The three mustaches stock up on glowsticks and MDMA and head to Pennsylvania to cover a recently solved cold case. Just a few days before Christmas in 1992, 25-year-old Christy Mirack failed to show up for her job as a teacher at a local middle school. When the principal stopped by her house to check on her, he discovered a gruesome murder scene. Despite witnesses providing a description of the suspected murderer, investigators found nothing but dead ends. It soon became clear that it would take more than old-fashioned detective work to track down the killer.

The three mustaches are once again joined by three-time best-selling author and generous lover, Ross Patterson, to conclude the tragic tale of Orenthal James Simpson. In this episode we finally uncover the truth behind the murders of Nicole Brown and Ronald Goldman, and the answer will shock you! Also, is it just me or does Ryan look like he’s getting shorter?

The three mustaches get in the Christmas spirit and celebrate the 100th episode of Crime Corner! And what better way to kick off the holidays than listening to 911 calls from horrific murders? Jessie curated some of her favorite 911 calls and it's up to Coop and Ryan to figure out whether the person on the other end of the line is an innocent victim, or the perpetrator. Grab some eggnog and get an alibi ready because this is Christmas Eve, Crime Corner style!