Frankenstein, Death, and Original Sin

Episode 11 —

Frankenstein, Death, and Original Sin

This episode explores Frankenstein by Mary Shelley as more than a warning about science—it’s a story about death, the human will, and what happens when traditional theological frameworks collapse.

🧭 Core Idea

In earlier Christian thought—seen clearly in Paradise Lost—the pattern is:

sin → death

But in Frankenstein, that pattern is reversed:

death → becomes the engine that drives human action

The novel presents a world where death is no longer explained within a theological framework, but becomes the central problem shaping everything.

⚔️ Historical and Theological Background

• John Milton writes within a world shaped by:
  • Reformation theology
  • divine sovereignty
  • human fallenness
• John Calvin and later thinkers emphasize:
  • the brokenness of the human will
  • salvation as something given
• By Shelley’s time:
  • these ideas are still present
  • but increasingly questioned and rejected
• William Godwin (Shelley’s father):
  • raised in a Calvinist environment
  • rejects it in favor of reason and human perfectibility
• Mary Wollstonecraft (her mother):
  • rejects the idea that humans are born ruined
  • retains belief in moral progress

💀 Death as the Engine

In Frankenstein:

• The death of Victor’s mother becomes the turning point
• Death is no longer a consequence—it becomes the driving force
• Fear of death leads to:
  • control
  • technological intervention
  • desecration of the human body

The grave becomes a resource. The body becomes material.

🧠 The Will: Control vs. Trust

Victor’s response to death reveals a deeper tension:

• The will is active, but shaped by fear
• Faced with death, there are two paths:

1. Resurrection (received)
   • death is not final
   • not ours to overcome
2. Control (attempted)
   • death must be defeated directly
   • leads to manipulation and violation

Victor chooses control.

🧩 The Creature and Belonging

The Creature reads Paradise Lost and asks:

Am I Adam… or a fallen angel?

• He begins with longing and moral awareness
• He seeks relationship and acceptance
• He is consistently rejected

His turning point comes when:

he concludes he will never be received

This leads to:

• collapse of hope
• emergence of rage

⚡ Key Question

The novel leaves a central question unresolved:

Are we corrupt because of how we are made… or do we become destructive because death is already at work?

🔥 The Horror

The real fear in Frankenstein is not the Creature itself—

it is the recognition that his transformation makes sense

Under the same conditions:

• isolation
• rejection
• fear of death

we would become him

✝️ Final Reflection

The episode closes with a contrast:

• If death is ultimate → fear drives everything
• If resurrection is real → death is not the final authority

The question is not whether we face death— but how we face it.

🎯 Key Takeaway

We don’t escape becoming the Creature by overcoming death— but by trusting that death has already been overcome.