The FBI and J. Edgar Hoover: The History and Legacy of the Federal Bureau of Investigation Under Its First Director

De: Charles River Editors

Narrado por: Bill Hare

"We are a fact-gathering organization only. We don’t clear anybody. We don’t condemn anybody.” (J. Edgar Hoover)

No single figure in 20th century American history inspires such opposing opinions as J. Edgar Hoover, the iconic first Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. In his time, he was arguably the most powerful non-elected figure in the federal government. Serving under eight presidents (and outliving two of them), he remains the longest-serving head of a major government office, and Hoover died as he began: a civil servant, having been appointed by the Attorney General and serving at the pleasure of the president. That said, no civil servant had ever accrued to themselves the power and public attention that Hoover did.

To many Americans in the 1930s, ‘40s, and ‘50s, Hoover was a real American hero. In a country suffering from the Great Depression and the crime wave of the early 1930s, Hoover was the symbol of law and order as his “G-Men” used the newest in scientific crime solving methods to bring gangsters like John Dillinger, Pretty Boy Floyd, and Baby Face Nelson to justice. In the 1940s, he protected a country at war from German and Japanese spies and saboteurs. In the 1950s, he led the charge against Soviet spies and domestic communists who he saw as undermining the institutions of the country. Every boy in the country wanted to be a G-Man, helping Mr. Hoover ferret out anyone who would harm the United States.

However, by the 1960s and 1970s, Hoover the hero had become Hoover the villain. Various exposes and investigations revealed a darker side to the legend, one that included serious violations of the civil liberties of individuals. Hoover’s G-Men, it was discovered, engaged in illegal break-ins and wiretaps of suspected subversives, wrote fake letters that undermined the reputations of public individuals, paid informants for information, and pushed the groups they belonged to into committing illegal acts. It was alleged that Hoover led a personal vendetta against Martin Luther King, Jr. and the entire Civil Rights Movement. Hoover, it was said, had stayed in office so long by gathering secret files of damaging information about politicians (including presidents) that shortly after his death in 1972, the Hoover legend was in tatters, replaced by a caricature of a vain, vindictive, power-mad petty dictator who was a closet cross-dresser.

As with most larger-than-life figures, the truth lies somewhere between two myths. Views of Hoover as hero and Hoover as villain contain elements of truth. The same man who took a small insignificant office of the Justice Department and transformed it into the premier national law enforcement agency in the world was the same man who approved (or at least had knowledge of) actions that violated the Constitution he was sworn to uphold. The director who ordered his agents in the 1960s to destroy the Ku Klux Klan when they were engaging in violent acts against Civil Rights protesters also surveyed the leading figure of the Civil Rights Movement. J. Edgar Hoover was in many ways a walking contradiction, but his apparent contradictions embodied the issues at the heart of 20th century America.

The FBI and J. Edgar Hoover: The History and Legacy of the Federal Bureau of Investigation Under Its First Director examines the events that led to the formation of the FBI, the most important cases it was involved in, and the controversies surrounding Hoover’s methods. You will learn about the FBI under Hoover like never before.

©2019 Charles River Editors (P)2020 Charles River Editors

Text Goes Here

Short and succinct review of Hoover's reign in government. The things we consider illegal in 2022 were normal in earlier times. Illuminating. This book is not subtle about pointing out Hoover's faults and jealousies.

Makes a tacked-on defense of Hoover at the end

The book is a good intro to Hoover's life, machinations, and work as FBI director. The intro, fairly, paints him as a contradictory set of opposing forces. The end of the book, however, makes an off-putting attempt to be "fair to Hoover," implying that it's unfortunate he's known for his secret files. The book ends by quoting a Lord Acton line that "great men are almost always bad men," which is not only untrue but a very thin excuse for the damaging actions Hoover took against civil liberties, the civil rights movement including Dr. King, etc. The misguided quote implies that to be a "great man," one must do damage. In Hoover's case, the damage was almost always intentional.

On the plus side, the book does mention Hoover's obsession with leftists and Reds while seemingly not caring to defend Freedom Riders of the Civil Rights movement, and having his office literally seek to blackmail King into ending his own life.

Additionally, I'm not sure why the editors felt the need to whitewash Hoover's personal life, stating that there was no evidence he ever had a partner of either sex. (I'm sure Hoover's longtime partner would have disagreed). Why the book tries too hard to cover up certain aspects of Hoover's life, I'm not sure, especially since Hoover made no attempt to protect the reputation of others.

Overall, the book tries to "be fair to" Hoover, portraying itself as balanced and not sensational, but ends up almost apologizing for his misdeeds. 3/5

Did not enjoy the narrator…monotone

Narrator was boring…no inflection. Also, the book was so short for using a whole credit.