused, angry, or just exhausted… you’re not alone.

Edwin Díaz is heading to the Dodgers, and Mets fans have thoughts. Stefan, Justin, and Sid break down the contract details, why Díaz never circled back to the Mets, and what this means for the bullpen and the offseason ahead.

We share real fan reactions from Samira, Patch Man Phil, Shaun in Wantagh, Cory from Nyack, Joey Bo, and Anthony from Fresh Meadows. Plus, we recap David Stearns’s biggest takeaways from SNY — including his comments on Pete, trade buzz, and staying disciplined at the Winter Meetings.

If you're a real Mets fan looking for clarity, therapy, or both… hit play.

The MLB Winter Meetings are here, and chaos is already brewing. In Episode 9 of Meet the Mets Fans, Stefan and Justin break down the biggest story shaking Queens: Devin Williams is officially a New York Met. What does this mean for Edwin Díaz and the back end of the bullpen?

We also share real fan reactions from every corner of Mets fandom — Geno, Stevie, Connor, Mike, Reiko, and Joe — as we explore why this move has the fanbase buzzing.

We preview all the Winter Meetings madness in our Group Chat Headlines segment, where we react to the actual screenshots lighting up our Mets group chat all week. Rumors, trade targets, Passan bombs… nothing is off the table.

To wrap things up, we play the Mets GM Game, reviewing who’s still available and debating how the Mets can realistically fill their many needs with a growing payroll and more holes than answers.

If you love Mets baseball, offseason rumors, fan reactions, and a little chaotic energy… you’re in the right place.

Join the Community

🔔 Subscribe for new Mets episodes every week

📩 DM us if YOU want to be a fan co-host on a future episode

Let’s Go Mets. 🧡💙
#LGM #Mets #DevinWilliams #WinterMeetings #MLBTrades #DavidStearns #MetsFans #MeetTheMetsFans #BaseballPodcast #EdwinDiaz #MLBRumors #MetsOffseason

BREAKING NEWS!!!

Devin Williams has reportedly been signed by the Mets to a 3 year deal worth approximately $50 Million according to Will Sammon of the Athletic.

Hear Justin and Stefan's initial reactions in the moment. A deep dive episode will follow this one featuring reactions from fans like you.

Send in your audio, video, or written reactions to have them aired on the pod. DM or email us at meetthemetsfans25@gmail.com.

Stefan and Sid welcome fan co-host Matt for a Black Friday episode breaking down the silence after the Brandon Nimmo trade. We run through this week’s group chat headlines, including the latest rumors about Framber Valdez coming to the Mets and if the locker room is an issue.

We look at the Mets’ current projected lineup, and talk through why the front office needs to act now. Then Matt takes on the Mets GM Game and each host shares their Black Friday Mets Wishlists.

DM us if you want to cohost an upcoming episode and share your Amazin’ Beginning!

Justin jumps in for a quick-hit reaction pod to break down everything David Stearns shared in his post blockbuster press conference following the stunning Brandon Nimmo trade. Stearns opened up about why the deal happened, how Marcus Semien fits into the Mets’ long-term vision, and what this move says about the franchise’s direction heading into 2026.

In this mini-episode, Justin gives us the biggest takeaways from Stearns’ comments, the moments that stood out, and what Mets fans should expect next. It’s short and perfect for anyone trying to make sense of one of the most shocking Mets trades in recent memory.

Available now on all streaming platforms.
Subscribe and join real Mets fans as we react, analyze, and ride this roller coaster together.

The Mets fanbase is SHOCKED — and so are we. In this episode of Meet the Mets Fans, Justin, Stefan, and real Mets fans just like you give their instant reaction to the blockbuster move sending Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers in exchange for Marcus Semien.

We break down:
🔵 Why the Mets moved Nimmo 🟠 What Semien brings to New York🔵 Immediate impact on the Mets lineup and clubhouse🟠 Fan reactions from across Mets Nation

Plus — Justin and Stefan tackle other major headlines around Queens and begin exploring the future of Metropolitan Park, the proposed entertainment district next to Citi Field. We discuss what it could mean for the neighborhood, Mets fans, and the entire game-day experience.

If you love Mets news, fan takes, trade breakdowns, or anything orange and blue, hit play — this is a big one.

Don’t forget to like, comment, subscribe, and share your reaction to the Nimmo trade!