Summary
Magpie Murders by Anthony Horowitz is a masterful blend of classic and contemporary mystery, offering readers a unique “story within a story” experience. Published in 2016, this New York Times bestseller pays homage to the golden age of British crime fiction while weaving a modern thriller. The novel follows Susan Ryeland, an editor who becomes entangled in a real-life mystery while reading the manuscript of a fictional detective story. Horowitz's ingenious structure allows readers to simultaneously enjoy a traditional whodunit and a contemporary investigation.
In 2022, Magpie Murders was adapted into a six-part television series, starring Lesley Manville as Susan Ryeland and Tim McMullan as the fictional detective Atticus Pünd, premiering on BritBox in the UK and PBS Masterpiece in the US.
Plot
Magpie Murders follows two intertwined mysteries. The first is a classic whodunit set in 1955, written by fictional author Alan Conway. In this story, detective Atticus Pünd investigates the murders of Mary Blakiston, a housekeeper at Pye Hall, and her employer, Sir Magnus Pye. Pünd uncovers family secrets and motives, ultimately revealing Robert Blakiston as the killer of not only both victims but also his brother Tom years earlier.
The second mystery unfolds in the present day, as editor Susan Ryeland reads Conway's manuscript. She discovers the final chapter is missing, leaving the mystery unsolved. When Conway is found dead, Susan begins to suspect foul play. She travels to Conway's village to investigate, uncovering the author's true feelings about his work and compiling a list of potential murderers.
As Susan delves deeper, she uncovers a shocking truth—her boss, Charles Clover, murdered Conway to prevent him from revealing a coded message hidden in his books that would have damaged the publishing company's reputation. When Susan confronts Charles, he attacks her and sets fire to the office. She is saved by her boyfriend Andreas, and the final chapter of Conway's novel is recovered.
The novel concludes with Charles arrested for murder, Cloverleaf Books closed down, and Conway's final novel published by another company. Susan, having declined the offer to take over Cloverleaf Books, decides to move to Crete with Andreas to run a hotel, leaving behind the world of publishing and murder mysteries.