Are criminals born that way, or does life create them?

In this episode of Killing Time with Friends, Billy, Melanie, and Hope explore one of the biggest questions in psychology and criminology: Nature vs. Nurture.

We dive into brain science, trauma, genetics, and real criminal cases to explore how violent behavior develops. From the shocking story of Phineas Gage to the controversial twin separation studies, we look at the science behind personality, impulse control, and behavior.

We also examine well-known criminals like Aaron Hernandez, Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, and Richard Ramirez to ask whether their crimes were influenced more by biology, upbringing, or a complex mix of both.

By the end of the episode, we ask a difficult question:
Are killers created… or discovered?

This episode explores the psychology behind crime while emphasizing the importance of mental health awareness and early intervention.

Listen, think, and decide for yourself.

00:00 Intro
00:42 The Big Question: Are Criminals Born or Made?
02:14 Brain Science & Behavior
03:40 The Phineas Gage Case
05:03 Charles Whitman & the Brain Tumor Discovery
10:08 Mental Health Stigma & Early Intervention
17:01 Suicide & Crisis Resources
17:25 The Twin Separation Experiment
18:00 The Story of the Identical Triplets
26:50 The Dark Truth Behind the Adoption Study
31:20 Tragic Outcome & Ethical Questions
39:41 Famous Criminal Case Studies Begin
40:00 Aaron Hernandez & CTE Brain Damage
41:55 Ted Bundy: Psychopathy or Environment?
42:52 Jeffrey Dahmer & Early Warning Signs
44:05 Richard Ramirez & Violent Childhood
44:34 The Stanford Prison Experiment
45:59 The Movie "Trading Places" & Environment Theory
47:33 Group Debate: Nature vs Nurture
51:10 The Quote: “Genes Load the Gun, Environment Pulls the Trigger”
52:20 Billy’s Final Thoughts on Prevention & Responsibility
57:24 Final Reflections & Mental Health Awareness
58:32 Outro

A tragic school shooting in Georgia left four people dead and many others injured. But the trial that followed raised an even bigger legal question.

Should a parent be criminally responsible for the actions of their child?

In this episode of Killing Time With Friends, Billy, Melanie, and Hope break down the case of Colin Gray, the father of the Apalachee High School shooter. Prosecutors argued that by failing to secure firearms and ignoring warning signs, Gray created the conditions that led to the attack.

But the debate isn’t that simple.

Was this criminal negligence, or is the law being stretched beyond its limits?

The hosts examine:

• The timeline leading up to the shooting
• Warning signs that may have been missed
• The role of schools and mental health support
• The legal arguments behind the charges
• Whether the verdict sets a dangerous precedent

This episode includes a respectful discussion honoring the victims while exploring the difficult legal and ethical questions surrounding parental responsibility.

We also want to hear your perspective.

Do you believe the verdict was justified ... or does it open the door to criminalizing bad parenting?

Comment below and join the discussion.

Watch, listen, and kill some time with us.

🔗 Listen to the podcast everywhere:
https://killingtimewithfriends.com

00:00 Intro
00:45 Introducing the Colin Gray case
01:12 The Apalachee High School shooting
02:05 Why this case hit close to home in Georgia
04:57 Colt Gray’s home life and family background
06:56 The day of the shooting
10:03 Access to firearms in the home
14:49 Evidence photos and gun access discussion
16:17 The Discord threats and FBI warning
19:08 Warning signs and troubling behavior
24:27 The father’s reaction after the shooting
26:00 The trial and testimony
29:21 Verdict: guilty on all charges
30:39 Mental health perspective from a school counselor
34:50 The school counselor’s timeline and response
36:05 The mistaken identity moment at school
39:05 Billy argues the father should be not guilty
42:11 The legal debate: responsibility vs intent
46:49 Reviewing the charges against Colin Gray
50:01 Is bad parenting the same as murder?
54:17 Should parents be criminally liable for their child’s crimes?
57:17 What legal standard should apply to parents?
1:00:05 Jury bias and emotional influence
1:03:00 Hypothetical legal scenario debate
1:07:13 Could the jury have been wrong?
1:09:10 Honoring the victims
1:10:41 The lasting impact on students and educators
1:11:09 Final thoughts

In December 1968, 20-year-old Emory University student Barbara Mackle was kidnapped from a motel in the Atlanta area and buried alive inside a fiberglass box underground.

She had seven days of air.

For 83 terrifying hours, no one knew if she would survive.

But this story doesn’t end with her rescue.

The man responsible - Gary Steven Krist - served his sentence, reinvented himself, and decades later became a licensed physician. Until he was arrested again… this time for running an underground cocaine lab.

Three friends. Dark cases. Real questions.

killingtimewithfriends.com

Chapters

• 00:00 The Chilling Survival Story of Barbara Mackle
• 09:30 The Kidnapping and Burial
• 17:04 The Aftermath and Rehabilitation
• 25:43 Victims Profiting from Trauma
• 32:20 Gary's Downfall and Legal Troubles
• 37:20 Total Rehabilitation and Permanent Consequences
• 42:48 Violent Criminals in Professions

Sources

“Woman Is Sought in Mackle Case,” UPI, Dec. 23, 1968

“Making an Impact,” Time Magazine, Jan. 3, 1969

“South Florida’s Crimes of the Century Riveted the Nation,” by Edna Buchanan, Miami Herald, Sept. 15, 2002

“Kidnapper Now a Smuggling Suspect,” Atlanta Journal-Constitution, March 11, 2006

“Sentencing Delayed for Drug Smuggler,” by Todd Defeo, Athens (Ga.) Banner-Herald, Aug. 9, 2006

https://people.com/barbara-mackle-kidnapping-buried-alive-8736831

https://www.coastalbreezenews.com/columnists/the-daring-kidnapping-of-barbara-mackle-part-1-of-3/article_0823b341-edc0-540d-8d52-6f8e48bcc48a.html

http://www.atlantatimemachine.com/commercialbldgs/clairmont_1706.htm

https://abcnews.com/US/story?id=91055&page=1

https://openlibrary.org/books/OL5078353M/83_hours_till_dawn

https://www.14news.com/story/1422081/town-left-without-a-doctor/

https://www.coastalbreezenews.com/news/who-dunnit-anatomy-of-an-egomaniacal-con-artist/article_f0eefeee-e416-11ef-ae1a-23edb9fc3b68.html

https://www.fbi.gov/wanted/topten/topten-history/hires_images/FBI-292GaryStevenKrist.jpg/view

https://crimelibrary.org/gangsters_outlaws/outlaws/gary_krist/

https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/son-of-sam-laws/

In 1994, 19-year-old Emory University student Shannon Melendi vanished in Atlanta.

There was no body.

Years later, a man was convicted of her murder.

But here’s the question we couldn’t stop asking:

Could you say “guilty” without a body?

In this episode of Killing Time with Friends, we dive into the disappearance of Shannon Melendi, the investigation that followed, and Georgia’s first murder conviction without a body. We unpack the forensic breakthroughs, the delayed justice, and the emotional toll on her family — and then we wrestle with the bigger question:

Is justice about certainty… or probability?

🕯️ Dark stories. Real questions.

👇 We want to hear from you:
If you were on that jury, could you say “guilty” without a body?

Sources:

Forensic Files

Southern Fried True Crime

Mom and Mysteries True Crime Podcast

Petition: https://c.org/9K9ZtbwnJK

Check out this Facebook group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/290132543635/

🎙️ Follow & Subscribe for new cases every week.

#TrueCrime #ShannonMelendi #AtlantaCrime #ColdCase #NoBodyCase #JusticeSystem #TrueCrimePodcast

killingtimewithfriends.com

The Murder of Marilyn Mitchell | Alabama, 1990

In this episode of Killing Time With Friends, we break down the murder of Marilyn Mitchell, a 1990 Alabama case that still raises questions decades later.

What really happened that night?
Was this premeditated — or something else entirely?

We explore:
• The timeline
• The key players
• The evidence
• The unanswered questions

🎧 New episodes weekly.
📲 Follow us for clips and updates.

Source Material
* https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/al-court-of-criminal-appeals/1116891.html
* https://www.wtvy.com/2022/05/10/32-years-later-this-convicted-nurse-killer-awaits-execution/?outputType=amp
* https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-almd-1_05-cv-00831/pdf/USCOURTS-almd-1_05-cv-00831-0.pdf

Tags: #MarilynMitchell #TrueCrime #Podcast #KillingTimeWithFriends #ColdCase #DothanAlabama #CrimeStory #Justice

The first episode of the Billy and Mel Kill Time podcast introduces the hosts' fascination with true crime and their exploration of criminal psychology. They discuss the impact of court cases, the nature vs. nurture debate, and the Brian Nichols case. The conversation delves into the psychology of true crime interest, the desensitization and empathy of true crime enthusiasts, and the role of media in true crime reporting. The hosts also explore the line between curiosity and exploitation in true crime content. The conversation delves into the attraction to infamous figures, the tension between humor and empathy in true crime content, personal stories and reflections on specific cases, and the obsession with true crime as a mirror for self-reflection and understanding societal red flags.

Takeaways

• Curiosity vs. Exploitation
• Desensitization and Empathy
• Media's Role in True Crime Reporting Understanding the balance of humor and empathy in true crime content
• The importance of recognizing and reporting potential red flags in society

Tags: True Crime, Criminal Psychology, O.J. Simpson, Brian Nichols, Serial Killers, Podcast, Crime Stories, Justice System, Mental Health, Crime Enthusiasts.

#TrueCrime #Podcast #BillyAndMel #CrimeObsessed #SerialKiller #MurderMystery #CrimeStories #TrueCrimeCommunity #CriminalPsychology #Podcasting