Miss Crabtree's School for Unnaturals

The Unnaturals, Book 1

By: Hargrove Perth

Narrated by: Jonathan Johns

Length: 4 hrs and 40 mins

Publisher's summary

YA Fantasy Award Winner 2015

Deep in the woods sits an unassuming house, one not noticed by those who pass it by, but inside exists those the world has forgotten: the Unnaturals, children born with magic from an ancient source, who also possess supernatural powers that make them dangerous to the outside world. Outcasts, misunderstood, they are taken in by Miss Crabtree, the loving headmistress of the school. Here, at the School for Unnaturals, they learn to control their gifts and learn the art of spellbinding under her care.

When the war comes to England, their lives are placed in danger as the threat of the Nazis overtaking England brings a secret society called the Ahnenerbe, desiring to use the Unnaturals to give them an advantage during World War II. When an impassioned plea is made for her children to help save England, Miss Crabtree must rally her students to stand tall in the world of the Mundanes, the same world that made them outcasts. With time running out, they must fight to stay alive and out of the hands of the Nazi regime as the war rages.

©2015 Hargrove Perth (P)2018 Hargrove Perth

Spellbinding

Miss Crabtree is everything she should be; compassionate, strong, resourceful, and magical. This is a fantasy woven into the tapestry of historical WWII. It is full of colorful characters who draw you in completely. A delightful read to while away the hours of "mundane" life.

Decent kids with magic story

This story kept making me think Harry Potter since the main characters are all kids with special abilities that go to a school to get taught how to use the abilities. It is written well and narrated decently well. The narrator has a British accent which is excellent since the story takes place in England.

If there are more books I may just get them.

Just wonderful!

Just from the start, you know that you will totally enjoy this novel! The story involves a group of children and their teacher/guardian who was born with usually powers and are shunned from society.. yet during the start of WWII, it is their abilities that will make a difference. This is so worth the listening/reading and I look forward to Book 2 and find out what else will happen.

Disappointed

I don’t come across many books that I can’t finish, sadly this is one of them. I tried on several occasions to listen to this book and I just couldn’t get into it. I found myself half way though the book and not sure what was going on. I will try again another time and if my review changes, I will update.

A great start to a new series

This book comes across like Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children, and I can see the similarities, but these are are only facile ties, and Crabtree is most definitely not Peregrine. When I got this I did not realize it was YA, silly me, so I had my kids listen to it with me, and they absolutely loved it. My oldest son is a fan of the formerly named series and even he said that he liked this as much if not more.

A little warning, the book does end on a cliffhanger, so don't get your pajamas in a knot when you realize that the story isn't over. Just be happy that there is MORE coming later. The book is set in WWII, and that fits the tale. I don't know if it would work as well in modern day. . . we'll see, who knows what the future holds. The magic works, and the kids are interesting.

Johns does a great job narrating, and we can't wait to hear more of his work in the future.

I hate books without a conclusion!

This is well written and enjoyable to listen to but it just stops without giving an adequate conclusion. I hate half story cliffhanger books.

Many of the ideas in the premise of this book are not very original but they are very well told. I particularly liked the telling of Mrs Crabtree’s story. The history in the book is wonderfully written and while frightening at times, not overly detailed or graphic in a way that would scare a child of preteen age. The narrator does a wonderful job of drawing you into the story and making each character really come alive. I would have enjoyed this a lot if it simply would have drawn a conclusion. My 6th grade English teacher would have reprimanded me for something like this saying, “A story must have a beginning, a middle and an END.”

A story that takes magic to a whole new world!

This story captured me, heart and soul. Chandler Crabtree helps so many Unnaturals learn how to live amoung the mundane. Her school is a safe home for anyone who needs it. Until the Nazis begin to invade England. It is up to the students to save not only the school but their homeland as well.

Hargrove Perth completely intertwined paranormal and historical events superbly. If only the unnaturals truly existed at that time, how different the outcome could have been. I founs myself wondering that so much as the Unnaturals sought to save England. The historical hints truly made this book realistic, even though it was paranormal. The twists and turns through out it, kept me guessing.

Jonathon Johns is the perfect narrator. His accent only enhances the characters because of where the story takes place. His ability to distinguish the character is flawless. His narration truly helped create a movie in my mind as I listened.

Uniquely gifted with both magic and personality

Miss Crabtree's School for Unnaturals: The Unnaturals, Book 1

By: Hargrove Perth Narrated by: Jonathan Johns

This was an interesting story. It reminds me of a combination of Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children and Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events.
Set in England in the times of war, these children are uniquely gifted with both magic and personality. I loved all the characters and their unique “gifts”. The friendship that blossoms in this touching story is beautiful.
Miss Crabtree's School for Unnaturals is beautifully written to be a smooth read. Though not a quick read, it’s worth the time. I do have to confess that it took me a bit to be completely intrigued with this story, but once it gets you, you’re hooked. The narrator did an excellent job, which is what made it easy to give it more time.
My overall rating for Miss Crabtree's School for Unnaturals is 4 Boundless stars. I loved it. I only wish it didn’t take a while to really want to dig into it.

not what I was expecting

I like this book, it was enjoyable but I was expecting something more similar to the peculiar children books. I wanted more special gifts. I guess I just had a hard time relating to these characters. it didn't hold my attention the way I had hoped. it was still good just not great.

Nice story.

I loved all the detail and the story. It was interesting the whole way through.