A Great and Terrible King

Edward I and the Forging of Britain

De: Marc Morris

Narrado por: Ralph Lister

Edward I is familiar to millions as "Longshanks", conqueror of Scotland and nemesis of Sir William Wallace (in Braveheart). Yet this story forms only the final chapter of the king's action-packed life. Earlier, Edward had defeated and killed the famous Simon de Montfort, traveled to the Holy Land, and conquered Wales. He raised the greatest armies of the Middle Ages and summoned the largest parliaments. Notoriously, he expelled all the Jews from his kingdom.

In this audiobook, Marc Morris examines afresh the forces that drove Edward throughout his relentless career: his character, his Christian faith, and his sense of England's destiny - a sense shaped in particular by the tales of the legendary King Arthur. He also explores the competing reasons that led Edward's opponents (including Robert Bruce) to resist him.

©2009 Marc Morris (P)2015 Tantor

Reseñas de la Crítica

"[V]ivid details and an engaging narrative style bring the man and his period to life." ( Library Journal)

Fascinating

A very compelling narrative of the life of a complicated monarch, and very engagingly narrated.

Outstanding Scholarship

Marc Morris knows his topic inside and out. This is a most detailed biography of a great warrior king, who subjugated Britain. Edward I was a commanding and brutal king. This book is most balanced in its portrayal of Edward. One really needs an outline and family tree to keep all the main players straight. Well done. And Ralph Lister completes the masterpiece. Well done.

Best Narrator of All Time

What made the experience of listening to A Great and Terrible King the most enjoyable?

Hands down the best audio book narration to date. Not only a great, and fascinating book, but the story comes alive with the voice of Ralph Lister's narration.

What other book might you compare A Great and Terrible King to and why?

The Life of Elizabeth I by Alison Weir.

Well researched

Really enjoyed the narrative, information, and narrator. I highly recommend as a good peek into an interesting character.

Narrator and Book are Both Very Good

Would you consider the audio edition of A Great and Terrible King to be better than the print version?

yes, the narrator really did a great job . Makes reading so much more enjoyable!

What other book might you compare A Great and Terrible King to and why?

"The Norman Conquest" was also a very good book by same author and also had a very good narrator. (Despite the negative reviews on the narrator of that book...I thought his way of reading was very interesting and fitted the history...((As does the narrator of this book by Marc Morris))

Which scene was your favorite?

not sure yet..as still "Reading " it

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

no..this is a book to listen to again and again to get all the details fully understood

Any additional comments?

very happy with the book and performance of narrator

Detailed and fascinating

Marc Morris presents an enormous amount of information in a well-organized, accessible, and compelling narrative. My only real complaint is the time he spends in the last chapter rationalizing some of Edward's many flaws. For example, Edward banished all Jews from England: Morris admits that he was antisemitic, but defends him on the grounds - paraphrasing here - that so was every one else.

(I was also irritated that he issues a blanket denial that there is any historical basis for the legends of King Arthur. He may well be right, but I'm not willing to surrender my illusions that easily. Fortunately he didn't go after Robin Hood too - that would have been a definite deal-breaker.)

Edward comes across in the book as a man of intense concentration and single-mindedness, someone who could temporarily set aside one goal - going on Crusade - to pursue a different one - subjugating Scotland - but who always came back, as soon as possible, to the first goal. His problems were legion. He fought wars against Wales, Scotland, Ireland, and France, succeeding definitively only in the first one. He struggled to maintain the rights of the king, over against the rights of the people. He was a king cast from the assertive, warlike mold.

Ralph Lister is an excellent narrator, maintaining a clear and crisp pace throughout. Despite my nitpicking about this or that point, I enjoyed the listen and would - and will - definitely do it again.

Very detailed but rich story

Overall I enjoyed this book but be ready for a lot of specific detail. The performance is excellent and seems “spot on” for the material. The academic research behind this book is impressive and the amount of detail available after 800 years is amazing. The writer has done a nice job distilling most aspects down into their relevant, intertwined pieces. When finished you will have what feels to be a full portrait of Edward I, his motivations and conquests, his weaknesses and failures. I appreciate so much more the nobility of Edward I that is completely left out of pop culture references and movies. He deserves for people to have this kind of complete picture available to modern readers. However, this book may have found a wider readership with fewer obscure details about this march and that campaign and these minor lords and those lessor characters. In all though, recommended!

Interesting but bias and lost me at the end

Didn't waste my time and the book is interesting, well researched and thorough. I just felt it was too "great king" focused especially as he got older, it lost me because based on what I was hearing he was way more "terrible". I felt the evidence and interpretation did not match and it kept me mentally stopping as I assessed the difference and then mentally rolled my eyes by the end. Still worth a read though.

Brought King Edward I to vivid life

I liked the focus on analyzing the King's motives and behavior, while discussing his decisions and the events of the late 13th century. Narrator was excellent.

Good storytelling, Compelling story.

If you enjoy English history, this account of the life of King Edward I (Edward Longshanks) is entertaining, detailed, and the performer is animated and easy to understand.
It is also sourced well if you would like to do further research based on this author's assertions.