The Scarlet Letter

De: Nathaniel Hawthorne

Narrado por: Charlton Griffin

Considered his masterpiece, The Scarlet Letter is Hawthorne's story of Hester Prynne and her daughter, Pearl, conceived through an adulterous affair with a Puritan pastor in 17th century Boston. From start to finish, the book explores the themes of law, guilt, and sin. Since its appearance in 1850, this magnificent book has been a perennial favorite among young and old, though it was extremely controversial when it was first published.

Henry James described the novel thusly: "It is beautiful, admirable, extraordinary; it has in the highest degree that merit which I have spoken of as the mark of Hawthorne's best things - an indefinable purity and lightness of conception. One can often return to it; it supports familiarity and has the inexhaustible charm and mystery of great works of art."

Public Domain (P)2012 Audio Connoisseur

Great story, but do not love the narrator

I wish I'd heard this story with a different author. While he lends sufficient gravitas to the narration, the high-level vocabulary, and the historical nature of the story, to say nothing of the male characters, his treatment and voicing of the female characters - strong, vibrant women with complex personalities, make them sound like Tinkerbell. The falsetto he uses makes me think not of a woman, but of some animated caricature, and I feel that it does the entire storyline a grave disservice.

Beautifully written.

The story was absolutely wonderful. Sometimes hard to understand and stay along with the plot, but Charlton was mesmerizing. Would recommend for ages 16 and older.

Off-putting female voices

This is a novel that is probably better read than listened to. It involves a lot of description and commentary, and I think its depth is lost if you are easily distracted while listening. Overall, I was interested enough to finish it, but the narrator's female voices drove me crazy. He was good with the male voices - they sounded like normal, intelligent human beings - but his female characters sounded like a parody, almost as though he were mocking them. That took some weight away from the central issue of the novel: Hester's having to wear the scarlet letter and her reaction to it.

Decent

Dimsdale's struggle and inner Igbo are pithy, and the chilling Dr. Chilling worth brings a spectrish malevolence very fitting for an antagonist. The whole dreary New England setting is somewhat depressing, and Hawthorne's subtle mocking of colonial English superstition and belief in the supernatural make this not without merit, but not for the reader looking for a lift in the spirits.

Masterpiece! Brilliantly read!

I was blown away by the lofty language and the sheer brilliance of the author. I was also truly grateful and impressed by the talent of the narrator, that made the lofty language both authentic and easy to understand.