Metaphysical Animals

How Four Women Brought Philosophy Back to Life

De: Clare Mac Cumhaill, Rachael Wiseman

Narrado por: Alex Dunmore

A NEW YORK TIMES BOOK REVIEW BEST BOOK OF THE YEAR • A vibrant portrait of four college friends—Iris Murdoch, Philippa Foot, Elizabeth Anscombe, and Mary Midgley—who formed a new philosophical tradition while Oxford's men were away fighting World War II.

The history of European philosophy is usually constructed from the work of men. In Metaphysical Animals, a pioneering group biography, Clare Mac Cumhaill and Rachael Wiseman offer a compelling alternative. In the mid-twentieth century Elizabeth Anscombe, Mary Midgley, Philippa Foot, and Iris Murdoch were philosophy students at Oxford when most male undergraduates and many tutors were conscripted away to fight in the Second World War. Together, these young women, all friends, developed a philosophy that could respond to the war’s darkest revelations.

Neither the great Enlightenment thinkers of the past, the logical innovators of the early twentieth century, or the new Existentialist philosophy trickling across the Channel, could make sense of this new human reality of limitless depravity and destructive power, the women felt. Their answer was to bring philosophy back to life. We are metaphysical animals, they realized, creatures that can question their very being. Who am I? What is freedom? What is human goodness? The answers we give, they believed, shape what we will become.

Written with expertise and flair, Metaphysical Animals is a lively portrait of women who shared ideas, but also apartments, clothes and even lovers. Mac Cumhaill and Wiseman show how from the disorder and despair of the war, four brilliant friends created a way of ethical thinking that is there for us today.

A crucial story for moral philosophy

I’ve long been a student of Iris Murdoch’s philosophical work. She opened a space for me to engage crucial moral questions of attention, love, unselfing and just vision, which were otherwise ignored in my analytic education. hearing the story of her colleagues in the wider context of their setting was a pleasure. The narrator brings their voices to life, even adjusting her accent so we can hear Murdoch, Anscombe, Midgley and Foot in their particularity. Delightful!

I love the book as much as I love the performance

This book is incredible, I’m utterly convinced that these women were the greatest minds of their generation in philosophy. Also Alix Dunmore is SPECTACULAR.

Important

The revival of Metaphysics by these four women philosophers is a service to post war philosophy. A service that lives on today. They are also pioneers for equal opportunity. The Audible performance was one of the best I have heard. The content was a necessary balance between their humanity and their work. Excellent.

Four Greats

Excellent in every respect: cogently argued, beautifully read, the French pronounced perfectly. Readers interested in philosophy will thoroughly enjoy getting to know these four greats: Anscombe, Foot, Midgely, and Murdoch. Highly recommended! ppc

Excellent

Worth the listen. Looking forward to reading. This story brings philosophy to life. It is an introduction to four philosophers that we should all wrestle with as we journey on our philosophical quest.

Fundamental

The best is the narration, the content is fundamental, for it gives the essential elements of philosophy for a better future. The story sometimes goes into superfluous, though decoratively pretty, elements.

Excellent. Long awaited.

As a woman grad student facing bias, harassment, and sexual assault the example of these women was a source of strength and perseverance. Thank you to the authors. Also an excellent performance.

Excellent in every way, plus…

A deft weaving of the philosophers’ lives and times and the development of their thinking. A celebration of the fruits of particularity and relationship.

I also greatly enjoyed the intimate portrayals of other important philosophers, particularly insightful (and at times charming) regarding Wittgenstein.

Book about nothing

I found the book the book empty
Just a marketing “scheme”
Nothing on serious philosophy
Just a gender revanche