Vigil

Hong Kong on the Brink

By: Jeffrey Wasserstrom

Narrated by: P.J. Ochlan

What can the massive protests that have roiled Hong Kong and the harsh repressive moves made against activists tell us about where this special metropolis is heading? And about how a resurgent China under strongman rule is challenging and reshaping the international order? Jeffrey Wasserstrom draws on his many visits to the city and his background as a specialist in the history of protests against authoritarianism to make a powerful and sobering case for the near inevitability of China’s imposing its model on Hong Kong.

Vigil tells a tale of two interrelated processes. The first involves a stop and go, but never reversing, set of moves by China’s Communist Party to minimize the many things that once made Hong Kong unlike the cities neighboring it just across the border on the mainland. The result of this has been that, since the 1997 Handover from Great Britain to China, more and more of the once clear-cut contrasts between Hong Kong and nearby urban centers such as Canton and Shenzhen - differences that decades ago were as stark as those between East Berlin and West Berlin - are lessening or going away completely.

The second process involves bold efforts by residents of Hong Kong to push back against this erosion of differences. The key actors are people who are passionately committed to defending the special qualities of a city they love - a freer press, more judicial independence, a system of rule of law rather than rule by law - against moves to diminish them made by Beijing and its local proxies. The result has been one of the great David versus Goliath stories of our time, pitting creative and determined activists, joined on the streets in recent years by ever larger numbers of Hong Kong residents, against a Chinese Communist Party whose global clout keeps growing and whose current leader, Xi Jinping, has grand ambitions for bringing all parts of the People’s Republic of China under tighter forms of control.

The result is a tale of heroism but also tragedy. Even against-all-odds longshot victories - and there have been some - can only slow a process that has led, in essence, to Hong Kong’s people becoming subjects of first the great imperial power of the 19th century and now the most important rising imperial power of the current era.

©2020 Jeffrey Wasserstrom (P)2020 Random House Audio

A disappointing read

I was expecting more from a China expert like Dr. Wasserstrom on a topic of his specialty. The book touches a little bit of everything on Hong Kong social movements from pre-hangover events to the modern-day extradition bill protest. The book seems to be written for someone who has never been to Hong Kong and doesn't know much about it. But even for an introductory book, it is flawed with a biased view without placing the HK issue within a perspective of Chinese history which should have given him much more power and deeper reflection in explaining why the protests occurred. It takes a simplistic (and lazy) view on China and never explains why the protesting in Hong Kong has gone from its democratic root to an anti-China phenomenon.