The Siege of Vienna

The Last Great Trial Between Cross & Crescent

De: John Stoye

Narrado por: Robert Feifar

The siege of Vienna in 1683 was one of the turning points in European history. So great was its impact that countries normally jealous and hostile sank their differences to throw back the armies of Islam and their savage Tartar allies.The consequences of defeat were momentous: The Ottomans lost half of their European territories, which led to the final collapse of their empire, and the Habsburgs turned their attention from France and the Rhine frontier to the rich pickings of the Balkans. That hot September day in 1683 witnessed the last great trial of strength between the East and the West-and opened an epoch in European history that lasted until the First World War.

©2000 John Stoye (P)2013 Audible, Inc.

Reseñas de la Crítica

"In his splendid study The Siege of Vienna, the Oxford historian John Stoye provides a detailed account of the intricate machinations between the Habsburgs and the Ottomans. Mr. Stoye's description of the siege itself is masterly. He seems to know every inch of ground, every earthwork and fortification around the Imperial City, and he follows the action meticulously." (The Wall Street Journal)

"Worthy of the pen of Herodotus. . . . It is a measure of the fascination of Mr. Stoye's subject that one should think of comparing his treatment of it with the work of the greatest historians." (The Times Literary Supplement)

"John Stoye is the master of every aspect of his subject." (Daily Telegraph)

“Interesting” narration…

So many narrators are British. We enjoy their accents and overlook their uniquely “British” mispronunciations of Spanish, French and Italian words because, well, I suppose it amuses us North Americans. Those Brits…
Mr Stoye seems to be an accomplished North American narrator and has a pleasant voice. However, a problem that he persistently exhibited was either the author or the narrator was unacquainted with the term, ‘cavalry’, soldiers who fight on horseback, and the location of Jesus’ crucifixion, Calvary.
I will give him that he is consistent. Never once did he miss an opportunity to refer to the mounted troops as anything other than ‘Calvary’. How could this astounding error have slipped by the editors. Perhaps what was most disturbing was that I found myself anthropomorphizing the appliances, in this case my telephone, and shouting every time he made mention the hill outside Jerusalem when the soldiers on horseback threw themselves against the opposition.
I was able to keep my comments to myself when he used original and interesting pronunciations of other common words. We all need a break from time to time.

This book's depth is a double edged sword

I had great difficulty keeping straight the names and sources. I doubt you could find more information on this world event.

A partial review

Would you try another book from John Stoye and/or Robert Feifar?

I would.

How could the performance have been better?

The narrator isn't bad, but for Gods sake, the man can't for the life of him say the word "cavalry". It sounds ridiculous I know, but he constantly says "calvary" and it started off ok, then I started to wince every time and now I just get mad. Why didn't anyone tell him? Other than that he's not a bad narrator at all and I would listen to more of his books so long as they don't involve cavalry...

Could you see The Siege of Vienna being made into a movie or a TV series? Who should the stars be?

It should be, but it won't.

Any additional comments?

The first half is very very dry.

Starts slow but picks up steam

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

I would recommend it if they had an interest in the story. I'd tell them the first chapter is difficult listening. I didn't get much out of it, but towards the end of the first chapter, the story starts slowly developing. It builds momentum and becomes gripping as the siege develops. A great deal of detail is provided, such as the cost of materials needed to defend the city or the costs to build an army, but it helped bring the story to life for me. It drifts a little after siege is over, but was worth listening to in order to find out what happened.

Send in the CAVALRY!

This book wasn’t for you, but who do you think might enjoy it more?

Some one who is untroubled by terrible narration.

Who would you have cast as narrator instead of Robert Feifar?

Almost anyone.

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

The history of the Siege and events leading up to it.

Any additional comments?

I have listened to hundreds of audiobooks and I have to say that this was probably the worst narration I have experienced. The subject included a great variety of 17th C Central European place names and people which is an obvious challenge to any narrator, but the choice of someone who intermittantly changed his pronunciation of names , could never seem to get Magyar, almost always said "Calvary" rather than "cavalry", and had a very difficult time reading clauses with understandable vocal stresses , was a terrible mistake and injustice to a good book.

Very Disappointed

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

More information about the siege itself instead of going on and on about the political situation in Eastern Europe at the time.

What could John Stoye have done to make this a more enjoyable book for you?

Less minutia about the politics of the era more information about the siege of Vienna. The dearth of information about the Siege of Vienna was pitiful.

Would you be willing to try another one of Robert Feifar’s performances?

Yes

What character would you cut from The Siege of Vienna?

Most

Any additional comments?

This should have been titled: The Politics Leading up to the Siege of Vienna.

Constant mispronunciations

What disappointed you about The Siege of Vienna?

The reader of this work works hard to enunciate every single word. The problem is, he doesn't know how many of them are pronounced. He doesn't just mangle most of the Germanic pronunciations, but common English words as well.

Would you be willing to try another one of Robert Feifar’s performances?

No.