Doomsday Book

De: Connie Willis

Narrado por: Jenny Sterlin

One of the most respected and awarded of all contemporary science-fiction writers, Connie Willis repeatedly amazes her many admiring fans with her ability to create vivid characters in unusual situations. With Doomsday Book, she takes listeners on a thrilling trip through time to discover the things that make us most human.

For Oxford student Kivrin, traveling back to the 14th century is more than the culmination of her studies - it's the chance for a wonderful adventure. For Dunworthy, her mentor, it is cause for intense worry about the thousands of things that could go wrong. When an accident leaves Kivrin trapped in one of the deadliest eras in human history, the two find themselves in equally gripping - and oddly connected - struggles to survive.

Deftly juggling stories from the 14th and 21st centuries, Willis provides thrilling action - as well as an insightful examination of the things that connect human beings to each other.

©1992 Connie Willis (P)2000 Recorded Books

Reseñas de la Crítica

• Hugo Award, Best Novel, 1993
• Nebula Award, Best Novel, 1992

"Ms. Willis displays impressive control of her material; virtually every detail introduced in the early chapters is made to pay off as the separate threads of the story are brought together." (The New York Times Book Review)
"A stunning novel that encompasses both suffering and hope....The best work yet from one of science fiction's best writers." (The Denver Post)

Cut by half would have made it twice as good.

We're in the middle of the 21st century, and a group of Oxford scholars are now able to travel back in time. Young student Kivrin Engle has a passion for the middle ages, and the object of the next study involves traveling to the 14th century Oxford region in 1320, well before the arrival of the bubonic plague of 1348 which killed off entire villages. Kivrin has spent years preparing for this trip, and even though professor Dunworthy thinks her too young and worries the trip is fraught with too many dangers, she hasn't wasted time learning Middle English and Latin and the various tasks and labours expected of the young noblewoman she is meant to impersonate. But things have gone wrong from the start. When she arrives in the 14th century, she is badly disoriented and falls gravely ill. She is found and brought to the home of a family who do their best to nurse her back to health, but though she has spent many dedicated months to prepare for this journey, she soon discovers all her studies have been for naught, because for one thing, she can't communicate with them. Meanwhile, in the Oxford of the 21st century, things are going very wrong too. Badri Chaudhuri, the young technician responsible for setting up the apparatus for Kivrin's time travel, seeks out Dunworthy to tell him that "something is very wrong", but he can say no more than that, having fallen gravely ill and suffering from high fevers which put his life at risk, so that all he is able to communicate through the better half of this lengthy novel is that "something is wrong" over and over and over again.

The very beginning of the story showed great promise, and I found all the details about 14th century England fascinating, but I felt that for at least the first half of the narrative barely anything happened at all and we were circling round the same details again and again, as if in a bad dream. I quickly lost patience and was ready to give up, but so many fans of this book assured me it was well worth the effort that I stuck to it. The story that finally emerges is a good one, but I would probably have enjoyed it more had there been a serious editing job done, since so much of the book was taken up with what seemed like filler. Had the novel been cut by half, I would probably have thought it was pretty great, but as it is I have a hard time believing that it won prestigious awards (the Hugo, Nebula and Locus awards among many others), and had to overcome a lot of frustration to finish it. I think I found a reasonable compromise with my current rating.

You might love it completely, and then again, you may not.

Not What I Hoped For

Is there anything you would change about this book?

How many characters do I get? My sub-title for this book is "Or What Happens When Stupid People Get Time Travel." The bone-headedness of all of the characters was immensely frustrating as were the half-baked futuristic elements. We've got time travel, but we're still frustrated by "phone outages" and characters asking to borrow phones although in 1992, cell phones weren't unknown. Surely the author could have seen a future with them? No one can look up an NHS number. There's been a worldwide flu pandemic, but Christmas vacation means no one can do anything. Does anyone actually believe the CDC says "sorry, they're on vacation" when a possible pandemic is in the works? Entire hours are seem to be wasted on the inability of the quarantine area receiving supplies. First: not gonna happen that way, and two, probably not the reason you picked up the book. You probably picked it up wanted to read about life in the 14th century, and there's precious little of that.

How would you have changed the story to make it more enjoyable?

Characters that are smart and capable. The characters were all so slow on the uptake. Forgetting important concepts until 10 minutes into the conversation. I'd be mentally reminding them to ask about "X" while I listened to character blab on about stupid stuff that wasn't story. The historian is particularly susceptible to being an idiot, taking forever to realize what's going on (The whole "wicked man" episode in the church was particularly grating.) There was so little actual medieval history or culture in this book, IMO, and waaaaay too many annoying children (yes, there are TWO.) Also, some resolution to where the actual director of History had gone off too. They spend the entire book looking for him, entire sections devoted to "finding Basingham (?)"

What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?

My frustration with the characters probably has roots in the way the reader would repeat a question like she'd never heard of the concept before. Typical exchange: "Yes, but what if Kivrin catches the flu?" "Kivrin?" said like they'd never heard the name before. OMG. It was head-bashing frustration at times to listen to this book.

If this book were a movie would you go see it?

Probably because a movie would certainly cut out all of the over-writing. If this author could find a way to make something more time-consuming, she would. Everything skitters out of reach requiring a second try. Everyone gets sick and has to bring the story to a stop while we have scene after scene of "no visitors!" or "you're not supposed to be out of bed."

Any additional comments?

What sold me on this book was the fact it had won both the Hugo and Nebula awards. As science fiction, I found it lacking. As history, I found it lacking. By the time the "real" story starts, you're ten hours in. This book would have been more enjoyable with a length of maybe 15 hours.

Good if you want to be depressed

I had read Connie Willis' book, To Say Nothing of the Dog. It was lighthearted, historically interesting, fun. This was dark, dismal, historically interesting and so depressing. A good read if you don't mind death, pestulence, putrification. I couldn't wait for it to end.

Stunning, moving, thought-provoking

This is a long book, and I think it was good that I happened to be able to listen to it when I had long stretches of uninterrupted time. I was able to be drawn fully into the story. It might not be an easy book to listen to in short stretches.

I found it emotionally wrenching - the details were so vivid and the characters and situations so compelling. As others have noted, not all of the endings are happy ones. I couldn't wait to listen to more because I wanted to know what happened. I was very sorry to reach the end, and found myself thinking about it for weeks, and telling others about the book, too. (I did that also with Blackout and All Clear - highly recommend them.)

Connie Willis's attention to historical detail is amazing. I became fascinated by the particulars of daily life in the Middle Ages, which are presented in a way to make the characters and situations come to life.

There are parallel plots, one set in the current day of the time travelers and one set in the middle ages. The intertwining of these situations caused me to reflect on our attitudes towards medicine, technology, and faith. Each society's assumptions and beliefs play a role in the story.

An entertaining story

The science fiction elements are few but required as they are the bits that allow the story to be. The people are the bones that walk the story forwards. An interesting presentation (flashing back and forth between times and situations) of memorable characters.

Simply wonderful!

Yes, this book is long. Yes, this book is detailed. But these are two of the things that make this book really great. The performance was incredible, and you really felt like the characters were real. The story comes alive. It is poignant and heart wrenching, but so wonderful. WONDERFUL!!

An endless back and forth

Seems to be needlessly drawn out with something ALWAYS, ALWAYS standing in the way of our heroin discovering the obvious. It's a very tedious listen.

Litlle long, but very engaging

I have to agree with most listeners' reviews for this book - it could be edited down to 40% of original length before it would start loosing details. But if you, like me, listening to audiobooks while working it's actually a plus - if you spaced and missed something, the narrative will loop around to revisit missed plot point again. And maybe again sometimes later.

The story is very character driven but i was hoping for more historical details. Both in the future and past plotlines focus on human interactions, which is great, but could use little more backdrop, so to say. Main characters are very endearing - and maybe just a touch too anecdotal - every female from the future plot sounds like Mrs Marple.

Everyone who is complaining about state of technology in the future part of the novel has to realize that the book was written in the 90s', way before smartphones, WiFi, GPS devices and other awesome things we're so used to take for granted. Yes, it sounds a little odd now that someone would have to sit by the landline phone waiting for a call in 2056, but future ain't what it used to be, eh?

I was so sorry that it was over!

I absolutely love this book. The story is wonderful and the narrator is fantastic!

Enthralling, funny, compassionate and wonderful

I have now listened to this book a second time, simply to enjoy it once more and i did enjoy it just as much as the first.

The story is engrossing. A very different variation on the time travel genre, I love the way it interweaves the 14th and 21st centuries.

I found myself totally enthralled by the story, really caring about the characters, crying and laughing. What more can one ask from a book?