The Best Unsolved Mystery Podcasts to Uncover Your Inner Investigator

Go behind some of the biggest and most mysterious cases—confounding murders, eerie sightings, and all sorts of unexplainable happenings—that continue to stump investigators. Here are the best unsolved mystery podcasts to check out now.

There are so many unsolved mysteries in the world, from murders that have left investigators mystified for decades to UFOs. Strange creatures, haunted houses, and perplexing crimes have fascinated humans for as long as we've been telling stories. Unsurprisingly, there are dozens and dozens of wonderful podcasts that seek to shed light on such mysteries, both big and small. This list will help you find the best of the best: the must-listen podcasts that explore enduring mysteries related to murder, monsters, supernatural activity, and more.

Whether you're a true crime buff who enjoys unique takes on cold cases, backed by thoughtful reporting, or a paranormal nerd on the hunt for your next great listen, we've got you covered. We've split this list into sections to help you find exactly what you're looking for—even it's a little bit of everything. We've got Appalachian legends, interviews with people who've seen ghosts, true crime sagas, a duo of cocktail-drinking paranormal enthusiasts, true tales about the internet you'll never believe—and a whole lot more.

 

The Best Unsolved Monster Mystery Podcasts

Appalachian Monsters & Mysteries

If you enjoy a podcast with plenty of atmosphere, you'll want to tune into this spooky weekly show. Each episode focuses on a different part of Appalachia and its unsolved mysteries. You'll learn about cryptids and ghosts, bleeding houses, haunted forests, and ancient Appalachian monsters and legends that have gone unexplained for decades. Steeped in the rich regional culture and history of Appalachia, this is one podcast that's sure to satisfy mystery fans and monster lovers alike.

Sasquatch Chronicles

Bigfoot, aka Sasquatch, is one of the most famous monsters out there, and sightings of this mysterious beast have been stirring up intrigue and controversies for years. Whether you're a dedicated Bigfoot follower or just curious to see what all the fuss is about, Sasquatch Chronicles will draw you right in. Each week, the hosts discuss the latest Bigfoot sightings. They speak with eyewitnesses, researchers, amateur sleuths, and investigators, attempting to unravel the mystery of Sasquatch.

The Cryptonaut Podcast

Fans of unsolved monster mysteries need look no further than this entertaining and comprehensive podcast. The Cryptonaut Podcast explores aliens, monsters, cryptids, ghosts, demons, and dozens of other strange and unexplained happenings. From the Amazon basin to the New Jersey suburbs, hosts Marc Storrs, Chris Carnicelli, and Rob Morph take listeners all over the world in search of the creepiest and most bizarre monster mysteries out there.

The Cryptid Factor

No list of the best mystery podcasts would be complete without a show dedicated to cryptozoology: the study of creatures whose existence is unprovable or unsubstantiated. If you're curious about such bizarre cryptids as the famous Loch Ness monster, the Mongolian Death Worm, Bigfoot, and many, many others, this is the podcast for you. Hosts Rhys Darby, Dan Schreiber, and David Farrier attempt to get to the bottom of these mysteries and monsters. While they'll probably leave you with more questions than answers, their conversations are a whole lot of fun.

Lore

Ghost stories and horror movies may be scary, but the truth is often the scariest story of all. History is full of mysteries, and Lore is a biweekly podcast that delves right into them. Each episode explores a different historical theme, from mysterious creatures to unusual places. Recent themes include stories about those who have defied death, tales about islands that straddle the line between two worlds, and an exploration of the roots of some of folklore's most enduring monsters.

Appalachian Monsters & Mysteries

If you enjoy a podcast with plenty of atmosphere, you'll want to tune into this spooky weekly show. Each episode focuses on a different part of Appalachia and its unsolved mysteries. You'll learn about cryptids and ghosts, bleeding houses, haunted forests, and ancient Appalachian monsters and legends that have gone unexplained for decades. Steeped in the rich regional culture and history of Appalachia, this is one podcast that's sure to satisfy mystery fans and monster lovers alike.

Sasquatch Chronicles

Bigfoot, aka Sasquatch, is one of the most famous monsters out there, and sightings of this mysterious beast have been stirring up intrigue and controversies for years. Whether you're a dedicated Bigfoot follower or just curious to see what all the fuss is about, Sasquatch Chronicles will draw you right in. Each week, the hosts discuss the latest Bigfoot sightings. They speak with eyewitnesses, researchers, amateur sleuths, and investigators, attempting to unravel the mystery of Sasquatch.

The Cryptonaut Podcast

Fans of unsolved monster mysteries need look no further than this entertaining and comprehensive podcast. The Cryptonaut Podcast explores aliens, monsters, cryptids, ghosts, demons, and dozens of other strange and unexplained happenings. From the Amazon basin to the New Jersey suburbs, hosts Marc Storrs, Chris Carnicelli, and Rob Morph take listeners all over the world in search of the creepiest and most bizarre monster mysteries out there.

The Cryptid Factor

No list of the best mystery podcasts would be complete without a show dedicated to cryptozoology: the study of creatures whose existence is unprovable or unsubstantiated. If you're curious about such bizarre cryptids as the famous Loch Ness monster, the Mongolian Death Worm, Bigfoot, and many, many others, this is the podcast for you. Hosts Rhys Darby, Dan Schreiber, and David Farrier attempt to get to the bottom of these mysteries and monsters. While they'll probably leave you with more questions than answers, their conversations are a whole lot of fun.

Lore

Ghost stories and horror movies may be scary, but the truth is often the scariest story of all. History is full of mysteries, and Lore is a biweekly podcast that delves right into them. Each episode explores a different historical theme, from mysterious creatures to unusual places. Recent themes include stories about those who have defied death, tales about islands that straddle the line between two worlds, and an exploration of the roots of some of folklore's most enduring monsters.

 

The Best Unsolved Ghost Mystery Podcasts

Real Ghost Stories Online

Real Ghost Stories Online delivers a daily dose of spooky ghost mysteries, hosted by Tony Brueski. Told by the people who've experienced them, these stories encompass everything from haunted houses to demonic possessions. Each episode features a different kind of ghost story—some terrifying, some surreal, some simply bizarre. Tune in for the creepy tales, but stay for the stories behind the stories.

The Grave Talks | Haunted, Paranormal & Supernatural

Tony Brueski is back with another podcast celebrating all things paranormal, The Grave Talks. In this interview-style show, guests discuss their experiences with ghosts, hauntings, and the spirit world. Each 40-minute episode is a deep dive into a ghostly mystery. Recent interviewees include a man who can speak with ghosts from the American Revolution and a woman who has dedicated her life to paranormal investigation. Brueski's interviews are thorough, and after listening to a few, you won’t look at the world the same way again.

And That's Why We Drink

Looking for a bit of humor along with your ghost stories? On this unique podcast that’s equal parts terrifying and hilarious, two good friends get together to talk ghost mysteries and true crime, all while sipping on the cocktail of the week. In each episode, Em and Christine share the latest ghost stories that are keeping them up at night and get into the details of a different unsolved murder mystery as well. If you can't decide what kind of unsolved mysteries podcast you want to listen to, this is a good bet: it's got a little bit of everything!

Real Ghost Stories Online

Real Ghost Stories Online delivers a daily dose of spooky ghost mysteries, hosted by Tony Brueski. Told by the people who've experienced them, these stories encompass everything from haunted houses to demonic possessions. Each episode features a different kind of ghost story—some terrifying, some surreal, some simply bizarre. Tune in for the creepy tales, but stay for the stories behind the stories.

The Grave Talks | Haunted, Paranormal & Supernatural

Tony Brueski is back with another podcast celebrating all things paranormal, The Grave Talks. In this interview-style show, guests discuss their experiences with ghosts, hauntings, and the spirit world. Each 40-minute episode is a deep dive into a ghostly mystery. Recent interviewees include a man who can speak with ghosts from the American Revolution and a woman who has dedicated her life to paranormal investigation. Brueski's interviews are thorough, and after listening to a few, you won’t look at the world the same way again.

And That's Why We Drink

Looking for a bit of humor along with your ghost stories? On this unique podcast that’s equal parts terrifying and hilarious, two good friends get together to talk ghost mysteries and true crime, all while sipping on the cocktail of the week. In each episode, Em and Christine share the latest ghost stories that are keeping them up at night and get into the details of a different unsolved murder mystery as well. If you can't decide what kind of unsolved mysteries podcast you want to listen to, this is a good bet: it's got a little bit of everything!

 

The Best Unsolved True Crime Mystery Podcasts

The Riddle of Emmon Bodfish

The true crime podcast follows Paul Holes, the cold case investigator who helped identify the Golden State Killer, through one of the strangest investigations of his career. After studying the crime scene of the murder of Emmon Bodfish, Holes suspects that this case is no ordinary homicide. As he begins to build a case, each episode reveals another clue. This is an edge-of-your-seat story, full of twists and turns you'll never see coming. Holes uses his extensive knowledge of forensic science and criminal behavior to work the case piece by piece—all the way to its shocking conclusion.

Serial

A must-listen for fans of superb storytelling and investigative journalism, Serial is one of the top crime podcasts of all time. Each season tells one true story. Host Sarah Koenig follows the twists and turns through to the end, never knowing what's going to happen until it's actually happening. The seminal first season investigates the murder of Maryland high school student Hae Min Lee. The podcast's third and most recent season explores the American criminal justice system more broadly, looking at several cases all taking place in and around Cleveland, Ohio. Serial is top-notch longform nonfiction; every season is worth a listen.

The Messenger

This moving and prescient story about friendship, betrayal, terrorism, and the cost of fake news was one of the top crime podcasts of 2020—and it's not too late to experience the story for yourself. In the wake of the 7/7 bombings in London, investigative journalist Shiv Malik began researching a story for the BBC about how and why young British Asian men were becoming suicide bombers. But after his biggest source betrayed him, Malik's life suddenly and completely fell apart. He spent the next 15 years uncovering the truth about what happened. This riveting podcast is a thoughtful take on the true crime genre, and an example of how powerful good journalism can be.

Unraveled

In the first season of this popular murder mystery podcast, hosts Billy Jensen and Alexis Linkletter examine the decade-old unsolved case of the Long Island Serial Killer. In the upcoming second season, they turn their attention to one of the most notorious cyberstalkers in recent history. If you enjoy true crime stories that explore the reasons behind a crime, Unraveled is truly an unrivaled podcast.

The Generation Why Podcast

This long-running podcast premiered in 2012, and it's still one of the best murder mystery podcasts there is. Generation Why delivers a fantastic introduction to the world of true crime and unsolved mysteries. The hosts, good friends Aaron and Justin, discuss every kind of mystery out there, from cold cases to conspiracies. During each hour-long episode, they discuss the details of the case and then offer their own opinions and insights. It's an engaging listen that'll introduce you to dozens of mysteries you've probably never heard of.

The Riddle of Emmon Bodfish

The true crime podcast follows Paul Holes, the cold case investigator who helped identify the Golden State Killer, through one of the strangest investigations of his career. After studying the crime scene of the murder of Emmon Bodfish, Holes suspects that this case is no ordinary homicide. As he begins to build a case, each episode reveals another clue. This is an edge-of-your-seat story, full of twists and turns you'll never see coming. Holes uses his extensive knowledge of forensic science and criminal behavior to work the case piece by piece—all the way to its shocking conclusion.

Serial

A must-listen for fans of superb storytelling and investigative journalism, Serial is one of the top crime podcasts of all time. Each season tells one true story. Host Sarah Koenig follows the twists and turns through to the end, never knowing what's going to happen until it's actually happening. The seminal first season investigates the murder of Maryland high school student Hae Min Lee. The podcast's third and most recent season explores the American criminal justice system more broadly, looking at several cases all taking place in and around Cleveland, Ohio. Serial is top-notch longform nonfiction; every season is worth a listen.

The Messenger

This moving and prescient story about friendship, betrayal, terrorism, and the cost of fake news was one of the top crime podcasts of 2020—and it's not too late to experience the story for yourself. In the wake of the 7/7 bombings in London, investigative journalist Shiv Malik began researching a story for the BBC about how and why young British Asian men were becoming suicide bombers. But after his biggest source betrayed him, Malik's life suddenly and completely fell apart. He spent the next 15 years uncovering the truth about what happened. This riveting podcast is a thoughtful take on the true crime genre, and an example of how powerful good journalism can be.

Unraveled

In the first season of this popular murder mystery podcast, hosts Billy Jensen and Alexis Linkletter examine the decade-old unsolved case of the Long Island Serial Killer. In the upcoming second season, they turn their attention to one of the most notorious cyberstalkers in recent history. If you enjoy true crime stories that explore the reasons behind a crime, Unraveled is truly an unrivaled podcast.

The Generation Why Podcast

This long-running podcast premiered in 2012, and it's still one of the best murder mystery podcasts there is. Generation Why delivers a fantastic introduction to the world of true crime and unsolved mysteries. The hosts, good friends Aaron and Justin, discuss every kind of mystery out there, from cold cases to conspiracies. During each hour-long episode, they discuss the details of the case and then offer their own opinions and insights. It's an engaging listen that'll introduce you to dozens of mysteries you've probably never heard of.

 

The Best Eclectic Unsolved Mystery Podcasts

Highlights Mystery Theater

Mystery podcasts aren't just for adults! This Audible Original audio drama for kids encourages listeners (of all ages) to help solve the case. Mike and Cleo McClue are kid detectives trying to get to the bottom of all kinds of mysteries, from weird disappearances to bizarre sounds and a whole lot more. The siblings use their smarts, creativity, and teamwork to tackle a different mystery in each entertaining episode. Listening for the clues together is great fun for the whole family.

Astonishing Legends

The world is full of mysteries, old and new. Astonishing Legends is a podcast dedicated to celebrating, investigating, researching, and discussing those mysteries, no matter how strange or unbelievable. Hosts Scott Philbrook and Forrest Burgess delve into crop circles, Ouija boards, historical disappearances, and UFOs, among a wide range of mysterious phenomena. They're methodical and thorough too—most episodes last about two hours, but some are as long as four! Scott and Forrest examine these mysteries from every angle, leaving no stone unturned.

Hillbilly Horror Stories

Hosted by standup comedian Jerry Paulley and his wife, Tracy, Hillbilly Horror Stories blends humor with the paranormal for a podcast that'll satisfy comedy fans and die-hard ghost hunters alike. Jerry and Tracy discuss an eclectic mix of mysteries, eerie happenings, real stories behind horror movies, the occult, true crime, and more. While they offer plenty of opinions on strange happenings of all kinds, the hosts never take themselves too seriously, which makes this a refreshing and enjoyable listen.

Unexplained

What is reality, anyway? What's the difference between our experience of the world, and the world as it is? Where's the line between fact and fiction? Unexplained takes on those questions. Blending storytelling, history, and philosophy, host Richard MacLean Smith examines real life mysteries and unexplainable events for their insights into the answers to big questions about life and death, memory, myth, and belief.

Somewhere in the Skies

UFOs and alien encounters—that's the specialty of this podcast. But rather than scrutinize the particular details of such experiences, host Ryan Sprague focuses on the human stories behind them. He talks to people who have witnessed and/or experienced unexplained events, discussing not only what they saw, but also how they felt and how their lives have changed. There are plenty of great UFO podcasts out there; Somewhere in the Skies stands out for its thoughtful storytelling and human-centered approach.

Red Web

How much do you really know about the internet? We all use it every day, but that doesn't mean we know everything that's going on in all its shadowy corners. Red Web is a podcast about unsolved internet mysteries and strange cyber phenomena. Hosts Trevor Collins and Alfredo Diaz explore a mysterious ad that appears each year in an Arizona newspaper, viral songs, the Bermuda Triangle, and a whole lot more. Wondering what the Bermuda Triangle has to do with the internet? Well, tune in to find out!

Murder, Myth & Mystery

This podcast blends true crime with mysterious happenings in a unique format: each episode contains a story about a murder, a myth, and a mystery. (Yes, Murder, Myth & Mystery is true to its name.) It features an eclectic mix of mysterious stuff. You'll learn about myths and monsters from all over the world, unsolved murders from across time periods, and legends that might keep you up at night. Sara, Erik, and Mary, the three friends who get together to host the podcast, have a jovial, back-and-forth style that makes it feel like you're part of the conversation and possibilities.

Highlights Mystery Theater

Mystery podcasts aren't just for adults! This Audible Original audio drama for kids encourages listeners (of all ages) to help solve the case. Mike and Cleo McClue are kid detectives trying to get to the bottom of all kinds of mysteries, from weird disappearances to bizarre sounds and a whole lot more. The siblings use their smarts, creativity, and teamwork to tackle a different mystery in each entertaining episode. Listening for the clues together is great fun for the whole family.

Astonishing Legends

The world is full of mysteries, old and new. Astonishing Legends is a podcast dedicated to celebrating, investigating, researching, and discussing those mysteries, no matter how strange or unbelievable. Hosts Scott Philbrook and Forrest Burgess delve into crop circles, Ouija boards, historical disappearances, and UFOs, among a wide range of mysterious phenomena. They're methodical and thorough too—most episodes last about two hours, but some are as long as four! Scott and Forrest examine these mysteries from every angle, leaving no stone unturned.

Hillbilly Horror Stories

Hosted by standup comedian Jerry Paulley and his wife, Tracy, Hillbilly Horror Stories blends humor with the paranormal for a podcast that'll satisfy comedy fans and die-hard ghost hunters alike. Jerry and Tracy discuss an eclectic mix of mysteries, eerie happenings, real stories behind horror movies, the occult, true crime, and more. While they offer plenty of opinions on strange happenings of all kinds, the hosts never take themselves too seriously, which makes this a refreshing and enjoyable listen.

Unexplained

What is reality, anyway? What's the difference between our experience of the world, and the world as it is? Where's the line between fact and fiction? Unexplained takes on those questions. Blending storytelling, history, and philosophy, host Richard MacLean Smith examines real life mysteries and unexplainable events for their insights into the answers to big questions about life and death, memory, myth, and belief.

Somewhere in the Skies

UFOs and alien encounters—that's the specialty of this podcast. But rather than scrutinize the particular details of such experiences, host Ryan Sprague focuses on the human stories behind them. He talks to people who have witnessed and/or experienced unexplained events, discussing not only what they saw, but also how they felt and how their lives have changed. There are plenty of great UFO podcasts out there; Somewhere in the Skies stands out for its thoughtful storytelling and human-centered approach.

Red Web

How much do you really know about the internet? We all use it every day, but that doesn't mean we know everything that's going on in all its shadowy corners. Red Web is a podcast about unsolved internet mysteries and strange cyber phenomena. Hosts Trevor Collins and Alfredo Diaz explore a mysterious ad that appears each year in an Arizona newspaper, viral songs, the Bermuda Triangle, and a whole lot more. Wondering what the Bermuda Triangle has to do with the internet? Well, tune in to find out!

Murder, Myth & Mystery

This podcast blends true crime with mysterious happenings in a unique format: each episode contains a story about a murder, a myth, and a mystery. (Yes, Murder, Myth & Mystery is true to its name.) It features an eclectic mix of mysterious stuff. You'll learn about myths and monsters from all over the world, unsolved murders from across time periods, and legends that might keep you up at night. Sara, Erik, and Mary, the three friends who get together to host the podcast, have a jovial, back-and-forth style that makes it feel like you're part of the conversation and possibilities.

Up Next