When Samantha Schuster and Steven Mueller were courting, she loved the fact that they worked at the same restaurant because it meant they'd get to see each other more often. But ever since Steven broke her heart, having to run into him every day at work is like pouring salt into her wound. She knows she has to make a change as soon as possible. That's when she stumbles on a job listing at the local Amish newspaper, "The Buggy News". Immediately she thinks this could be her chance to start over.