The three mustaches stock up on garlic and holy water to hunt down a Midwest vampire. When Sydney Loofe met a young woman named Audrey on Tinder, she thought she had hit the jackpot. Audrey was fun, attractive, and always had some really good weed. But, unbeknownst to Sidney, her new love interest was hiding a dark secret that involved black magic, ritualistic sacrifices, and the occult. Keep a wooden stake close at hand because there's a vampire loose in Nebraska.

The three mustaches grab their hair gel and touch up their spray tans to cover a controversial case from New Jersey. In the Spring of 2004, suitcases began washing up on the shores of the Chesapeake Bay. Inside were the dismembered remains of a Jersey native named Bill McGuire. As investigators began unraveling the mystery surrounding the case, they discovered a toxic relationship filled with gambling, infidelity, and lies. But, was it Bill's scorned wife that committed the murder, or was it an old-fashioned mob hit? Whatever you do, don't ask Ryan about it. Apparently talking about New Jersey really sets him off...

The three mustaches hop in their time machine and travel back to 1989 to tell the story of Patricia Stallings. When Patricia and her husband David rushed their three-month-old son Ryan to the emergency room, doctors were at a loss. The infant's symptoms seemed to caused by ethylene glycol poisoning. But, his loving parents wouldn't slip anti-freeze into his bottle... would they? For a mystery like this, we're going to need a little help from the Godfather of True Crime, Robert Stack.

The three mustaches brace themselves for the brutal conclusion of the life and crimes of Carl Panzram. After spending most of his teens locked up, Carl is unleashed upon the world to get revenge for the horrors he was forced to endure. Sadly, the targets of his wrath are primarily innocent young men who had the misfortune of crossing his path. This episode has it all: a little blah-blah, a whole lot of yadda-yadda, and a surprise cameo from Jessie's husband, Ross. That's not applause you're hearing, it's the sound of Carl clapping some poor guys cheeks.

The three mustaches cave in to peer pressure and finally cover the life and crimes of bonafide psychopath, Carl Panzram. Born in the late 1800s, Carl's life started out rough and it only got worse from there. By the age of 8, Carl was already a sticky-fingered alcoholic with a predilection for violence and disdain for authority. But, was he born this way or did his experiences growing up shape him into the monster he would ultimately become? Brace yourselves, this two-part series starts off dark and keeps getting darker.

The three mustaches head to South Carolina to tackle one of the most shocking and convoluted cases ever featured on Crime Corner. As the old saying goes, everyone is a villain in someone else's story. Well, if all of the allegations presented in this case are true, this story has nothing but villains. What started off as a seemingly theatrical murder soon devolved into a Mexican standoff of finger-pointing involving an international custody battle, child exploitation, and the alleged violation of innocent canines. Buckle up for this one because it's going to be a wild ride.

The three mustaches head to Alpharetta, Georgia to take a ride on the Farris Wheel. And just like any good carnival, somebody is going to end up in an early grave. When Gary “Big Daddy” Farris went missing in July of 2018, the whole family came together to track him down. Fortunately, within a few hours, they were able to find him. Unfortunately, by that point all that was left was a pile of charred bones. But who killed him? Was it his greedy wife? Or one of his greedy children? Grab a glass of wine and get ready for a story straight out of a soap opera.

The three mustaches stock up on glowsticks and MDMA and head to Pennsylvania to cover a recently solved cold case. Just a few days before Christmas in 1992, 25-year-old Christy Mirack failed to show up for her job as a teacher at a local middle school. When the principal stopped by her house to check on her, he discovered a gruesome murder scene. Despite witnesses providing a description of the suspected murderer, investigators found nothing but dead ends. It soon became clear that it would take more than old-fashioned detective work to track down the killer.