Beneath the Mountain

A Novel

De: Luca D'Andrea

Narrado por: Charles Constant

Beneath the Mountain has descriptive copy which is not yet available from the Publisher.

Excellet Narration - Unusual Story

It took a couple of chapters for me to get into this book. I thought at first that there was too much meandering going through details that seemed irrelevant to the story. But I was patient and kept going. Eventually everything tied together and I understood why the author laid things out the way he did. The story takes place in northern Italy, where the people speak German. The narrator did a marvelous job with a German accent, and the unique voices for the many characters in the book. The motive for the crime which is the topic of the book, seemed to have been made clear several times, but then changed. Every time it seemed that all the facts had come out, and the culprit had been exposed, things turned upside down, and the facts were not at all what they had seemed to be. I thought that this book was unusual - it is unlike anything I have ever read before. Somewhat strange, but intriguing, written in first person, a lot of time was spent on developing the characters and exposing their individual histories. I needed a lot of patience to get through this book. It is not the kind of book that goes straight through to the solving of the crime. Many side trips are taken - interesting ones though. The author writes almost as though this was a diary, filled with his emotions, reactions, motivations, and demons.

Story about an emotional struggle

This was a mystery but dealt more with the protagonist’s emotional struggles and the author frequently digressed to extreme lengths on what protagonist was thinking and on background that was agonizingly long and detailed. The mystery itself was good with some unexpected twists. Some of the actions of the characters seemed unrealistic and/or extreme. I think the Narrator did and excellent job with character voices and inflection of emotion into his reading. He did the best he could and kept me listening where otherwise I would have given up on the listen. It wasn’t horrible but it’s not a book for a guy like me. I think the author missed an opportunity to grab the readers attention to the history of the region. I likely will avoid this author in the future.

Loved the Story and the Narration

The story may start out slowly, but builds to an ending that isn't one that I would have guessed. Having spent time in the Alto Adige, the location of this book was one of the reasons I purchased it. It is an area where Germanic and Italian languages and cultures come together and also clash. It was a perfect setting for the protagonist, who is emotionally struggling, to find an inner resolution while solving a mystery that has longed plagued the area.

The narrator was also wonderful. His German and Italian pronunciations were great. He was easy to listen to as well as understand. I would certainly listen to his narration again.

80% conversation, 20% description. 100% boring

If you like people talking back and forth this book is for you. I had enough with the conversations about half way through. I could not care less as to what happened, about the characters, or how it ends. I like the most of the readers voices so he did a good job.

Dull and boring.

The book is awful. The plot is dull and it moves at a snail's pace. Don't waste your time or money.