Unworthy Republic

The Dispossession of Native Americans and the Road to Indian Territory

By: Claudio Saunt

Narrated by: Stephen Bowlby

Length: 11 hrs and 36 mins

Publisher's Summary

In May 1830, the United States formally launched a policy to expel Native Americans from the East to territories west of the Mississippi River. Justified as a humanitarian enterprise, the undertaking was to be systematic and rational, overseen by Washington's small but growing bureaucracy. But as the policy unfolded over the next decade, thousands of Native Americans died under the federal government's auspices, and thousands of others lost their possessions and homelands in an orgy of fraud, intimidation, and violence.

Drawing on firsthand accounts and the voluminous records produced by the federal government, Saunt's deeply researched book argues that Indian Removal, as advocates of the policy called it, was not an inevitable chapter in US expansion across the continent. Rather, it was a fiercely contested political act designed to secure new lands for the expansion of slavery and to consolidate the power of the southern states. Indigenous peoples fought relentlessly against the policy, while many US citizens insisted that it was a betrayal of the nation's values. When Congress passed the act by a razor-thin margin, it authorized one of the first state-sponsored mass deportations in the modern era, marking a turning point for native peoples and for the United States.

©2020 Claudio Saunt (P)2020 HighBridge, a division of Recorded Books

A Slow Burn

This is history done right, a book of extraordinary scholarship, made accessible and riveting by the author’s ability to organize his research and drive home the story. What Claudio Saunt makes clear is the extent to which layers and layers of hypocrisy, self-interest and double dealing led to one of the most shameful episodes in the history of the United States. And none of it was inevitable, as Saunt makes abundantly clear.

Imagine, for example, the extreme posturing required to assert (as Georgia politicians did) that the Cherokees’ presence in the immediate vicinity of white settlers was detrimental to the Cherokees, while at the same time asserting that the black slave population’s presence was enhanced and improved by their proximity to the whites. Indian land, once reclaimed, became plantation land, with vast numbers of slaves supplanting the Cherokees who had been unceremoniously driven out of their ancestral homes.

The role of rhetoric, especially the kind known nowadays as “whataboutism” (appeal to hypocrisy) is also clearly demonstrated, with senators and representatives from the South cynically mocking the politicians and activists of the North (not without justification, but still cynically) for their treatment of Native populations on their own soil. Andrew Jackson’s role in bullying and threatening politicians with retribution unless they voted his way, and the way these politicians valued their jobs above any principles of decency and fairness again reminds me of the compliant and spineless politicians of today, who choose to ignore a multitude of wrongdoings by their leaders and are therefore deeply implicated. When your job becomes more important than your soul, something is wrong. It is both revelatory and infuriating to discover how not much has changed. Cynicism is the enemy, and lack of empathy for the plight of fellow humans, now as then.

Well narrated too! Easily a five star rating.

Truth

In order to know who we are, we have to acknowledge who we were. Willful ignorance of our past is not acceptable. Being truthful about shameful chapters of our past empowers us to be better.

Genocide by any other name

Whether it's called dispossession, expulsion, extermination, removal, or any other euphemistic turn-of-phrase a ruling body can create, it ends up the same place. Genocide. Raphael Lemkin knew this, and drew on this knowledge of colonial-settlers when he coined the phrase following the Holocaust. Powerful book, detailing all stages of the horror show, from the claims of benevolence to natives, to the final realization of all out extermination. From the dubious and/or coerced treaty farces, to the willful violation of the same, to the acknowledgement that they were nothing ever more than a means to an avaricious end.

For anyone inclined to believe the whitewashed history of the nation, I can only give this advice. Go into this book without preconception of race or ethnicity. Don't go in with the trite straw man defense that the story is claiming all of these people are wonderful, and all of those people are evil. Go in with an open mind, as a human, without a team to root for, so to speak. Let the words teach you the true history.

Eye opening!

A hard read but a necessary one to understand the history of America.Saunt's detailed synopsis of the Indian removal/extermination acts shows exactly why we should be lamenting our history instead of celebrating.

American Carnage

Excruciatingly details the cruelty and dehumanization entailed in the white conquest of America and expulsion of native Americans from their homelands to make room for expansion of the brutal slave plantation economy in the South. Essential reading for anyone who wants to come to grips with the legacy of white supremacist ideology in the United States.

Brutal Chapter in US History

this is a comprehensive, detailed history of the travesty inflicted on indigenous people in the South on the early 1830s. White Americans, driven by greed, expelled and exterminated thousands of Creeks, Cherokees, and Seminoles to take their land.

Very educational, highly recommend

Brutally honest of the atrocities committed by the United States government in the 1820-50s. This book goes into wonderful detail in how there truly was a systematic genocide and forceful removal of indigenous people near and within the growing United States. virtually none of this is covered in United States history and it is a real shame as this adds quite a bit context to both the following United States Civil War and the contemporary idea of Manifest Destiny. I appreciate that there is no real commentary because commentary allows you to then easy to skew perspective once that begins to take place. However this book constantly refers to such a numerous amount of primary sources that it gives you a very solid look into the actions of individuals and the United States government speak for themselves, and it is not pretty.

It can be a bit dry, there is virtually no commentary or break in the information given to you as it is almost entirely primary sources. However it did cause me to have to go back and rewind or take a break from time to time

Read it and Weep

This is a sad story with details that every American needs to know lest we continue down the road of raping and pillaging to line the pockets of greedy capitalists.

Awful

Wow
I got through the whole thing.
Page after Pago of disconnected anecdotes. Page after page of numbers and dollars listed.
It even ends with a recitation of the abbreviations used in footnotes. Really sorry I wasted a credit of the book

Excellent book, lots of details

Excellent book, thoroughly enjoyed it. Contains lots of details; I probably would have preferred a slightly condensed version, but it’s still a worthwhile listen.