In this chilling episode of Pod Candy: Cults, Crimes & Killers, Stacey Flaster and Dori Goldman unpack Netflix’s shocking true-crime documentary Unknown Number: The High School Catfish. What begins as a disturbing case of anonymous harassment among Michigan teens quickly spirals into one of the most jaw-dropping catfishing stories ever told.
Joined by forensic psychologist Dr. John Mayer, the hosts break down the psychology of this disturbing case—from “cyber-Munchausen” and parental obsession to the long-term trauma of betrayal and emotional control. Together they ask: what drives a parent to become the villain in their own child’s story?

Netflix may be shining a new spotlight on one of America’s most disturbing figures with Monster: The Ed Gein Story, but Pod Candy was there first. In this chilling mashup episode, hosts Stacey and Dr. John Mayer revisit their most fascinating and unnerving conversations about the real-life “Butcher of Plainfield.” With commentary from Dori, filmmaker Alex Flaster (who produced the A&E Biography on Ed Gein), and horror expert Adam Rockoff, they explore how Gein’s twisted legacy gave birth to icons like Norman Bates, Buffalo Bill, and Leatherface.

From Gein’s psychologically stunted upbringing under a fanatical mother to the macabre crimes that redefined horror, this episode dives deep into what made him both a monster and a myth. Plus, Adam returns to give his brutally honest take on Netflix’s new dramatization — what it got right, what it got wrong, and why fiction can’t compete with the horrifying truth.

Warning: Graphic discussion of real crimes and disturbing behavior.

Source Material: "A&E Biography: Ed Gein" (on A&E) & "Monster: The Ed Gein Story" (on Netflix)

In 1998, 23-year-old Amy Lynn Bradley vanished without a trace from a Caribbean cruise ship — and her story has haunted the world ever since. In this episode, Stacey, Dori, and Dr. John unpack one of the most chilling disappearances in modern history: Was Amy the victim of foul play, suicide, or something even darker like human trafficking?

From the baffling eyewitness sightings to the disturbing photos that surfaced years later, the hosts dive deep into every theory — mixing compassion, shock, and their trademark dark humor. Join the Pod Candy crew as they sift through the evidence, question the cruise line’s actions, and confront the eerie possibility that Amy Bradley might still be alive.

Stacey and Dori turn their attention to Teal Swan, a spiritual influencer whose teachings on healing and suicide have made her both magnetic and deeply controversial. Drawing from the docuseries The Deep End, the hosts unpack how Swan shapes her image, the unsettling dynamics within her inner circle, and why so many vulnerable people are drawn into her orbit. With Dr. John weighing in, the conversation digs into the psychology of manipulation, the ethics of self-proclaimed healers, and what this story reveals about belief, control, and the human need for answers.

Source Documentary: "The Deep End" on Prime Video

In this episode of Pod Candy, Stacey and Dori dive into Betting on Zero and expose the dark underbelly of Herbalife—a company accused of preying on vulnerable communities under the guise of opportunity. Joined by Dr. John, they peel back the layers of manipulation, exploitation, and broken promises that define multi-level marketing. In a groundbreaking moment, the hosts identify a new cult category—the “MLM Cult”—where recruitment replaces retail and loyalty is leveraged like currency. Is it a business, a scam, or something far more sinister? Tune in as they unpack the psychology, the players, and the real-world impact of this modern-day money cult.

Source Documentary: "Betting on Zero" on YouTube TV

In this powerful episode of Pod Candy, Stacey and Dori dive into Surviving Ohio State, the documentary exposing one of the largest sexual abuse scandals in U.S. history. They discuss the decades of abuse committed by Dr. Richard Strauss, the silence of Ohio State University, and the devastating toll on more than 300 male athletes whose voices went unheard for far too long.

Joined by Dr. John Mayer, the conversation unpacks the systemic failures that protected power over people, the stigma male survivors face, and the long shadows abuse casts over a life. From whistleblowers and cover-ups to the lasting trauma carried by survivors, this episode asks hard questions about accountability, justice, and the courage it takes to speak the truth.

Source Documentary: Surviving Ohio State on HBO Max.

If you’re a survivor or supporting one, resources are linked in the show notes. You are not alone.

This week on PodCandy, Stacey and Dori dive into the disturbing case of Keith Hunter Jespersen—infamously known as the Happy Face Killer. A seemingly average long-haul trucker turned serial murderer, Jespersen left a trail of victims across the country while signing his confessions with a chilling smiley face.

Dr. John helps to dissect Jespersen’s psychology, exploring his need for control, lack of remorse, and what might have triggered his violent outbursts. They discuss the challenges of catching a killer who operated in plain sight, the tragic misidentification of suspects, and the devastating impact on victims’ families—including Jespersen’s own daughter.

As always, Stacey and Dori bring their signature mix of dark curiosity and unexpected humor, asking the big questions: What makes someone snap? Why do some killers crave attention, while others lurk in the shadows? And is it ever okay to say a serial killer was… kind of cute?

Source Documentary: "The Happy Face Killer: Mind of a Monster" on Discovery+ via Prime Video.

In this powerful and disturbing episode, Stacey, Dori, and Dr. John take a deep dive into Shiny Happy People, the chilling docuseries exposing the Duggar family and their ties to the Institute in Basic Life Principles (IBLP), a fundamentalist Christian organization led by the controversial Bill Gothard. What lies beneath the surface of big smiles and modesty? Abuse, control, and a dangerous culture of silence.

The hosts dissect the teachings and tactics of IBLP, including blanket training, purity culture, and the cult-like authoritarian system that robbed countless women and children of agency and safety. With raw honesty and expert insight, they explore how this toxic ideology went mainstream—fueled by TLC’s reality TV empire—and how survivors are now bravely breaking their silence.