The Girl in Gray

De: Annette Lyon

Narrado por: Krista Nicely

Duración: 12 h y 50 m

Resumen del Editor

A country fighting to stay free. A woman with an impossible decision.

In November of 1939, Sini Toivola is sure of two things: She loves Marko Linna, and she has a comfortable life in Helsinki. But when the massive Soviet army invades her beloved homeland and Marko spurns her affections, her life is turned upside down.

Needing a fresh start, Sini decides to join the female volunteer corps - the Lotta Svärd - and is sent to serve near the front lines. Service at a field hospital proves to be a good distraction, until Sini discovers a Russian soldier lost behind their camp.

Duty requires her to turn him in, but her heart begs to keep him safe and help him escape. Torn between love for her country and love for her enemy, Sini must choose.

But no matter what choice she makes, heart-wrenching consequences await them all.

©2019 Annette Lyon (P)2020 Annette Lyon

Little known histórica info

This story was compelling and intriguing. My favorite aspect was that it detailed historical info that I was unfamiliar with and is rarely written about. I loved it. Annette Lyon is an amazing author and I will be looking for more of her books!

Love and loyalty complicated by war.

This story does an excellent job of highlighting the extraordinary role Finland played in the war. I had never heard anything about Finland’s role before and loved the historical context of the story.

This story has love, though it’s not a traditional romance. It follows characters that feel real as they struggle to figure out where their loyalties lie. Who can they protect, and who must be betrayed? Can a person betray their country by loving the wrong person? We follow our main character through her life as she faces a multitude of tough choices that will tear her apart.

Interesting premise, entertaining story, and satisfying ending. Well done.

More than worth a listen

Historical fiction is usually not my genre of choice, but I absolutely loved this book. I connected more with the characters than I have with any character for a long time. I felt their loves, their fears, their heartbreaks like they were my own. The Girl in Gray looks at love and war and human connection through a realistic, unromanticized lens and gives listeners a chance to see themselves and their own struggles in the story. I loved every minute of it, and as a bonus I learned some Finnish history along the way. The narrator's voice lent a nice tone to the story without being annoying or distracting from the book, an even more impressive feat considering all the Finnish she had to pronounce!

Outstanding Story & Listen🎧 Riveting & Heartfelt!

This is an amazing historical fiction, it is beautifully written and told. I am new to Annette Lyon’s work and I will definitely be checking out more of her work. She is a gifted author, I enjoyed her writing style, her descriptive details brings you into the story along side the characters allowing you to see and feel what the characters see and feel. I found the story completely engrossing and could not pull myself away. The storylines and characters that are realistic and easy to relate to which makes the story even more meaningful and moving. You can tell how much heart the author but into this book. The story takes place in Finland, winter of 1939, the Russians are invading Finland which turns in to an 105 battle. The lead character is Sini Toivola, she lives in Helsinki and has been in love with Marko Linna, who finished med school. She learns her feeling are not reciprocated, Marko has feelings for someone else, someone she can not have. Needing a change she volunteers to help with war efforts, becoming a “Lotta Svärd” which will bring her to the front lines. With no special training she becomes support services helping out in a Medical unit. She becomes friends with Leila, small world her husband was Marco’s best friend. Marko was also sent to the front lines, first working with a combat unit, then sent to a medical unit before returning to combat before the war’s end. Sinni learns what real love is like and realizes her infatuation with Marko was just that, an infatuation. Life during wartime is not a pretty one, we witness some of the atrocities that go on and what they went thru, gut-wrenching and heart-rending at times. The author does a great job presenting some of the challenges those serving faced. The book is well plotted and the story flows naturally. There is plenty of drama and emotions in this story and you can tell how much heart the author put into her work. I highly recommend it, it is a great historical fiction, there is plenty of drama, action, heartfelt moments, heartbreaking ones and a bit of romance. Annette Lyon, thank you for this stunning, heart-pounding story and emotional journey.

Krista Nicely is a fabulous narrator and voice artist. She does an amazing job portraying the characters, bringing them to life, giving each their own voice and personality. You could hear how much heart she puts into her work as she captures the characters emotions and projects them into her performance. She is an entertaining storyteller and a pleasure to listen to. Thank you for another great listen🎧

An incredible story

What and incredible story! I love historical fiction novels. It is an easy way to learn about our past. I’m glad I listened to it. I’m no good with foreign names and places. This book had many turns and twists that I did not see coming. Excellent work!

Compelling Listen with Stellar Narration

The Girl in Gray is a compelling/unpausable audiobook that highlights an aspect of WW2 history that is seldom discussed or written about. Krista Nicely's performance is captivating and she navigates the transition between different character viewpoints as smoothly as possible. Nicely's mid-Atlantic/neutral accent serves the story well and her pronunciation of non-English words is authentic but not ostentatious or distracting.

The story is written in third person omnipotent and switches between the three main characters: Sini, Leila, and Marko. The reason this story is 4 star for me rather than 5 star is because I did not find the development of the secondary characters Leila and Marko as compelling as the character development for Sini. In fact, the book opens with a greater focus on Leila and Marko and I wasn't really "hooked" until Sini was followed more closely.

This is an audiobook that is well worth the listen and I definitely recommend it for fans of authors such as Kristin Hannah, Melanie Benjamin, and Ruta Sepetys.

A Somewhat Melodramatic Christian Romance

First and foremost, this is a 'Harlequin' style romance with an historical setting. There is definitely an audience for soppy romances and weepy melodrama and I think those readers will enjoy this fairly 'clean' story of a Finnish woman falling in love during the harsh Winter War of 1939 (when Finland held off the Soviet forces at the beginning of WWII). The author gets the facts straight and gives a bit of a glimpse into Finnish culture (though the characters are shallow enough by being pigeon-holed into a romance that they feel very unreal). The book has heavy Christian overtones (including an angel speaking to our main character) so I would also classify this as a Christian romance more than an historical romance. The historical and cultural aspects are very light.

Story: After her parents died when she was a child, Sini was passed around relatives as an unwanted addition to their families. Now an adult, she lives in an apartment building in Helsinki and pines for an upstairs neighbor, Marko, who is in love with another woman. Dr. Marko Linna has been in love with childhood friend Leila for most of his life but she married his best friend and they had a son. After her husband died, Leila's whole life is devoted to her son, Taneli; so much so that she does not see Marko's years-long obsession with her. When the women join the Lotta Svart (military nurses) and Marko signs on to the military, their three lives will continue to intersect as Finland struggles not to be consumed by Stalin's forces.

The book takes place during the Finnish Winter War, which lasted for 6 months at the beginning of World War II in 1939. It is notable because the Finns managed to hold off Stalin through guerilla tactics, making full use of the snowy terrain against Stalin's conscripted soldiers (many of whom were from other countries/areas that had never experienced northern Winters). Not really mentioned in the story is how adverse Finns were to Russian occupation since they had suffered under Russian rule for centuries in the past. It was the reason the fighting was so spirited on the Finnish side. There are plenty of Finnish-perspective references throughout the book - including the overused tropes of Finnish Sisu and Sauna Vihta. But for the most part, the book takes places in a war hospital in the forest so you won't glean much about Finnish life/living as a result.

Our main characters all hail from Helsinki, creating an interesting perspective since those in the city were most fearful of what was to come - they knew their homes would be bombed if the Winter War failed. This, among other reasons, is why one character sends her young son to Sweden to be fostered until the end of the war. There are not really any actual war/battle/fighting scenes and Sini isn't a nurse so she does cooking and errands.

The novel gives three perspectives but, for the most part, the focus is on Sini. She is somewhat of a sad-sack character since she spends most of the book mooning after two unavailable men and being reactive rather than proactive. The war is more of a backdrop to the romance here in her quest for love. Marko, meanwhile, is just confused for most of the book and wanders around endlessly saying to himself how much he loves Leila while he goes through the motions of war. Leila is so perfect that I expected little birdies to braid her hair in the morning while she sang happy songs; Sini's love interest Nikolai is prince charming in a Soviet uniform.

Admittedly, I couldn't help but roll my eyes from the melodrama. It felt like 80% of the book was the characters repeating over and over the same topic - mostly about how much they are in love with someone else. It made it a chore to read for that reason and several times I decided to give up on the book in annoyance. In the end, I did finish it but I can't say I enjoyed it.

Those looking for a great source on the Winter War can go to the 1954 book The Unknown Soldier by Väinö Linna (or watch the recent big production 2017 movie of the same name). Linna wrote the book in 1954 as a form of protest of the over glorification of the Finnish soldiers after the war by showing the Finnish soldiers as ordinary people, mostly from small towns and villages, doing bad things and being just as desperate or dirty as the Russian soldiers. I imagine that choosing Marko's last name as Linna was an homage by author Lyon since Marko suffers the worst fate in the book of the three characters.

I listened to the audible version and I think a lot of the shallowness and problems with characterization may have come from the narrator. Her pronunciations of the Finnish words was adequate but the reading was bland and made the characters sound simplistic, rather stupid, and unrealistic. It was very hard to root for any of the main characters as a result. This also added to my issues with completing the novel.

Rich with Symbolism

Honestly, I started this book without any expectations and my initial impression of the book unfairly judged it as a sappy romance novel with a seemingly weak woman at the center. It took me a couple of chapters to connect with Sini.

I'm so glad I stayed with it! The Girl in Gray proved a spell binding historical fiction about the Winter War between the Soviet Union and and Finland in 1939.

Since world history doesn't spend time on these events and Finland often seems forgotten, this book opened my understanding to the importance the strength one small nation can make on the outcome of war.

Lyon takes her readers on a tour of Finland introducing Finnish culture, landscapes, traditions, and historical details that forever leave her readers enlightened. I thoroughly enjoyed seeing life through the eyes of a Finnish Lotta Svärd during the winter of 1939.

The Girl in Gray depicts how war is not only unpredictable but unforgiving. This compelling novel illustrates the significant role of women volunteers supporting military efforts in the Finnish army with their labors of love and nurturing. Lyon portrays that not all warriors fight with arms. More importantly, the human spirit awakens to the concept that not all on conflict is black and white. Sini Toivola, in her gray Lotta Svärd uniform becomes an evocative symbol of the gray area between duty and humanity.

I appreciated that Lyon, who is a well known author in Christian circles, kept the novel clean without dilluting the story. She could have easily applied the high moral standards of characters from her previous books in this war torn area of Scandinavia. However, she artfully demonstrates the most likely behaviors of the characters in this setting which manifests her commitment to history over popularity.

Couldn’t stop listening

This is the first book by this author that I have listened to. I really enjoyed it. The main character bugged me at first but she grew through the plot. She learned and became who she should be and wanted to be. She made mistakes (we all do!) but became reflexive on her life and what she needed to do to grow.

I love history and the main characters lives are entwined in the conflicts in Finland during World War 2. It was nice to learn their war strategy and to hear a different part of the history of that war.

This book made me think about the realities of war and how much it affects those who serve and the countries who are attacked.

I didn’t want the book to end because I want to learn what Finland did and how they handled Germany and Russia attacking at the same time. I want to know how the lives of the main characters continue. I am hoping this is the first book in a series.

Not the greatest story

This was a book club pick …not my favorite story. It was a lot of words with nothing to say.
Narrator was good.