Goodbye to All That

De: Robert Graves

Narrado por: Martin Jarvis

A famous autobiographical account of life as a young soldier in the first World War trenches. Robert Graves, who went on to write I, Claudius, has given to posterity here one of the all-time great insights into the experience of war.©2007 CSA Telltapes Ltd. (P)2007 CSA Telltapes Ltd.

Good minus flute

The story was well written and well narrated, but the constant flute music between sections was unnecessary and a bit irritating.

British light-hearted look at WWI

Would you consider the audio edition of Goodbye to All That to be better than the print version?

This is Robert Graves telling his experiences in WWI, a terrible war in which millions died. But you wouldn't know it from this book. It sounds like a walk in the park. I guess he was trying to spare his readers reliving a war all wanted to forget (it was published in the late 20s). One gets a feeling for the war, but these are rare instances. More often we get a form of British good humor when the officers go over the top with nothing but a swagger stick. He has many humorous stories, some of which sound gruesome today. It's like a gentle, quick tour of the trenches, which he survived by great good luck.

What about Martin Jarvis’s performance did you like?

The narration is jaunty, clean and emotive. Good work by Martin Jarvis, narrator.

Great book, offensive and off-putting narration

Why is it still acceptable for audiobook narrators to use fake foreign accents? The narrator's sardonic, upper-crust British accent was fine for the voice of Robert Graves, himself a sardonic, upper-crust Brit, but dramatizing Germans as speaking in a kind of Sergeant Schultz-Dummkopf accent is both offensive and cringeworthy. A moment's reflection tells you that Germans speak German, not English with a German accent. It is even worse when the narrator speaks in a Welsh accent-- I couldn't understand a word of it. The narration alone killed this book for me. I'll read it on my own.

Not the full book

Skips around a bit, not the entire text, but overall I really liked the story so it’s worth the read/listen overall

Moving

This book was written in 1929 as a memoir of his service in World War One. The book covers his early life, his time at Charterhouse School where he was mercilessly bullied, the war and the post war period up to writing the book in 1929.

Like many young men Graves enlisted within days of the outbreak of the Great War with no understanding of what war was like. He enlisted as an officer in the Royal Welch Fusiliers. He fought in France—the Somme, Souchez, Bethune, Loos, Cambria and Cuinchy—and was seriously wounded and discharged in 1918. In January 1926 Graves, Nancy and their four children set out for Egypt where Graves was to take up an appointment as professor of English in Cairo. In 1929 he divorced his wife and set up house in Deya, Majorca with the American Poet Laura Riding. Graves book “Goodbye To All That” was published the same year as Erick Maira Remarque’s “All Quiet On the Western Front.” Graves was a well known poet and he also wrote poems about WWI as did his friend and fellow soldier Siegfried Sassoon. Graves is best known for his book “I Claudius.”

What makes this such a good memoir about the war is that it is not bogged down with ideologies or politics. He presents what it was like to live day to day in the trenches (as an officer). His vivid account of life and death in the trenches is haunting. While there is obviously much fear, discomfort and horror, there is also lots of comedy and camaraderie. Graves wants to show what WWI was really like, no sentimentalizing it or giving it a meaning he didn’t feel. It was a horrific, life changing experience and that was all.

I had just finished reading “The Storm of Steel” by Ernst Junger. Junger’s memoir is similar to that of Graves in that they both are about reportage. Graves included information about his fellow soldiers, Junger did not, both books tell about the daily life of a soldier. I find it interesting to read about the same battle they both fought in but on opposite side such as the Somme and Cambria. Between the two books I have seen World War One from both viewpoints of the average German and English soldier. Both books reveal a unique, honest and incredibly powerful depiction of the realities of life as a soldier, and of the true effects of fighting on those who experienced it. Martin Jarvis did a good job narrating the book. I recommend this book as a must read for the WWI 100th anniversary.

Horror of WWI

An enthralling account of a young man's experiences in WWI brilliantly read by M Jarvis.

excellent

an excellent personal story of the insanity and brutalness of World War 1. short but highly recommended

An Interesting Perspective

This was a fascinating perspective on the war, from a person who appears to be from the elite class and with family ties to “the enemy” which caused him grief during his service.

Definitely worth the read or listen.

Amazing narration - but abridged and the edited 1958 second edition

This is an abridged version of the 1958 rewritten version. One of my favorite autobiographies of all time., but I would rather have had an unabridged version of the original edition. The narration of this book is one the very best I have ever heard.

beautiful

absolutely perfect. I couldn't have asked for a better story. that was enthralled from beginning to end not just with the story but with the speaker and the music.