Torn between her love for the parents who raised her and her growing suspicion that they may have kidnapped her, Janie writes a letter to the Spring family but hesitates to send it. When she loses the letter and fears someone else may have mailed it, Janie is forced to confront her parents with her discoveries. The novel ends with a cliffhanger as the Johnsons insist on calling the Springs, and Janie reluctantly picks up the phone to dial the number that could change her life forever.

Themes

• Identity and self-discovery

• Family secrets and deception

• Trust and betrayal

• Coming of age and adolescent struggles

• Memory and its reliability

• Moral dilemmas and difficult choices

• Love and relationships in times of crisis

Setting

Set in the late 1980s or early 1990s, The Face on the Milk Carton reflects a time when missing children's photos on milk cartons were a common sight in American households. This era was marked by increased awareness of child abductions and a nationwide effort to locate missing youth through various public campaigns.

The story primarily takes place in suburban Connecticut, where protagonist Janie Johnson lives with her parents. The quiet, seemingly idyllic neighborhood serves as a stark contrast to the turmoil Janie experiences as she uncovers the truth about her past. Key scenes also unfold at Janie's high school, highlighting the typical American teenage experience of the time.

As Janie's investigation progresses, the setting expands to include New Jersey, specifically a shopping mall where the kidnapping allegedly occurred. This geographical shift adds tension to the narrative, bridging Janie's present life in Connecticut with her mysterious past in New Jersey. The contrast between these two locations underscores the dual nature of Janie's identity and the complex web of relationships she must navigate.

Characters

• Janie Johnson: The 15-year-old protagonist who discovers her face on a milk carton. She struggles with her identity and the possibility that she was kidnapped as a child. Janie is intelligent, curious, and determined to uncover the truth about her past. Her journey of self-discovery drives the plot of the novel.

• Mr. and Mrs. Johnson: Janie's loving adoptive parents who raised her since she was a toddler. They are protective of Janie and reluctant to reveal information about her past. Their complex motivations and the truth about Janie's adoption are gradually revealed throughout the story.

• Reeve Shields: Janie's boyfriend and confidant. He supports Janie in her search for the truth and helps her investigate her past. Reeve is caring and loyal, providing emotional support to Janie during her crisis.

• Hannah Javensen: Janie's biological mother and the Johnsons' daughter. Her involvement with a cult and subsequent abandonment of Janie set the events of the story in motion. Hannah's actions and motivations remain mysterious for much of the novel.

• Sarah-Charlotte Sherwood: Janie's best friend. She is a minor character who provides some comic relief and serves as a sounding board for Janie's thoughts and fears.

• The Spring family: The family of Jennie Spring, the missing girl whose photo appears on the milk carton. They become a focal point of Janie's investigation into her true identity.

Quick facts

• The book was inspired by missing child flyers Caroline B. Cooney saw at LaGuardia Airport.

• It was first published in 1990 and is the first book in a five-part series.

• The novel has sold over 4.2 million copies as part of the Janie Johnson series.

• It was adapted into a television movie in 1995 starring Kellie Martin as Janie.

• The book won several awards, including the 1993 Pacific Northwest Library Association Young Readers Choice Award.

• It was one of the most frequently challenged books in U.S. schools and libraries in the 1990s and 2000s.

• The story was inspired by the real-life practice of putting missing children's photos on milk cartons in the 1980s-90s.

• Cooney wrote four sequel novels continuing Janie's story, with the final book published in 2013.

• The book explores themes of identity, family relationships, and individual responsibility.

• It has been used in classrooms to encourage students to examine moral and ethical dilemmas.

About the Author

Caroline B. Cooney is a prolific American author known for her young adult suspense, mystery, and romance novels. Born in 1947 in Geneva, New York, Cooney discovered her passion for writing in sixth grade. Her career took off when she began selling stories to Seventeen magazine, eventually leading to a successful career in book writing.

Cooney's most famous work, The Face on the Milk Carton, has sold over 3 million copies and was adapted into a television movie. This bestselling novel is part of her popular Janie Johnson series. Throughout her career, Cooney has authored numerous standalone novels and series, including the Time Travelers Quartet and the Losing Christina series.

To maintain authenticity in her writing, Cooney frequently visits schools to interact with teenagers and gain insights into their lives. She often engages students in a “plotting game,” where they collaboratively create story plots. This dedication to understanding her audience has contributed to the enduring popularity of her books among young readers.

Currently residing in South Carolina, Cooney continues to pursue her passion for writing while enjoying time with her grandchildren. She also indulges in various hobbies, including playing the piano, walking, pottery, and jewelry-making. With over 15 million copies of her books sold and translations in multiple languages, Caroline B. Cooney remains a significant figure in young adult literature.